Sergio’s Restaurant & Bar

Lunch was great. Homemade pasta was great. Chicken Martini is a hit. Would recommend for lunch and dinner.

Came here with a group for a work event. Friendly staff, we were seated in a private room upstairs.
Did the 3 course prix fix, started with crab cake, which was OK, not great, but certainly not bad. They were tiny, so certainly not sharable, I want to say 2 – 3 tiny tiny crab cakes… maybe equivalent in total to ¹⁄₃ of a normal crab cake.
Main course I got the papparadelle with veal osso buco. The pappardelle was homemade according to their menu, but didn’t taste like it. It was even a little cold by the time it reached me too. The osso buco was OK, lacking flavor big time.
For dessert, I got vanilla ice cream, which is tough to complain about.
Overall, there are far better options within 5−10mins down the road in pleasantville.

Fantastic food & service. Hosted our father’s repast here today, and all of our guests raved about their dishes! All were flavorful & beautifully prepared, and Jim handled our event with an expertise unequaled elsewhere! Even the dessert platters were beyond expectations! We will definitely be back — still dreaming about the penne ala vodka:)

Attended a surprise 90^th birthday party here (not for me XD). The biggest issue was that the space was very small and it made mingling and greeting/​saying goodbyes quite difficult and uncomfortable. Once the waitstaff got going it was good service, but it took quite a long time before the bread baskets were even put on the table. I was already two glasses of wine in on an empty stomach. Yikes!
The salad was ok, the dressing was a bit harsh and there was too much of it. The lettuce they use is a bit bitter which is probably why they douse it in dressing. The penne alla vodka was delicious. Nothing bad to say about it. My chicken was forgettable. I don’t recall what it tasted like.

I can describe this restaurant in 3 words. Delicious, intimate restaurant. My new favorite. Valhalla is lucky to have this little gem. I’ve seen that building turn over so many times, but I think this restaurant is it. Not only is their menu impressive, I am dually impressed with their food. My favorite is the Pesto Gnocchi. I have an old family recipe for a creamy basil sauce that I grew up with and no one ever knew it or understand it (green spaghetti, we used to call it). I was in shock when I found it at this restaurant. My only complaint is that it is impossible to get a last minute reservation… and honestly that really can’t even be a complaint because there’s good reason they’re always booked! Just make sure you call ahead!

Love this restaurant! The food is great and the service is amazing. They treat their customers like family. That’s the result of a small well run family restaurant.

The lasagna is incredible. Don’t judge this book by its cover! If you are in the area you must have dinner here.

I came here tonight with my boyfriend for our anniversary & we both loved it ! From the minute we walked in we felt welcomed. The staff if very nice and friendly. The whole experience was excellent ! They’re drink and food menu had a lot to choose from which was nice, we got the calamari appetizer which was very tasty and delicious. I ordered the cheese ravioli and my boyfriend got filet mignon which we both thought we outstanding. we had a nice bottle of wine. Our server was very attentive. We will definitely come back !!! The flan dessert was to die for ! LOVEE the place !

Sergio’s is simply fantastic! The service is top-​notch and friendly. The food is amazing! I’ve eaten here several times and have never been disappointed. So glad to have this great place so close to home!

We went for Valentine’s Day had a reservation for about a week. Arrived with a few minutes to spare we were told they are cleaning out table please wait at the bar. I noticed several tables open while waiting for a table. There was no room at the bad at all. When they finally sat us it was at a table that was clean when we had arrived. The first server gave up menues one of which was not correct they had replaced all the regular pages with the valentines special when I asked those dinning with me if they had the same the answer was no. One waiter brought us drinks then disappeared to the bar to watch the game on tv. Finally someone else came over we said we were in a rush and she walked of. The crab cakes were so small and over priced. While serving the food the waitress hit me with my plate. We tried to waive the waitress down several times and even tho she looked at us she never came back. When reviewing the bill she over changed us significantly on a fixed menue meal which we didn’t ever have all parts of. Needless to say I will not be returning to Sergio’s any time soon. The first time I was there it was great. But I guess they were either overwhelmed or under prepared. Either way they lost a customer I can get better service at the local diner. Only bright side is most of the entries were good except one that a friend complained was over whelming cover with pepper. Choose wisely before dinning out. I hope management sees this and addresses the concerns before they loose more customers

Went on Valentine’s day.
They changed a lot on the menu.
I had scallops in a citrus sauce and they were pefect
Main course was tuna steak in ginger and orange sauce.
It was wonderful!
Cooked just as I had ordered. Sushi quality tuna without any imperfections.
And a good portion.
Service was excellent. They are very personable and make everyone welcome.

