S. Prestano Bakery

Selden, United States

4.4

Closed now

8 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 631-698-2288
Address:
806 Middle a Country Rd, Selden, NY, 11784
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Delivery
No
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes

Today

Today 7:00 am – 7:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Selden) 05:31 Tuesday, 24 June 2025

Business hours

Monday 7:00 am – 7:00 pm
Tuesday 7:00 am – 7:00 pm
Wednesday 7:00 am – 7:00 pm
Thursday 7:00 am – 7:00 pm
Friday 7:00 am – 7:00 pm
Saturday 6:00 am – 8:00 pm
Sunday 6:00 am – 6:00 pm

Related places

You might also consider:
1
ft
B Prestano Bakery
806 Middle Country Rd
1
mi
Badolato’s Market
1315 Middle Country Rd Ste 3
1.9
mi
Land of Cakes
2
mi
Pond Plaza Bagels
2229 Rt 112
2.1
mi
Paisapan Bakery Cafe
385 Horseblock Rd
2.2
mi
Dunkin Donuts-Baskin Robins
626 Horseblock Rd

Nearby

Browse nearby places:
1
ft
B Prestano Bakery
806 Middle Country Rd
30
ft
Campus Breakfast Nook
810 Middle Country Rd
30
ft
Campus Heros
810 Middle Country Rd
40
ft
Corner Heroes
810 Middle Country Rd
70
ft
Nick’s Auto Body
802 Middle Country Rd
280
ft
NY Gyro & Grill
795 Middle Country Rd

8 reviews of S. Prestano Bakery

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Selden, NY
I love, love this bakery. The girls are always so nice. I usually go in on a Friday morning to pick up donuts to bring to work. the Boston crème are like hockey pucks, they are so heavy and delicious! The jelly… Oh my God! I refuse to eat lousy dunkin donuts garbage after knowing Prestano’s.
The only thing that absolutely kills me is my dad loved a good jelly donut. He passed away right after I moved to selden and before I knew about this place. I always feel bad that I never got to get him a jelly from here. He would have loved them.
Place rating: 5
Selden, NY
So many selections and the smell eminating from it is amazing… bought the cheesecake which is delish
Place rating: 5
Medford, NY
I started buying bread from here, and it is soooo delicious! I also tried the raisin cinnamon bread because it was on sale and that was phenomenal. Buttery and light, and sweet. Toast and put some butter on it. Delish!
Everything in this bakery always looks so good and fresh. I’d try everything but I’d be 500 lbs by the end of the year.
Place rating: 5
Selden, NY
This is the best Bakery! The almond horse shoes are amazing and they always have good prices.
Place rating: 4
New York, NY
Per my 06⁄2013 review of
= Parked behind this joint in one of the unmarked spots and ended up with a $ 3 raspberry crumb cake slice, which was tasty. A nice spot along MCR if you’re feening for something doughy.
Place rating: 5
Long Island, NY
It’s true there are big bakeries on Long Island that dwarf this place. If there are 8 people in this place, it’s crowded. But not one of those big bakeries capture the Brooklyn-​Italian bakery smells and feel like S. Prestano Bakery.
I could of went to a big store place like Wild by Nature or someone else’s Uncle and bought some «bread» for Christmas. Nah. I want bread that I had as a kid. I want a big loaf of seeded Italian bread to dip in my sauce for Christmas eve. The only place I know is my go to Italian place in Selden.
S.Prestano Bakery has all the typical Italian baked goods you need for Christmas: Breads, Grain Pies, Ricotta Pie, Biscotti, Cookies, you name it, its here!
I guess its just the smells, the family atmosphere and the great bakery products makes this my favorite area bakery.
6 stars
Place rating: 2
Seaford, NY
Disappointed, girls there were not friendly and I was charged for bread different prices, each day.
Place rating: 4
Centereach, NY
I have never been to a bakery that I would give 5 stars to because I feel I can always bake something better at home. With that said this place is awesome. I have been going to the Prestanos in Nesconset my entire life, that is the brother of the baker in Selden. I thought the Nesconset location had the best jelly donuts even until I went to selden, they are insane. Their brownies are crazy too, all different sweet and sticky flavors. I also bought a black forest cake from there one day and that I had no hopes for because bakery cakes are usually made to last a few days at least which to me ruins the cake but not this one, it was great. Best bakery around.