You Say When Yogurt Soho

The building & staff…
This place is very small and very cute. We rolled in about 5 minutes before they closed on a Saturday SoHo party time fun, but she was very polite. We made a little bit of a mess pouring our yogurt into the cups (she’d already cleaned), but she was still cool, so they get an A+ for service.
The food…
I wish I could give them a 5, but I just didn’t enjoy the yogurt. If you’re into fro yo, you’d probably like this. They have A LOT of flavor options and many toppings, but it’s a bit pricey.

I was craving yogurt during my visit home to Tampa so I begged my friend to stop in after our dinner and give this neighborhood shop a try. At first glance it looked like my favorite little place in Dallas (Yumi-​Liciuos) with a variety of yogurt flavors… until I realized after pouring a bowl of frozen goodness and walking over to the toppings bar that ALL the fresh fruit is missing. No blueberries, strawberries, kiwi or other ways to freshen up my yogurt. Hmm, looking at my watch (9:35) then at the open until 10pm signage and then at the girl working who was frantically pouring fruit into Tupperware and heading to the back fridge, I was left with only sweet candy toppings. Yogurt without fruit… Ugh. I said outloud «wish there was fruit» and was clearly ignored by the girl working there. I had the choice of walking out and embarrassing my friend or just grinning and bearing it (which I did). Waste of money. So in an empty store there was no «hello» greeting, no personal interaction of any kind, no offering of fruit which was sitting in closed Tupperware containers on the counter and no «thank you» after paying. Such s shame… sweet yogurt in such a sour environment. Find another place for your yogurt fix — this place is out of gas.

Run of the mill yogurt place, really. No special flavors in particular, but the toppings are great and you can have basically whatever kind of toppings you want on your yogurt. The service isn’t necessarily exceptional since it’s a basic froyo place, but I don’t really expect a lot if I’m pouring my own yogurt and putting on my own toppings.
I can’t speak to the smoothies, but they’ve got a wide variety of options for smoothie lovers. They just seemed a little expensive to me.

Happy hour 5 – 7 every night. Fill a cup for $ 5
Standard fill your cup yogurt place. The staff is young and friendly. The place is clean and bright. The flavors rotate and the toppings are well stocked.
Their happy hour is a great deal. I prefer the other yogurt place but this one will do in a pinch (or when I’m trying not to eat everything under the sun and walk out with a $ 10 cup of froyo).
Overall, I like this place. I have turned around and left before due to the parking situation at night. The plaza fills up quick with parking for nearby bars so if you’re trying to get your yogurt fix here on a Friday or Saturday night and you may be SOL.

Very good yougurt! Also, makes it better when you can go during their happy hour and get a $ 5 one.

I wish this were a Yogurtology, I like the actual yogurt better there but for the $ 5.00 Happy Hour, I’ll gladly hit up this You Say When!
Lots of toppings and about 8 flavors typically to choose from, the $ 5 deal from 5−7pm M-​F is a no brainer.

The yogurt here is fantastic and probably my favorite frozen yogurt. I pretty much crave the cookies and cream and peanut butter yogurt night and day. Im also a huge fan of their happy hour special where you can fill a cup as high as you like for $ 5.
The reason why I am giving 4 stars instead of 5 is because the people who work there are pretty flightly. Half of the time when I walk in there it is empty with no employee to be found. So I get my yogurt, stand by the register screaming, «HELLO? Customer here!» for several minutes while my yogurt melts.