Carlo’s Pizza

The abosolute best! Authentic Italian food, pizza & heros. I love this place! Eggplant parm hero well done. Chicken marsala specialty slice. Philly cheesesteak specialty slice. Regular slice. Penne ala vodka. Broccolli rabe.

I am not a big pizza person mostly due to the fact that I am lactose intolerant, but when I do splurge and get some pizza I always go here. I have not yet been disappointed. We go here at least once a week. My father is very picky when it comes to pizza and I have tried every place within 30 miles and then found this gem. He loves the Sicilian pizza. I am not a big fan of Sicilian pizza but it is pretty good. They have so many special team slices I never know which to choose. They were in a big display case right at the counter which will leave you drooling. My entire family loves this place which is a first. Nobody in my family likes the same place or the same food. The pizzas always perfectly cooked and has the perfect proportion of dough to sauce to cheese. If you are looking for a new pizza spot go here!!!

Great food. Tons of different slices to choose from! Best deep fried calzones ever! Meatballs, excellent
Rice balls, pinwheels, knots — everything is so good!

Love this place! The pizza is definitely the best around. Specialty slices are always awesome, as well as their dinner menu and pasta and chicken nights. My husband and I use this place as our go-​to for nights we want to order in! Wish the staff was a little more pleasant but can’t complain about the food!

Have never had anything I didn’t like from Carlo’s but my favorite is sausage pizza. They put SO much sausage on it. So delicious! I’m picky with pizza so takes a lot to make me happy. Have had heroes, a handful of items on the dinner menu… everything is good. Staff is always very friendly and accomodating.

Had regular slice and a Sicilian slice. Both were good.
They seemed to have a variety of specialty slices which I don’t eat but they looked good.
However, the service even for a Friday night was lacking. There ere about 8 ppl behind the counter and they were more interested in conversing amongst themselves then helping customers.

Carlo’s is our favorite place to go for dinner! My boyfriend is obsessed with the arribiatta! He will not eat it from anywhere else! The staff are all nice and hard working.

By far the best italian food in the area!!! No matter what I order from this place it rocks my taste buds. I’ve been in the pizza business for over 25 years and this place always has my mouth watering. No other place in the area comes close! Now… if they could get their employees to smile more and be a little more friendly they’d get 5 stars from me!

Good food. Only place around that has a deep dish bbq slice. Prices are a little above average but the environment is decent so it sort of evens out. Decent service, could be better.

Never complain about much specially about places I love, but went there the other day it was like teen night at the club behind the counter to much talking going on and very loud could barely here myself order, miss the old staff. But other then that the pizza and food is still very good.

This pizza is phenomenal!!! Treat yourself next time you are on the way to the Hamptons!!!

Stopped in for a couple of regular slices recently. The pizza was VERY good but the service is just horrible. No one says thank you, have a nice day or smiles. Whatever happened to making the customer feel like you appreciate their business. It’s not wonder anytime I drive past this place there is ALWAYS a help wanted sign in the window.

Updating to say I gave in and became a frequent customer here again haha. The pizza has gone back to being tasty and my favorite in the area. Also the garlic knots have been good lately, more like how they used to be.
I got 2 calzones and garlic knots the other night at like 1030 at night and even though it was late at night, everything was very good. I was very satisfied. Especially with the buffalo chicken calzone.

3.5
Pizza is pretty good here, plenty of seating to grab a slice. They have seperate dining room adjacent to takeout. Dined in once a year ago or so and thought it was okay but nothing memorable. Tried a stuffed garlic knot last time I was there. It was stuffed with red pepper, prosciutto, mozzerella and basil. It was good but, not the best I’ve had. I guess that would sum up most things I’ve tried. it is certainly good but, sad to say not the best.

I really like Carlo’s. My husband has been coming here for years and introduced me to the place when we started dating. There are always delicious options to choose and the counter folks are patient and friendly. We make it a point to get a slice or a square (Grandma’s!) when out on the Island.

the pizza is delicious. but today i ordered a chix parm dinner. GROSS! could not even eat it. was tempted to call them. but decided not too. there was just kids workin there. and i wasnt about to drive back there. how can u serve someone day old chicken? and it took a half hr to make. it was like i reheated leftover chicken. i guess i have to remember that it is just a pizza place. that has good pizza thats it