I was cautious to try this place after reading reviews but I was happy with the pizza. I got a 4 cheese white pizza. I also got the fried rolled eggplant which was very good. If I had a complaint, it would be that they didn’t have nam many garlic knots it breadsticks.
Chuck C.
Place rating: 1 Nokomis, FL
It closed and has been renamed Italiano’s.
J C.
Place rating: 1 Venice, FL
We were long-time customers(back to original Buon Gusto days!) and got take out for the last time last night. I had printed a voucher from just prior to ordering dinner. I called in my order to Il Panificio(that’s how they answered the phone.), went to pick it up and was told that my voucher was not good, as they are now«the Pizza Company.» This is no way to treat loyal customers in a small community. We won’t be back and we’ll be sure to tell our friends.
Brady J.
Place rating: 1 Venice, FL
Ordered the goat cheese and arugula pizza. Worst pizza I have ever had. They forgot to put the pizza sauce on the pizza, there was nothing but puddles of grease, and they was hardly any goat cheese or arugula on it. Who does that? This is the second time I have had an issue with them. The first time we had subs which I will never get again. You could not bite into the bread. And what was on the bread was not correct. This place just needs a new owner or new staff. I don’t think it will be open too much longer.
Rachel T.
Place rating: 5 Venice, FL
These folks are great at what they do! They are a lunchtime staple for me and the girls at work since we are around the corner! Always friendly!
Emilee E.
Place rating: 2 Orlando, FL
Highly recommended by hotel front desk — then the delivery went to the wrong hotel, ok human error. Pizza arrives as the greasiest thing I’ve ever ate. I bit into it and I had a puddle appear on my plate. The cheese/garlic bread looked decent but it was even worse. Had to spit it out. I wanted to see the extent of the oil mess — I was able to WRINGOUT my bread. Something’s wrong with that picture. The lady who answered the phone there demanded a picture sent to her personal phone to prove it? She got a pic of the plate of grease and half eaten food. But we were told they couldn’t do anything until tomorrow. Good thing we leave then, right?
Joshua L.
Place rating: 5 Port Charlotte, FL
Very Good Pizza! I was home sick for some good New Jersey Pizza. Lucky for me my home sickness is over. I will definitely be back!