Atmosphere not very«Pub-ish» but what do you expect from a strip mall? Very good bangers and mash, chicken pot pie, and lamb lollipops. The«Shepard’s» pie(made with ground beef) was tasty but would have better served with lamb. To be proper, it should be called Cottage Pie if you don’t use lamb. Server was not very familiar with the menu. Did not know where fish was from for«fish and chips». By the way, it was frozen haddock. Did not try many menu items. Almost like the server was given a ticket book and hit the floor. She was nice though. I blame management. A restaurant here Jupiter 1 mile from the inlet — that doesn’t offer fresh local fish — is not someplace I will come back to eat fish from. And why charge $ 17.00 for«Shepard’s» pie that doesn’t even contain lamb?
Christy M.
Place rating: 5 Fort Lauderdale, FL
Had a fantastic meal at McCarthy’s. Food was great, perfect cocktails, great live music, and great service. Brought the kids and they loved their dinners and desserts. Excited to go back!
Ali T.
Place rating: 4 Stuart, FL
Came here, a local restaurant/bar on the recommendation of my neighbors. New location for McCarthy’s, with an excellent outcome. This location had two other restaurants that did not do well. Both closed shortly after opening, but Mc Carthy’s was packed on a Friday night and by the time we left, there was a crowd waiting outside, for a table. Our friend order the specialty, Shepard’s Pie which was a huge portion and delicious. Her husband ordered the fish tacos, an appetizer, which was large enough for dinner, and also a delicious choice. My husband and I ordered hamburgers which were very good, large but not thick. The roll and accompanied potatoes,(I had the roasted red skin choice) were very good also. With reasonable prices, and good food, it’s no wonder the place gets crowded! We will return to try some of the other menu items and their wide selection of beer.
