Pie In the Sky Restaurant & Pizzeria

MYA member here– best pizza ever! Every friday we get sky pillows, fantastic!

Ordered from here for the first time tonight. Got 2 cheese steak sandwiches which were decent but nothing to write home about. Also ordered eggplant fries and after hanging up received a phone call back from them stating they were out of eggplant fries so we got an order of sweet potato fries which were burnt black and were not even close to edible. I have no idea why they were packaged with our order as they should have gone straight to the trash. When i called to complain, the young woman on the phone responded in a dismissive manner, stating «yup, sorry». Not a very good first impression. Mistakes happen, it’s how you handle them that matter. This place failed in an epic way. We will not be back.

Very kind. Gentlemen on the phone was very verbose and friendly. He helped give recommendations from the menu, as I was a first time customer. I got the sky pillows and a chicken caeser salad. Let’s start by saying the salad was fresh and the chicken was just as fresh in the salad. I recommend. The portion is generous. As for the sky pillows delectable, enjoyed everyone before I could even touch my salad. This was a good experience. Even the delivery guy was very kind. Im happy with this place.

Order a pepperoni pizza for delivery while watching the (terrible) Eagles game at 7pm on a Sunday. Ask for pineapples on half. I receive a call 10 minutes later to inform me that the place is out of pineapple, would I like something else? No biggie. Yes, please I would like mushrooms instead. «Oh, we’re out of mushrooms too.»
What? Total joke. Place sells pizza. It’s not very difficult to keep toppings stocked. Complete lack of caring. There are 2 grocery stores within 2 miles that sell both… pineapples and mushrooms. This will be the last time ordering from this «pizza place». The pizza’s not that different from other joints and there’s too much competition to care so little, IMO.
At this point I’m surprised they have cheese in the house.

Great cheesesteak, milk shakes, and sky pillows.
Nice little place to grab a bite. Downsides: all the little rms kiddos who park themselves in there for hours on end. Also, the past several times I’ve ordered by the slice, the pizza is obviously old and had been sitting out.

Worst pizza, worst stromboli and the portions for sides compared to the price is ridiculous.

Delish! Sky pillows are such a treat, and pizza is very good. The sandwiches are yummy.

Pie-​in-​the-​Sky generally means something that seems good but is not likely to be achieved. That was definitely not the case when I visited as my expectations were met and then some!
I showed up for an eat-​in lunch on a week day and these folks were really busy. I ordered a 7″ Mushroom Cheesesteak and fries and grabbed a bottle of soda from the cooler. My lunch cost me $ 10 and change.
The customer service here was excellent. The guy behind the counter asked me if I wanted a cup of ice for my bottled soda. There was a family there with small children and he offered to cut the pizza into smaller pieces for them. Are you kidding me! They didn’t ask, he offered!
My meal was out quickly. One bite of my cheesesteak and what a surprise, I could actually taste the cheese. That’s not always true with inferior sandwiches. Everyone’s taste in rolls is different. Here they are very very soft. Overall it was an excellent sandwich.
My fries were hot and crispy and once again I was surprised. I could actually taste potato instead of just fried slabs of carbs used for moving ketchup into your mouth!
If you decide to eat in this is a small place with seating for twenty something. The atmosphere is classic pizza joint.
My fellow Unilocalers say this is a four star place and I agree.

Amazing veggie burger! One of the best pizza places in Wayne! Prices are average for pizza places in the area. The menu has plenty of options for vegetarians which is nice for a change. There is also a lot of variety on the menu ranging from pizza to pasta to even Mexican food. Everything seemed fresh and tasted amazing. I definitely recommend stopping by for a bite to eat!

Pie in the Sky has improved greatly since Joe Orsatti took over several years ago and it has become a thriving business in downtown Wayne. Joe is friendly and very hard working. What more can he do to get his now thriving business better?
Well, for one thing, maybe he can listen to criticisms from his customers. When they complain that the pizza they got delivered is sometimes not the one they ordered (no pepperoni), or when customers complain about the quality of the food they bought… maybe he should listen. Because, you know, it never hurts… PLUS the customer sometimes just might have a valid complaint. If Joe doesn’t listen to them enough, Joe might find them walking down the block to New Wayne Pizza, even though their Mama Boss wrote the book on not listening to customer concerns.
A couple of weeks ago, I ordered two orders of fried chicken wings and fries (plus several other hoagies). When we brought them to our office, we found the wings and fries completely over-​cooked and dried out. We were very hungry so we ate one order, but after dinner, I called Joe to tell him of what happened, and he told me that the next time we ordered the wings, it would be on-​the-​house. We returned the order — even though Joe said we didn’t need to – but I wanted him to see it and taste it. Did he taste them? Well, uh…
Yesterday, I met Joe and I reminded him about the incident. Since I had been in the Fast Food business for several years, I thought he would appreciate my comments. (Having gone through the McDonald’s manager training program, I now understand the importance of getting complaints. The worst thing for a restaurant is to not get complaints, so if things start not doing well, you are shut off from an important avenue of customer feedback.) I have NEVER complained to Joe about… anything! Well, Joe disappointed me. He was defensive and claimed our complaint was out of line. The wings and fries looked fine to him, he said. Did he taste them? Well, uh…
I apologized profusely. And I certainly won’t be asking for a free order of wings and fries for the order we returned. I like Joe and wish him success. But if you order the wings and fries, make sure to tell them NOT to over-​cook them. Please!

