Nicky’s Pizza

Sheboygan, United States

3

Open now

11 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 920-457-6425
Website:
www.nickyspizza.com
Address:
1735 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan, WI, 53081
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Noise Level
Loud
Alcohol
Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
Free
Has TV
No
Dogs Allowed
No
Waiter Service
Yes
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Open now
Local time (Sheboygan) 21:28 Thursday, 17 July 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 12:00 am
Saturday 11:00 am – 12:00 am
Sunday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Pizza, Chicken, Mexican & More

History

Established in 1988.

Opened by Tom Pulos in 1988, this restaurant has had a tradition of making the finest thin-​crust pizzas in the county. Current owners Joelle & Margarito are dedicated to continuing this tradition.

Related places

Explore similar places:
220
ft
Faye’s Pizza
1821 Calumet Dr
1
mi
Papa John’s Pizza
2632 Calumet Dr
1
mi
The Upper Crust Pizza Pub
920 Michigan Ave
1
mi
Peabody’s Pizza Company
1123 N 8th St
1
mi
Time And A Half
2518 N 15th St
1
mi
Domino’s Pizza
1107 N 14th St

Nearby

Near this location:
140
ft
Macco’s Flooring Covering Center
1803 Calumet Dr
220
ft
Faye’s Pizza
1821 Calumet Dr
440
ft
Schulz’s Restaurant
1644 Calumet Dr
540
ft
Menzer Glass
1628 Calumet Dr
650
ft
St Paul Lutheran School
1819 N 13th St
650
ft
St Paul Christian Child Care & Pre-School
1819 N 13th St

11 reviews of Nicky’s Pizza

No registration required
Place rating: 2
Sheboygan, WI
Needs to speak better English if your answering phone and taking orders. Didn’t honor online deal on Unilocal
Place rating: 3
Cross Plains, WI
Had the pizza delivered to the Blue Harbor Resort. The pizza was very greasy and not cut into pieces. The flavor was good and the crust was cracker thin… very good for thin crust pizza.
Place rating: 5
Pound, WI
Fantastic pizza. Ordered delivery while staying at Blue Harbor, and we really enjoyed it. Fast, hot and perfect crust and loved the sausage. Garlic cheese bread with marina was also really good. Strongly recommend!
Place rating: 5
Santa Ana, CA
I ate here about a month ago and it was divine. I was pregnant and it was exactly what I needed!
Place rating: 1
Cecil, WI
This place needs to close! Burnt pizza, way over cooked wings… Seriously, ordered a piece of Carrot cake, it was dried out to the point, frosting was hard enough to break the fork they sent along ! Don’t order from this place, hope I don’t get sick !’ Yuk!!!
Place rating: 2
Vashon, WA
We ordered a pizza to go with thin crust extra packages of cheese and red pepper. When we opened the box no cheese, no pepper. The crust had no flavor, sauce was good sausage was good. Person taking the order needs help. Probably won’t call again mt
Place rating: 4
Las Vegas, NV
In the 90’s and early 00’s when the old owner (Pulos) was making pizza’s this was easily the best pizza in town, hands down. This is run by a former driver, and is comparable to the good olé days.
Place rating: 2
Sheboygan, WI
So the first time we got Nicky’s, it was really good. See prior 5 star review. The two times we’ve gotten it since, it wasn’t so good. It wasn’t very warm. Did not get extra sauce like I ordered (and I know what their extra sauce is supposed to be like based on the first time we ordered). We ordered a pizza (The Sheboygan) that is supposed to have extra cheese, but it had no more than my bro in law’s standard pizza. I prob won’t order from them again.
Place rating: 2
Manitowoc, WI
They’re delivery service was a not so great experience. Food was okay. We were staying at blue harbor so i specifically asked for plates, ranch for my zucchini, parmesan and recieved none of it. I called back and the girl that answered was rude and and asked if i wanted the driver to go back… duh, yes! They never came back or called. I dont know why blue harbor even has them in their rooms for local restaurants.
Place rating: 2
Chicago, IL
I personally didn’t like this pizza. Let me describe it… it was SUPER paper thin, and although I asked for it to be baked well, it still was very soggy when handling a slice. The slices weren’t cut well either, despite them being super thin, ironically. I had pull apart each with force only to realize the cutter didn’t go through all the way. The slices were also cut sloppy, some were super huge, some were super big. Lastly, I asked for my pizza with extra sauce (not knowing it would be super thin and coulnd’t support much of any ingredients on top). Extra sauce to them means glops of sauce on top of the cheese. That’s not extra sauce — everywhere else I order like this and they simple spread extra sauce on the bottom layer of the pizza, no need for balls of sauce on top of it.
The only pro — service was nice and friendly. We also ordered a chicken dinner — decent, nothing special.
Place rating: 5
Hinsdale, IL
Great thin crust pizza, excellent wings, very friendly staff & reasonable prices. I really liked this place and will definitely go back!