Probably the best pizza i have had, always order when in the area(very fast delivery btw). Large with pepperoni and an 8pc hot wings. The quality is always consistent and will be sure to keep ordering if they keep it up!
Rob P.
Place rating: 3 Laurel, NY
Just had a couple slices, typically good ny/nj pizza. The guy at the table next to me was eating the meatballs & they looked & smelled fantastic. I also read some of the bad reviews that claimed the place was cold. The restaurant’s temperature was very comfortable. The bad reviews are over critical. I think if I order a dinner here I’ll have to add another star.
Steve T.
Place rating: 1 Fair Lawn, NJ
I have used this place for my lunch and dinner needs for the last few years. This evening I placed an order for a large pizza, a Mediterranean salad, French fries and a buffalo chicken sandwich. For starters, they were at my house with the food in like 20 min. I was shocked it was so soon. Being that I have grown up working in the restaurant business,(fresh) quality food in most cases takes at least 45 minutes to get delivered on a good day. Anyway, the result of this speedy process clearly showed in the food we ordered. My pizza pie had the cheese separate from the dough, my fries appeared they had been soaked in black oil the whole night and then just thrown into a to go container, and then my salads lettuce appeared at had been left out all day. I order from this place all the time. I didn’t want to call, but felt I needed to voice my concern. I spoke to Natalie. I let her know about the experience I had and shared with her that I probably will not be ordering from that place any longer. After telling the individual issues, she said«the lettuce is always refrigerator kept. The least of my concern. Her answer to the whole problem was«my food was prepared the way she sees all the food prepared on a normal basis. If that’s the case, your food is terrible. I for one will no longer consider this place for my lunch and dinner needs. Not just for the fact that the food wasn’t suburb, but for the simple fact that(a manager of the business) wasn’t there to address my concerns. Natalie should have showed a bit more concern for my needs. She failed to do that. The one thing I can say is, you lost a valuable customer who always recommended this place to friends and family. Good luck with the stiff completion in the area.
Leyla J.
Place rating: 2 Totowa, NJ
I only come here for the wings but just a warning, if you want to order anything from this place make sure you’re willing to wait around a year because they take forever, super slow service.
Noah S.
Place rating: 3 Great Neck, NY
A decent pizza place, not great. The place itself was old, run down, dark. It definitely needs a remodeling, at least. I do like the layout, a nice sit down room and a small room for quick eating. The menu isn’t too interesting, but it has all of the necessities. For a pizza place in New Jersey, though, I would expect something a little more audacious on the menu. But, this place was crowded, so they must have been doing something right. The way the restaurant operates is not good. The service wasn’t great, with workers talking to customers, not doing their job, etc. But, the food came out rather quickly and it was pretty good. We started off with a Caesar salad, which was pretty good, fresh, with a nice dressing. We had a steak and onion sandwich, which was a nice size portion. The steak was cooked well and the combination of flavors was quite nice from a pizza place. I had a chicken parm sandwich, but I got mine with vodka sauce. The chicken was tender and was a generous portion. The vodka sauce was drenched on there, but overall, it was a pretty interesting sandwich. This is a decent pizza place, but I might want to try something different next time.
Helpful Piglet A.
Place rating: 1 Newark, NJ
What a rip off! I ordered in and it took about 15 – 20 minutes for 1 slice of pizza and an Italian sandwich. I asked for American Cheese on my sandwich, and once I started eating it I noticed their was not any cheese on it. She told me I should have checked it before eating it. Now I have to check me food before eating it? Was putting American cheese on a sandwich so complicated? She then gave me back $ 0.50. I paid about $ 13 for an Italian sandwich that was only 6″ long. Crazy! I do not recommend this place and I will not be going to eat there again.
Catherine F.
Place rating: 4 Caldwell, NJ
Found out about sopranos about 2 years ago through work. We had ordered veggie pie. It was one of the best veggie pies I have eaten. Brought home a pie for my husband. He loved it as well. Our office moved and I didn’t have it quite as often. Luckily my husband now works very close. We have now switched to white veggie pie, which is even better. Try the white veggie pie. I guarantee you won’t be disappointed.
Marc L.
Place rating: 2 Sea Bright, NJ
It’s an ok pizza joint. I didn’t think it was as bad as some of the other reviewers have stated. I had a buffalo chicken slice and found that the tomato sauce was a bit sweet for my taste. It also didn’t have that buffalo hot sauce flavor to it that I really look forward to when eating buffalo wings. I could have used a bottle of red hot sauce to dump over my entire slice. Now — putting the hot sauce aspect of the slice aside — and the sweetness of the tomato sauce aside — the slice itself was ok. Nice consistency to it. And they appeared to have a good selection of slices to choose from. Cheese steak slice, Pasta Slice, Chicken Parm Slice, etc … You get the picture So would I come back here? No I wouldn’t, but it’s definitely wasn’t as bad as others are saying.
Nalu M.
Place rating: 5 Totowa, NJ
Love their buffalo chicken pizza and the Caesar salad pizza, salads and their garlic knots. I always call to place my orders and they usually done in no more than 15 minutes. The price is reasonable and the service is good.
Yesenia R.