Wow. That was amazing pizza. I’d post a pic but I are my 2 slices already! Wow great pizza. The gal who took my order was super sweet. All the food came just as ordered. Delivery gentleman was cute and very courteous. I wish I was in the area more often cause this place is amazing.

This place stinks. No idea why they get decent reviews (or why I keep giving them second chances because of it). This time I placed a delivery order and was told «45 minutes to an hour». An hour later I called and they said «he’s on his way there». Twenty minutes after that I called again and they said «he just left with your order». I said «call him and tell him to come back to the store, I don’t like being lied to». Don’t bother with PITS, just call New Wayne Pizza, they’re fast, friendly, and their food is better anyway!

Great Pizza! The customer service is also terrific, very friendly staff. And my kids (and I) couldn’t get enough of the sky pillows. We have eaten here many times, and highly recommend it.

Amazing!
Since the Orsatti family took over it has been a complete 360 turn for the better
Pizza is ridiculously great. Thin crust, super cheesy and a sweeter sauce (which I really love) they will make any combo you can think of but I really love the plain well done.
Cheesesteaks are out of this world. Fried onions and mushrooms chopped very fine and melted with the cheese to perfection.
The unsung heroes are really the sandwiches which include things like steak, broccoli rabe and excellent bread!
Sky pillows are a good treat but everything is made with love and from what I’ve seen no one puts more honesty and integrity into their food.

Veggie hoagie is the most disgusting thing I have ever taken a bite out of. Who wants to eat canned chopped black olives and canned mushrooms. Barf.

Pizza is good but the staff is pretty incompetent. I’ve ordered from there twice and both times they have messed up my order. The first time it happened I brought it to their attention and they were very good about it. Made me a new pizza and discounted my bill. The second time I didn’t feel like waiting around for a new pizza to be made so I just accepted it and will never go there again.

The pizza is very good. I opted for a couple of slices of pepperoni. Crust is thin. Slices are large. Fold the slice over and enjoy! I highly recommend if you’re in the area and in the mood for pizza. And by the way, the prices are very reasonable.

Really great if you go in, friendly people and great food. Just don’t ask for delivery. I waited over an hour and I live about 10 minutes away. They called an our into the wait to ask again what my, very simple, street name was that I had repeated twice on the phone.
This could have been a one time deal though and the food was great when it got here.

Good pizza, very casual environment. They deliver (not sure on distance or cost). Don’t expect a restaurant feel.

There are definitely not a lack of pizza places in Wayne, but after three years of trying nearly all of them I think I’ve settled on Pie in the Sky as my go-​to place.
The cheesesteaks here are very good and pizza is great. I read someone else saying Vic and Dean’s is better for cheesesteaks but personally I prefer Pie in the Sky’s (no offense against Vic and Dean’s they’re still very good too). The staff are always extremely friendly and prices are reasonable. There’s also a decent number of tables to sit at if you want to eat there instead of take out, which a few of the other nearby pizza places lack.

OMG. Pie In the Sky pizza tastes even better than I remember, having last tried it for the first time approx. 15 years ago when I was in middle school. I long thought their offerings would be more suitable for the adolescent me’s palate, but a pizza craving fortuitously lead me back.
I called in a slice of cheese 5 minutes before they closed. The owner was gracious, welcoming, and insisted it was no problem.
When I picked it up, the aromas exuding from the box were amazingly enticing. I sat in my car and opened the box for a sneak preview. I then proceeded to Hoover the entire slice. Two things to keep in mind: 1) I hardly ever eat the crust of a pizza, but this slice was perfectly cooked 2) I am very picky about pizza. Everything was perfect. The ratios of components were on point, the sauce and the cheese were amazing, and the thin crust had a crisp outer shell with a soft inner layer. I only wish I had gotten an entire pie so I could have more for later and to share with my BF.