Cassano’s Pizza & Subs

After forty years of eating at the Sidney Cassanos, the worst pizza I ever remember receiving was still pretty damn good.
Fortunate to have this establishment in town over the decades!

This is my favorite pizza on the planet. Perhaps I love it so much because I grew up eating it, however, even my wife fell in love with Cassano’s pizza when she first had it. I try and order a pizza at least once every time I visit home. I have also tried the Troy branch and it was just not as good. It would be 5 stars but I do admit when I dine in often times the service is questionable. But when I am there with a beer and having my favorite pizza it doesnt really bother me.. .

It is ok… doesn’t make salad dressing, just packets. Won’t deliver during lunch… starts delivery at 4pm. This is very strange since businesses order in! Pretty good. Oh, don’t call the general number, it goes to a central order place that doesn’t take orders for this location???

One of the better Cassano’s chains and the best option for pizza in Sidney. Good sandwich options too though I normally stick with the pizza. Less is usually more with the toppings because of the thin crust. Service is normally good.

This place is so consistently frustrating! WHY, every time we come here do we stand at the designated «stand here to be seated» oh, and also «RIGHT here to pay» location — up to a couple minutes — and can make eye contact with as many as 6 different employees who make no acknowledgment of our presence?! I swear I’m not wearing an invisible suit, don’t look like the elephant person, am typically showered, arms aren’t crossed and am even likely wearing a smile (granted, I’m sure the degree of smile has diminished over the course of these s*ck visits).
The friendliness of the person telling us to «seat ourselves» was, I suppose, «friendly» if one considers the command didn’t include projectile spittle accompanying the attitude of frustration and impatience in our having chosen to dine in their establishment.
Although not necessary, as we knew what we wanted, the slow-​to-​arrive menus were in practice still probably a good idea.
Should fear and intimidation accompany ones placement of an order with their server? Well anyway. The drinks arrived before the pizza, so I guess that was good. The salad («appetizer») also arrived before the pizza so I guess having been able to track down another server (as ours seemed to be donning the invisible suit) to request said salad was also good. *Why am I SO demanding?! Who the h*ll else wants condiments such as salt and pepper and why does it irritate me to have to ask EVERY time?! I’m such a jerk!
Pizza finally came out. It was hot and tasted good. It was nice sitting on the patio. Almost equally nice was seeing the server show back up to check on our meal more than halfway through. Guess one never knows, maybe during the latter part of the meal we may have needed something, you know, say the first and only soda refill for a nearly empty cup?
In the end, our dripping-​with-​appreciation-​for-​our-​patronage server nearly simultaneously dropped the check (careful not to make any eye contact when thanking us for coming in) while practically making a 180 dash from the table. Maybe she was in a hurry to *greet* the next invisible guests.
Bottom line: In spite of the food nearly consistently tasting good, the service is nearly always as consistently very slow and very poor. What continues to bring us back is that it’s only one of two places to sit outdoors without hovering clouds of cigarette smoke. It’s also close. And I’m also always hopeful (or a glutton for punishment)…

Very good meatball sub and pasta! Meatball is fresh made, not frozen. Price is reasonable. Service is quick and good.

Cassano’s Pizza was brought in to our conference this past weekend. It was very good pizza and despite it being delivered it was still very fresh. Will stop to get a pizza here again next time Im in Ohio.

Best pizza ever! And breadsticks with marinara and cheese sauce nom nom

One of the best of the franchises!

Phenomenal pizza. Just plain phenomenal. This is one of the only Cassano’s this still use the old way of preparing the pizza with the old concrete ovens. The taste is obviously better. The décor of this restaurant is great too, vintage sports oriented. Has a patio, beer, great service. Cassano’s is the best pizza on earth, and this restaurant is the best Cassano’s for sure. Its a franchise, but believe it or not, the franchises are the only ones who make the pizzas the old delicious way.