Place rating: 3 Newark, NJ
When I am looking for a pizza fix I would definitely choose this place to other local pizzerias, but they are not the best around. If you visit in the mid-day the pizza is awesome, but the later in the day the more dry the pizza gets. They basically stop making pizza around 4pm and you have to settle for the usual, or order a full pie. There pasts is ok, nothing out of this world. The price is also a bit high for the place.
Mike M.
Place rating: 1 Hillsdale, NJ
I came here for lunch. It was so cold inside, the patrons were sitting at the tables with coats and hats on. I decided to leave rather than sit and eat in the cold.
Daniel D.
Place rating: 1 Pompton Lakes, NJ
Ordered for delivery. Unimpressed and will not be ordering again. Ordered over the phone. Person answering phone acted/sounded inconvenienced. Ordered 2 Buffalo Chx Sandwiches, a Side Salad, and an Arizona Iced Tea. Screwed up the order. Only got 1 sandwich. Called back. Asked how it was possible that this was a $ 17 lunch. Buffalo Chicken sandwich($ 7), Side Salad($ 5), and Arizona Iced Tea($ 2). It wasn’t. He explained it was anyway and added tax. Fine. Whatever. Starving. Sit down to eat. The side salad is a hand full of romaine, 2 slices of cucumber, ¼ a tomato, and a handful of olives. Not $ 5 worth. Buffalo Chicken Sandwich is grilled chicken, not really spicy/kinda like bbq sauce, on a wrap. Nothing else. Blue cheese on the side. Terrible. An $ 7 sandwich that costs $ 3 to make and that’s being generous. Iced tea was Arizona and it was in the smaller container than the 99c cans and it was $ 2. Half an hour later they come back with another sandwich. Should of been a wrap. This time they toss tomatoes and lettuce on it. Put it on a huge, hard, crusted roll. Marked up prices, half ass effort, worse food than I could make at a gas station grocery store.
Lorraine D.
Place rating: 4 Newark, NJ
I am a fan of Sopranos. I know a few people by name as well as they know mine. I have never had any problems with any of my orders. I’ve dine in and carried out. If you try a few of their different pizza’s you will not be disappointed.
Rhonda S.
Place rating: 2 Independence, MO
I found Sopranos with my Garmin. I really want some New York pizza. This didn’t remind me of New York. I walked in, and the slices of several pizza varieties were sitting out. I fact, I noticed the slices which I ordered, looked like they’d been sitting out, except what I ordered. There was a pizza with French fries of it… kind of disgusting looking. If I had turned on the next main road, I would’ve found Tonys pizza. They warmed up my slice of sausage and my broccoli Alfredo. The Alfredo was decent. But the sausage, meh, not so much. I found it difficult to order, cause I don’t think they understood me, or maybe the other way around. Anyway, it wasn’t like I thought pizza from New Jersey(40 minutes west of N Y C) would be. The eating area, was a typical hole in the wall, and there were people waiting for their order. I won’t be back. The pizza slices looked old… so I am still trying to figure out who, this side of N Y C has good pizza. This didn’t quite do it for me.
Peter B.
Place rating: 3 Little Neck, NY
Their penne vodka slice is pretty good, two of those will fill you up. The other slices are ok, but I like the fact that their buffalo chicken slice doesn’t have any blue cheese on it. Their chicken francese was good too, a nice amount and lots of lemon juice in it. The other half of the place is a restaurant, haven’t gone there yet, or you can just grab a slice and sit in the front or take out. The delivery service is a plus too. A good overall place to grab a slice of pizza or some pasta.
Julieanne 0.
Place rating: 1 Little Falls, NJ
Whoever takes the orders over the phone at this place is an idiot. We’ve given this place several attempts to get orders right and they mess up every time. The food isn’t all that great either.
Carmela D.
Place rating: 1 McKinney, TX
I’m not sure what all these other people are talking about or if they’ve ever had real good pizza and Italian food but this place sucks. The food is bland. The prices are a little over ambitious for what they serve you. And the service was horrible. There were a bunch of teenagers running the store when I was there. I went to clear my plate into the garbage can and the kid just watched me do it instead of saying«oh here, let me do that for you.» I would have expected that since he was just standing there with his arms crossed and BSing with the blonde girl behind the counter. The Sopranos would be disappointed that their name is being tarnished by a crappy place like this.
Jim B.
Place rating: 3 Somerset, NJ
Not bad but nothing special. Order at the counter and they will bring you your food if dining in. Buffet line at lunch. Counter help is friendly. Seating just a little dingy. Single flat screen tuned to the news. Extensive menu. They make good sandwiches.
Bryce A.
Place rating: 4 New York, NY
Grilled chicken sandwich with honey mustard is amazing! Great staff and very helpful.
Amanda P.
Place rating: 5 Boonton Township, NJ
This is a tucked away pizza gem. I went here with a coworker for a slice of pizza and have been faithfully returning ever since for my local pizza fix. They make an OUTOFTHISWORLD grandma pizza that we order all the time — thick pan square crust, fresh plum tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil. This is what I reccomend without question, the flavors are SPOT on! After some time we’ve reached out and ordered other items, including sandwiches and wraps that each really hit the mark as well. This is my new local italian food stop!