Sweetie Bakery

Vanila maple bacon cupcake was kinda a let down cake was dry… my wife liked the salted caramel cupcake… Girl at the counter was nice

Pink everywhere! Sweets everywhere! Heaven on Earth!
Sweetie Bakery is soooo cute. The inside is reminiscent of a little old time soda shop, complete with shiny metal barstools. When you enter, your senses will be bombarded, in a good way. The first thing you’ll see (and the most important) is the display case of cupcakes. With flavors like vanilla maple bacon, double chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, salted caramel, and vanilla with strawberry, there is something for everyone. And at $ 2.50 a pop, super reasonable! YUMMO.
Staff is really nice and friendly (and the gal working even told us that for the best ice cream/​shakes, to head to Justine’s — love some honesty!).

They were excellent and made us a beautiful wedding cake. Looked lovely and tasted delicious ! Thank you Sweetie Bakery

So many pastries! Delightful diner-​style bakery with counter seating and any pastry your heart could desire. Definitely worth a visit (or two).

The berry crème bru lee was not very good at all. Crème bru lee is one of my all time favorite desserts and honestly I never met one I didn’t like… until I walked into Sweetie Bakery. The crème was fairly dry (how they managed that… I do not know) There was no crust on top, just a purplish syrup with wilted, sad berries in it. Not much flavor to be found. Sad, so much potential.

Great espresso & pastries.

There’s no missing this charming place with its bright pink and white colors, right on the main drag in downtown St. Michaels. This was just one of many places we walked in and out of on a lazy day trip across the bridge from Annapolis. The décor is bright and cheerful, as is the service. The treats we bought were delicious. The only thing that strikes me as a bit funny — the place is pretty big, and you walk in to buy something, and just about everything they have ready to go is in this small glass case in the front of the store, and the selection is not very big. I don’t know that this is a negative, it’s just FYI. Looking around inside, it looks like they probably do a pretty brisk business preparing cakes and such for special events, and selling single-​serving goodies across the counter may not be their biggest priority. Glad we stopped in though, and look forward to visiting again.

We stopped in this bakery to pick up some treats for my mom’s birthday. I thought the prices were pretty high, especially the $ 2.39 for a tiny bottle of water, but it’s a touristy town, so I didn’t complain. We bought several items, including cupcakes and a brownie. I specifically asked if the cupcake frosting was butter cream because I hate frosting made from Crisco. I was assured that it was butter cream.
Unfortunately, we waited until we got them home to try them. I don’t know what was used to make the frosting, but it tasted like motor oil. It was so nasty that I scraped it off and threw it away. I then spent five minutes scrubbing it off my fingers. It left an oil slick that wouldn’t come off! The cupcake itself was small, hard and dry. The brownie managed to taste both burnt and gooey.
I have tasted worse — in home economics class back in high school — but nowhere else.
I would not visit this place again, other than to get a refund.

Fabulous! Just days after they opened, I ordered a huge sheet cake to feed 50 people for my dad’s 70^th birthday party. It was beautiful, tasted amazing and was very reasonably priced. The flavor was black forest chocolate with a whip cream frosting and cherries in the middle that had been soaked in brandy (I think) and it was sooo good. People raved about it to me for weeks afterwards and I still think about those cherries sometimes!
Then again on new years, I went to party with a few pies from the shop and again they were amazing. Lemon meringue and a chocolate cream. Both made me want to lick the plate. None of that awful grocery store pie here folks. I can’t wait to go in again soon and try some other goodies on a cold yucky day!
As a local, I can’t say enough about the quality of the baked goods coming out of this shop. Please give them your support!

I came in here for the «sweet stuff» not the bread which is ultra fresh and made for The Big Pickle across the street as well as for take out by customers.
They have a variety of sweets but it seemed that they didn’t have a huge amount of anything in particular and a few things were mislabeled (the «espresso» cookie was actually chocolate chocolate chip. no hint of espresso.). Still they were mighty tasty.
Ambiance is ok. The display counter was half full and they have a soda fountain type counter for God Knows What? No one was «eating in» that I could tell.
Nice place. Quality stuff.

You can’t miss Sweetie Bakery walking down Talbot Street in St Michaels. It’s bright, fresh pink and white paint screamed «SUGAR» and attracted us like a magnet. And we were happy.
The place itself has a rather unique, fresh retro design that seems to blend a 1950s checker-​floored soda bar with a modern hip cupcakery you might find in any big American city. A surprisingly abundant amount of barstool seating extends around the perimeter of the store, brightly lit and inviting. Best of all, it was nice and warm inside, and the sugary creations are proudly displayed front and center behind a gleaming counter.
The decision what to sample wasn’t easy– because so many things looked so good. From the shiny glazed donuts and muffins to the chocolate mousse tarts and pies, we went chocolating tonight. The flaky, buttery crust balanced the delicate chocolate filling perfectly without too much sweetness. Which was ideal, because I was saving my sweet tooth for the amazing apple cider. I would definitely go there again just for the cider– thick, sweet and just what any cold day needs. I noticed they also had bagels, cookies, and even loafs of fresh bread, which we got to go. I think this place will become a mainstay for little St Michaels.

I’m sorry but this was my second time here and I was still disappointed. I got a cup of decaf coffee that just tasted strange to me. My husband had no complaints about his regular coffee but he wasn’t raving about it either. He also got a bagel with cream cheese that was OK. I got a chocolate chip cookie and was disappointed in it because it just didn’t taste like a chocolate chip cookie should to me. It was too chewy. The chocolate chips were plentiful and large but the cookie part was not like a Tollhouse. The service was good and the place is VERY clean.
I probably will not go back. If you want to give it a try go early because after lunch time the choices are few. The prices were average.