Upper Crust Pizza & Italian Restaurant

My family LOVES this restaurant! I have traveled numerous places in the U.S. and can’t find pizza as good as theirs. We’ve also had them cater for us. Everyone enjoyed the food.

Always disappointed but this was their 3^rd and last chance. The pizza was fine. The chicken Parmesan was DRY. And my Caesar salad had the date of November 18 on it and we ordered on December 1^st.
Maybe eating in would be better but I’m not willing to give that a shot at this point.
It’s too bad, there seems to be potential.

Just want to thank Upper Crust Pizza for the past two weeks. We ordered 7 pizzas 5 Sicilian and 2 double cut for my sons party! Not only we’re the ready, they gave us plates to go with them! The girl who took my order helped me figure out how many I would need, we had exactly one whole pie left over which to me was a success! Then the following week I was suppose to host my mother in laws 60^th birthday and being 8 months pregnant and exhausted I called Upper Crust and place an order with them for a tray of chicken parm and penne vodka! Both were amazing!!! Also gave us extra sauce on the side and took the pressure off me! I will be using them again in December for a party! Just want to thank them again for a wonderful job!!! We order pizza here all the time, they have great food and really make sure to take care of there guests!!! Thanks Upper Crust Owners And Staff!!!

Food isnt that bad. Unfortunately when we 1^st moved down here in 2007 we were greeted w an inflated bill for 3 dinner take outs that the owner felt was what we needed for our dinner party. Can u say $ 130??? When I disputed «She» later learn was the owner, told me to come back in the AM when the owner would be in for a credit or adjustment as my card was already charged. Next day no dialogue w same women and was asked to leave. Her greed cost her 10 years of our family patronage.

We used Upper Crust for catering this weekend and we will definitely be using them again. Their prices are good and the food tasted great. The delivery person was also super helpful with getting things setup and making sure we had everything we needed.

Pizza rated 0, sauce is bad. Crust is too much dough! like a thin pizza with good sauce.

Basic –homestyle Italian food in the Pine Barrens of New Jersey.
The owners are very very generous to local schools and charities so that is a PLUS!
Hoagies/​pizza and main dishes are very good for the price.
The positive about this place is that the owner works tirelessly with the local community. In an area where there are few restaurants-​this is a Positive!
Garlic knots are bangin!
If you’re on Route 206 on the way to «the shore” – it’s worth a try!

Delivery time is awful!!! Literally live 10 minutes away and it takes them an hour or more to bring one pizza and it’s always ice cold.

Good quality food at reasonable prices. Good service for both take out and eat in.

Standard, decent, neighborhood pizza place/​italian restaurant.

This place is nostalgic for me. I’ve been coming here since Girl Scouts. I love the cheesesteaks and cannoli’s. My parents love the pasta dishes and they’re always big enough for left overs. It’s BYOB too. Worth a trip in.

Whether you dine in, take out, or get catering service, this Italian place is awesome! The chef does a great job in preparing down to earth food with homemade ingredients. We love our local family restaurants! The business owners are great! Oh, and also try their homemade potato chips!

In a small shopping center off 206. Decided to stop in a give them a try! They are BYOB… wish I would have know before we entered! The younger heavy set girl at the counter was rude! Thank goodness our waitress was just a doll and made up for it. They brought Italian breads and garlic knots when we sat down! I had the Chicken Italiano … Delish ! The portions were huge and the quality was there! My husband had a seafood dish, which he loved as well! We dined in and had the place to ourselves! I would have given 5 stars except for the counter girls attitude!

It shouldn’t be a surprise that New Jersey is home to a plethora of decent pizza joints. I’ve definitely been around the block and will say there has always been one worth a drive out to the «sticks» in Tabernacle. This place is one of those little gem restaurants you find jammed into a small shopping center that really isn’t much to look at from the outside.
Don’t be fooled. The interior is well decorated and has a homey feel with low lighting and soft music. And although they have a full Italian menu with authentic menu items, my «usual» there is a basic pie (pie (n.) — what a northerner calls a pizza.) with cheese, pepperoni, red onions, & green peppers– and it is done up phenomenally. The crust is crisp on the outside and soft/​chewy on the inside. They don’t skimp on the toppings either.
Lastly– what isn’t so basic. You know a true Italian restaurant when you see they have homemade stuffed squid on their menu. My family gets this around Christmas every year when they put on the Italian Christmas eve dinner. They have a good amount of additional homemade items such as this.
Overall, this is a well-​established restaurant. I could rant on about its location (not a fan), but I won’t. I will say that I would love to see these guys get into a larger commercial property, wherever its location, and run their business out of a more olive-​garden-​like setting (I use this example merely for reference purposes). I think they would do great with that.
In any case, this restaurant is definitely worthy of your attention.

Very good, but dont eat in. They leave the doors open, so bugs come in and bother you while you are having your meal. Great pizza. The waiters/​waitresses can be a little rude sometimes though. 2 stars.

Service was poor. Waitresses not very nice. Pizza did not have alot of cheese and too much sauce and the bottom was not cooked. But otherwise place is well airconditioned.
Only here once maybe better with a different pizzaman.

I was a volunteer at a great wine festival in NJ. UCP was one of the food vendors. They supplied the workers with some eats.
Not only were they friendly, but their pizza was pretty good too (even for NJ)!
I loved the long sausage and balls of meat.
The sauce was the final finishing touch!
I will give a 5^th star once I come again.