The ice creams really good. Priced right. Good quantity and quality. Good friendly employees.
Joe C.
Place rating: 5 Oklahoma City, OK
Stopped while just passing through. Had an apple pie and red raspberry waffle cone, and really enjoyed it. Too bad it was raining because they have a nice outdoor area with picnic tables. Maybe next time
Ed V.
Place rating: 3 Canton, OH
I like the cherry slush every year or so I would get the cherry slush. they are good enough for me to come back
Troy S.
Place rating: 4 Hilliard, OH
I was excited about a return to New Baltimore as it was my ice cream heaven as a teen. My return brought back fond memories of huge cones, blue moon ice cream, and mini-golf. What I realized was the ice cream wasn’t as flavorful as I remember especially since eating my Columbus ice cream places. The sizes are awesome and the value is 5 stars. They have kiddie cones for $ 1.25 and they come with a smiley face. Kid cones are $ 1.75 and actually perfect for adults without gluttonous ice cream intentions. The small is around $ 2 and not very small. The medium is perfect for a couple who likes to share or ice cream lovers. They have two larger sizes which seem ridiculous to have after seeing the Medium. Waffle cones cost around $.75 to a dollar more. My little one ordered vanilla and got banana but her taste couldn’t tell the difference luckily. I barely could taste the banana, as it tasted close to vanilla. I was expecting a rich taste and was disappointed. The cake batter was similar as I couldn’t determine when I switched from banana to cake batter. I did have an opportunity to taste the maple nut which I think was fantabulous. My brother loved the blue moon as well. All in all, this place has ok ice cream for a great price which I guess might be better than having great ice cream for almost ridiculous high prices. I like the picnic table nearby and the mini-golf next door.
Jan P.
Place rating: 2 Akron, OH
It’s a nice ride out to new Baltimore, but… The chocolate isn’t very chocolatey. You get a lot for your money, but again, not really worth the trip. I’ll stick with my Handel’s.
Esther G.
Place rating: 4 Canton, OH
Don’t blink as you drive through Uniontown or you’ll miss New Baltimore Ice Cream Co. It’s an unpretentious place with seriously good ice cream. The cones are huge and piled high. They feature flavors each day and also serve fast food type sandwiches, fries and onion rings. All homemade. Seating is outside at picnic tables. They are open only in warm weather. Prices are reasonable, service is quick and the staff is friendly and fun. They happily make doggie bowls for your canine companions.
Bill J.
Place rating: 4 Merritt Island, FL
10 flavors of homemade ice cream. Insanely large sundaes.
