Goodfella’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

Great pizza. Quick & consistent service. We are lucky to have such a good pizzeria in Sour Lake.

Great pizza, and sandwiches! I’ve lived in this town my whole life, grew up eating goodfellas! The building may be old, but I have a lot of childhood memories there! From playing pacman all day and having birthday parties there!

I have been eating a Goodfella’s for at least 15 years. Their pizzas are pretty unbelievable. They use fresh ingredients and are always served piping hot. The white chicken pizza has a mixture if Alfredo sauce, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese as a tasty change from tomato sauce. All I can say is, «yum!»
They make the best muffaletta I have ever eaten. They make their olive dressing in house. The olives are cut into fine bits instead of the usual chunky olive dressing. The sandwiches are made fresh, not made in advanced and refrigerated. Goodfella’s does a brisk take out business, but I usually opt for their full service dining room. It is well worth the drive from Lumberton or Beaumont for some of the best Italian food in east Texas.

Great pizza! Takes them about 20 min to make, so call ahead whether it’s eat in or take out!