Pizagel’s Pizza & Bakery

This place just absolutely blew me away. I have lived in the proximity of Topeka for 20 years! I am not sure how long Pizagel’s has been there, but I can’t believe I haven’t tried it before now.
It is fantastic! Their pizza has the most amazing, perfect crust ever! The toppings are fresh! Their bakery items are incredible! I can’t wait to go back!

Every time we have gone it had been wonderful. Their hot wings are so good and our favorite is the Thai Chicken pizza!

My experience here was not too great. From the careless teenagers running the location to the not-​so-​great bagel sandwich with a café au lait that I ordered… None of it was memorable or something I’m looking forward to going back for.
I will say that I’ve had Pizagel’s bagels and cream cheese brought in for work events and I really did enjoy them — It’s just my dining experience was not good.
If I were to ever return, I’d try their pizza, which is what a lot of people tend to rave about.

You’ve got to try the taco pizza! Yummy! Doritos crumbled on the top! The crust is delicious and I really like the marinara sauce on the regular pizza. Glad you reopened after the fire!

I have only been here for the bakery and café, so I have no experience with their pizza (though I hear it’s pretty good). The bakery was pretty good, my husband loved the cronut. I got a coffee which was a little expensive, but good. It was definitely busy as it was a weekend morning — lots of families getting breakfast and people picking up donuts and bagels to go. The location itself is nothing special inside or out. The service was okay (seemed like mostly high school students running the place).

Although I mAy tend to rate places higher than others I try to base all ratings on food quality, service, and atmosphere. Service and food was great! Unique selection of food and desserts. Restaurant was nice. Would go back. The mini size pizza’s were perfect size and fresh (non processed) toppings!

Best pizza in Topeka. I went last night and got a personal mahrgherita pizza. It was only five dollars and I wasn’t expecting much since it was I usually go there for bagels and coffee.
I was shocked how good it was, they make the dough from scratch and the pizza was how I like it. A crunchy bubbly crust that’s light on sauce and cheese with just enough toppings. I wish I got the size up! I’ve had pizza all over town and most lean towards thick crusts and over cheesing/​topping. This was not that. The tomatoes on top were fresh and it tasted home made.
I’m so glad they reopened and I hope people go in at night for the pizza too. The customer service is always good and they run a very clean and smooth operation. My one suggestion would be to keep one TV on ESPNNews, it’ll make it easier for guys like me to just drop in and zone out.

Back after the re-​opening. Pizza just as good!
Just wish they could do something about that evening sun making most of the tables uncomfortable at dinner time with the glaring light.

Thank God this place is back open! I have been pizza depressed since they closed down after a fire last fall. I am giving them five stars even after we had a hiccup with our order, which I will write off as an error by very new staff (I think they only retained like 3 of their former staff members, so almost everyone working there is brand-​new), not to mention they were very quick to offer me a $ 15 credit on my next order. The problem was that they confused my order as to-​go and boxed up the pizzas, then could not locate them when we arrived to eat there. The pizzas were made, deliciously and correctly (and I have some strange order requests, too) and once they realized what was going on it was all good.
Even with new staff, the pizza tastes the same! Great! I love their Taco (I order without meat) and their Thai Chicken (I order with no chicken!) is excellent as well. Really, I love their cheese pizza, it’s not very expensive, has tons of cheese without being greasy, and is just plain good. They make everything there– no crust mix, no frozen crap, just good food. also, their kitchen is enclosed with big glass windows so you can see right in to verify the cleanliness of the place.
Another reviewer mentioned them not carrying alcohol, but they actually do have a modest selection of beer, wine and also margaritas.
Aside from the pizza, their sandwiches are great and their pastries are PHENOMENAL. You must go early to get a good pastry selection– don’t expect much to be left by dinner time. They cook them fresh, sell only that day and when they’re gone, they’re gone! They have unique coffees, but I have always found their coffee to be not quite strong enough to please me. That doesn’t stop me from ordering, but I don’t get the caffeine buzz that I would like.
Just go there. Oh, they have a drive-​through as well, which I have used many times– very convenient!

Weird that Topeka’s best pizza is from a place best known for bagels! But it’s true! Love the thin crust pizza, but the braided pan pizza is delicious too! For sandwiches, the tuna melt on an onion bagel is my personal favorite. Good place for groups. We just had lunch with friends today and they fit us in fine. They also have gluten free pizza that my daughter enjoys.