DON’T JUST DRIVE ON BY! Dining at Sergio’s is a great experience!
I came here for a Saturday afternoon lunch with my brother and other family members to celebrate a birthday. Sergio’s was selected as the venue by my mother — and probably wouldn’t have been my personal choice — but I came away very happy and impressed!
On Saturday afternoon at 2pm they were of course serving off of the lunch menu. There were many nice selections and the lunch prix fixe menu including appetizer, entrée, and tea of coffee for $ 11.95 (dessert with a $ 3 supplement) cannot be beat for value!
I had the delicious Caesar salad as did two other of my companions. The mixed greens salad with beets and apples was also reported as good as was the minestrone soup.
My entrée, «Chicken Martini» was a baked/​fried (?) chicken breast coated with a bit of Romano cheese. It had very nice flavor and the meat was juicy. It was accompanied by mashed potatoes and steamed veggies and which were also good. Two others had the chicken scarpariello which the kitchen graciously agreed to modify from using hot peppers to sweet pepper for the diners more sensitive palates. I love chicken scarp myself and have had it quite often elsewhere and this dish looked wonderful and was reported as very good. The usual potatoes that are included are thin sliced, more like potato chips, at Sergio’s and were an interesting update to the dish. My aunt had rigatoni with meat ragu and cream which she said was very good. My brother had penne vodka which he said was only «ok». He can be a tough (and sometimes inconsistent) food critic. In all the Fixed Price lunch included 9 entrée choices! Pasta and chicken dishes and one veal (veal Milanese) and one fish (filet of sole) dish. For value AND quality it just can’t be beat!
We did not partake in coffee or dessert since we were continuing the party back at the house where we planned to have dessert later in the afternoon.
Two in our party had glasses of wine and the pour was quite generous!
The service was very efficient and accommodating. One slight negative is that the room is on the small side (perhaps 12 – 14 tables, of which 4 or 5 were occupied during our lunch). There was one larger group of about 6 or 7 dining and I will say the room was fairly loud even on our visit! I can see how the room would get quite loud during dinner. Finally, since there are even fewer large tables which seat more than four, I would recommend calling ahead for a reservation!
Overall, the experience at Sergio’s is very nice, the food very good and the value excellent. While there are so many choice in Westchester, I am already looking forward to my next meal at Sergio’s!

What a find. Too bad it is so far from where we live. Loved all the appetizers, the homemade pasta and the great service.
Try the Veal Gorgonzola!

The food is an excellent twist on classic Italian which Mt Pleasant already has plenty of. Make sure you make a reservation though!

Had the eggplant rollitini, ossobuco and homade apple pie All was delicious! A great price too!

Food very nicely cooked and presented. Very professional staff. We lingered and talked to our friends with no pressure to leave. The maitre d’ was very personable and friendly. The crowd was couples and families. Not overly noisy. Wine and food were priced fairly. Pleasant environment. The only negative was that the air conditioning was too strong and we left because we were chilled.

Had price fix – was reasonable —app – dinner and dessert 22 $ — -app was great dinners (rigotoni) was very fillin and dessert was good also. comfortable –service was good —all the way around good experience – one negative carefull in parking lot —needs attention

Sergio’s goes above and beyond with your quality of food and service. Portion size is perfect. The entrees are so tasty and full of flavor. The price is on point. The atmosphere is class and very comfortable. The restaurant tends to full up quickly so be sure to make reservations!

I have to say this is a very good Italian restaurant-​close to home and the food is so fresh– they offer a prefix dinner menu for $ 21.95(3 COURSE DINNER) with great selections. Well worth the trip-​staff is very friendly and the cocktails are not so bad either

This place has great food, esp the salmon and the mussels appetizer; also it is a good choice as a business lunch. and excellent for a group of friends.