I have lived in West Babylon for five years on and off, and bounced back and forth between a few good pizza places but never finding a favorite. Until tonight. OMG, my fiancé ordered a four cheese pizza that they said was a calzone, but they could make it in a pizza, it was literally the best slice of pizza I have ever had ever! And it was made well done as requested(which other pizza places just don’t seem to do when we ask them to) Wow! Found our new spot! T
Julie Ann Y.
Place rating: 5 Hicksville, NY
I just moved to West Babylon and I got a offer for a free pizza in the mail but pick up only. So I decided to call and add things to the order along with the free pizza and they where more than accommodating. My food arrived promptly and I was blown away by the quality and taste. This place is my go to for Italian. Love it. Love it. Love it. I highly recommend it!!!
A M.
Place rating: 3 Lindenhurst, NY
Very good regular slice. I don’t like my pizza too doughy or cheesy. It was thin, nice and lite. I had giving up on pizza in long island but I will be going back here. That chicken fiesta slice I bought though was gross. I could not even finish it. My girl friend liked the white slice and she is from Queens and said it reminded her of the neighborhood joints back there. 3 and half stars
Chris M.
Place rating: 2 West Babylon, NY
Great Pizza. Terrible Delivery service with cold food. My wife and I order from this pizzeria at least two times per month. The pizza is some of the best in the area. However at least half of the time, the delivery service can take upwards of 1 – 1.5 hours when we live only 10 minutes away. This is especially true on Fridays where we have yet to receive a hot pizza. The last straw was on a Monday, when it took more than an hour, then a follow up phone call for us to receive our lukewarm food. if you plan to eat here — pick it up and enjoy it hot.
Tom G.
Place rating: 3 New York, NY
Just bought a large cheese pie that was half pepperoni and mushroom with an order of their zeppoles. It was pretty expensive for $ 19 for the pie and around $ 5 for the half dozen zeppoles. The food was good. The pie was on the greasier side though. The zeppoles were lacking sugar. Nothing really stood out that would make this pizzeria above average based on their pizza and prices.
Donna C.
Place rating: 5 Massapequa, NY
Really great pizza. I can recommend because I had them, the barbeque and buffalo chicken pizzas, and the Sicilian and Neapolitan. Never had a bad slice. Awesome service too. The girls who serve you are so nice!
Jonathan L.
Place rating: 5 West Babylon, NY
My wife and I moved from Nassau to Suffolk last year. I love pizza and was having a hard time finding something decent in Babylon, until I came across Brunello’s. Now it’s my go to spot. I’ll usually switch it up every time I go there, but I think my wife(hi babe!) and I’s personal favorite is the Sicilian Pie. I’m there at least once every other week, and will probably continue to come here.
Kristina K.
Place rating: 4 West Babylon, NY
We’ve been searching for a pizza place that delivers and offers great tasting pizza consistently and I think we’ve found it at Brunellos! Pizza is cooked perfectly every time, and arrives hot and delivered by some of the nicest people. Why four stars? Because the knots are in need of some love. We’ve had some great ones and some not so great ones. Heroes are great though! A real crowd pleaser.
John L.
Place rating: 5 Port Jefferson Station, NY
Brunnello’s catered to our auto dealership Arnold Chevrolet saturday 11÷15÷14 and the food and service was excellent ! Better than any restaurants in the area. We were extremely pleased and would not hesitate to recommend and use them more in the future. We applaud you ! Thank you all so much again.
Mark S.
Place rating: 5 West Babylon, NY
finally a good pizza on little east neck. great flavor sauce, cheese, crust. did not have to drown it in garlic powder, oregano etc to get some taste like the cardboard flavored pizza at giovannis or crack dealing micceli brothers.
Tracy K.
Place rating: 4 Syosset, NY
While visiting a relative nearby I always check out the little places on this back block of Little East Neck Road. It’s like a small little Italy vibe here lol. Why the review for a small Pizza place… the Sicilian slice was my idea of worth coming back for. Super light extra crispy crust, tangy fresh tomatoes, really good — mozzarella not really browned but perfect flavor. When passing through Sunrise Hwy… go north onto Little East Neck Rd and on the right… I can vouch for the Sicilian … would detour again.
Samantha F.
Place rating: 4 West Babylon, NY
Good food nice local spot.
Bob G.
Place rating: 4 West Babylon, NY
the only pizza parlor on little east neck rd worth eating. the rest suck! finally a pizza worth eating since fontanas original owner retired!
Jizzy J.
Place rating: 1 West Babylon, NY
I am done with this place. I don’t like pizza when it sits a box too long. I live 2 minutes from Brunello’s. I call and leave immediately to pick it up. The pie is already sitting on top of stove in box. How is a pizza made fresh in 4 minutes? They make pies in advance. The customer calls and they just heat them up. When you get home you realize the pie is all dried up and nasty. I have been going here for years! NEVER again.
