My Pizza

This was supposed to be a delectable buffalo chicken slice, only to find this darkened gelatinous piece of «mystery meat» that is definitely not dark meat and MOST DEFINITELY NOT white meat. I don’t even know how they have the nerve to sell this!!! Such a haphazard to sell uncooked and marred meat… Ever hear of Guillain Barre syndrome? Totally lost my appetite. Won’t give them my business ever again.

I should have known better not to eat in a place with a B rating on the outside but I was starving. Long story short there was a dead fly squished on my soda bottle I bought !!! All the girl at the counter offered was us to change for a new soda get the hell out !!! Ew

This pizza really lacks love. The crust is hard & the garlic knots are even harder. It was pretty disappointing especially since it’s so close by & would be so convenient for me.

I can’t give it one star because I do really like their penne vodka. I am, however, unhappy with their service. I’ve ordered three times and thrice my order has been messed up. The first time I ordered by phone and everything was okay except the side of penne had vodka sauce which was delicious. No biggie. The second time, I ordered online and clearly indicated that I wanted the side penne with vodka sauce. They sent the chicken entrée OVER the penne and then totally denied that my order had specified penne vodka. I had it in black and white in my email. This final time, my hero was wrong and the woman who answers the phone tried to lie to me and say she told us they didn’t have what we wanted. Clearly, their business plan includes sending whatever they want and hoping you don’t feel like sending it back.

hjust tried a philly cheese steak slice and this place has been christened my new favorite pizza place on SI — that’s saying a lot considering how many great pizzerias there are here! Plus they’re halal :)

Seriously the best damn pizza i have ever had. Buffalo chicken, bbq chicken, chicken alfredo and so much more to choose from. Its like a piece of heaven in your mouth. Service is always attentive and very affordable. I’ll never eat pizza elsewhere again. Customer for life.

Friendly guys here, but the pizza is always hit or miss.

The pizza is good, the indigenous people suck. Staff is awesome does try to help. They’re always on top they always get you whatever you need. Parking on street. If the crust was better I’d give 5 stars…

Really nice workers, great pizza. Their pizza isn’t salty which is awesome, and the eggplant roll is absolutely delicious. Their Sicilian slice is good however its a bit on the small side, I have gotten larger for the same price. However the prices are great regardless.

I swear they have the best eggplant parm heros in the area. Had my last one on 2003 and its still tasty as heck. Prices are super affordable. $ 6 for a whole!

I really enjoy their eggplant rolls. cooked fully through no doughy inside like other pizzerias.

Recently purchased a home in the area and doing a renovation, not having a fully functioning kitchen we’ve ordered from My Pizza quite a bit. We found their pizza and meatball heroes to be good and their eggplant rollatini entrée surprisingly very good.

Very nice workers.
Extra cheese pizza and totally was EXTRA cheese which I loved!
Order and picked up and it was not a long wait.
I know they offer pick up large pie for like $ 10 which you can’t go wrong with.
You can’t miss the sign its on a corner in one of the busiest intersections and by the highway, theres usually parking also.
Also sell desserts.

I’m giving this pizza shop four stars based solely on their unbelievably delicious… pizza. Plain slice, perfect mix of garlic/​cheese/​sauce and crunchy crust. Just what I needed after a long day of moving. If you find yourself traveling over the Verrazano bridge, go grab a slice.
The counter service, however, was awful and unpleasant. I ignored it and focused on the cheesy goodness in front of me.

Ordered a grilled chicken Ceasar salad, it was ok but hella small and expensive for the size. Bari’s Pizzeria or Brothers Pizzeria are a little further but have much better and bigger salads for the money, for the same price a My Pizza i get 2 – 3 times more salad and waaaaay more chicken! see the thing is that there are no other pizzeria’s in close proximity to My Pizza so the can get away with the higher prices due to lack of close competition. Come on guys it’s romaine lettuce a few strips of grilled chicken and some dressing on the side, a small for $ 9?! Not being cheap but I’ll rather wait for a further place to deliver or spend the gas and drive and get the better salad. As far as the pizza I wouldn’t know since I don’t eat pizza (no carb diet) but the specialty slices do look delicious

Not bad, not great. Average Pizzeria.

This place is hit or miss. I’ve only ordered delivery a few times when visiting friends who live on SI.
On a few occasions items were left out of the order, but were later delivered after we called to correct the omission.
The pizza is usually good. We’ve tried Alfredo, Sicilian, pepperoni, mushroom, and plain slices, as well as a multi-​topping pie. Again, pizza is generally good; not great or memorable. A couple of times slices have been burnt or tasted as if they’d sat around a while before reheating.
Spinach roll is good. Friends like the garlic knots.

It’s a nice place to grab a slice especially in the neighborhood. Food was delightful and love the cannolis!

Nothing too Special about this place. It’s one of the first pizza joints you’ll run into after crossing the Verrazano Bridge into Staten Island, right off of exit 13. The local neighborhood pizzeria.
Simple Décor. Huge Oven behind the counter with the glass display of specialty slices waiting to be picked. You know the huge specialty slices topped with crazy stuff like huge chunks of Buffalo Chicken or those crazy looking slices piled high with mad broccoli that are always just waiting there when you go into a local pizza joint. This place is no different. The specialty slices almost look like those plastic toy food pieces that come with the fake kitchen set. Yeah, the fake chicken and pizza plastic toys that you played with when your like in kindergarten. It’s for that reason I usually don’t pick up specialty slices from Mom & Pop pizza shops just cause you don’t know how long they’ve been waiting for you.
It was a whatever though day. The dude behind the counter was cool and was ready to take my order as soon I as I walked in.
«Lemme get that Chicken, Tomatoes and Onion Slice right there. You know what, lemme get a Plain Slice too»
«How much are the Garlic Knots?» … «Six for a Dolla Fifty? Yeah, I’ll take six of those as well»
Dude placed my order in the oven. Five minute wait. From the oven to a pizza box and I’m out the door.
Gadzooks! The Chicken Tomatoes and Onion Slice were warm at best. I’m used to biting into pizza and having my tongue burned and the top of my mouth scorched. Nothing worse than eating a cold slice of pizza as your driving away from the spot. It just came out the oven for goodness sake, why is my pizza cold? grumble grumble grumble
The crazy part is the pizza actually wasn’t bad. The cut up onions & tomatoes added a sweet kina flavor and the chicken chunks and tomato sauce were alright. But I really couldn’t enjoy it cause it was warm/​cold.
The Plain Slice was warm/​cold too, nothing really to write off. Blah Blah Blah
The Garlic Knots. Greasy little balls of dough. Not Tasty. Cold marinara sauce served with ‘em.
I really wasn’t expecting much and I didn’t get much. Definitely not «My Pizza» joint but I guess you can make it yours if you want.

2.5 stars.
Never been to Staten Island before, saw this pizza joint n was thinking «NYC style pizza!!!»
When I saw the pizza I stopped dead in my tracks n was about to pivot around n leave, but my sister was interested in the pizza. I was expecting typical NYC pizza — paper thin, crispy, big slices. What I saw was blocky thick, Ellio’s pizza style crust and small slices…
The only slice that looked like a typical slice was the plain cheese that was flat. which I was going to get but my sister urged me to go for a variety slice. the only thing that tempted me was the philly slice. healthy helping of chopped cheese steak meat w/​slices of green peppers completely covered in a thick layer of yellow american cheese sauce that cooled down… I was very skeptical but the taste was actually good. The meat was tasty and the crust was crispy and not thick tasting as I had thought. Not bad, was expecting worse. my stomach on the other hand…