Pagliacci Pizza

We had a tasty crisp, freshly prepared Cesar, with homemade croutons, that made us hopeful, which made us hopeful for a good pizza too. Unfortunately, the crust simply doesn’t make the grade. Toppings and sauce fair. There are many better options in Seattle.

Utterly confused! Went to go pick up my pizzas, but they weren’t there!!! No longer ordering over the phone!!!

Those pizza masters are nothing but awesome! I love dining here and I’m worried I’m going to get chubby because I eat here so much. The margherita is my personal fav! The girl with the long brown ponytail was very charming at the counter. :D A little pricy but what can you expect from some of the most delicious pizza in the city. Stay beautiful Pagliacci!

Big fan of Pagliacci Pizza.
Probably my favorite pizza chain in the area. Good ingredients and tasty pizza. I don’t really think you could go wrong with what you order here.
Other notes –
The parking at this location is limited (so beware if you are going during peak times)
There is definitely seating but if you have a big group this probably would not be a great location
They do offer Pizza by the slice (although I’m not sure during what hours)
The place always looks clean and well managed

I get delivery from this location. They are always quick (within 45 minutes) and the pizza is always great. It can be inconsistent (i.e. sometimes more or less cooked, or the amount of toppings vary) but despite that it’s always delicious. To top it off their phone etiquette is really fantastic, clear, and straight to the point. In the past 5 years I’ve ordered a ton of pizza from them and they’ve never given me a reason to go someplace else.

Writing this in hopes someone sees it and makes a change. I wanted to like this place as the ingredients on the pizza were high quality and the pizza was cooked excellently.
Unfortunately the «dash of sea salt» on the margherita pizza was code for piles and piles of sea salt and the pizza wasn’t edible as it just tasted like salt, and usually I’m a person who likes salty things.
The caesar salad was nice and ended up being my dinner.

I thought that combing your hair with your fingers, then progressing to make pizza with those same unwashed fingers was a health code violation. Two diff pizza makers did this in a span of 10 minutes. I almost wanted to wait around just to see what other unsanitary events would occur. Two thumbs down.
Pizza was very greasy and lacked taste — bland.

i was looking for a place to order pizza from that wasn’t domino’s
enter pagliacci delivery service
i ordered a large hawaiian pizza for myself
the box it comes in is dope!!! i felt like i was in the jungle
eating the large by myself filled me with self loathing so next time i will order a medium or find a friend
oh yeah and the pizza tasted amazing and the toppings were fresh af

I’ve never had a bad pizza from here.
The fresher the better of course, but it arrives very hot every time

Yum! It is always tasty. I always order the spicy pepperoni (it is from Salumi) and I am never disappointed. You can go into this place and order by the slice or they deliver. The salads are also very very good.
It is a bit more spendy than some of the other big brand places, but the quality cannot compare.
Treat yo self. Ya know?

This location is always friendly and the place is spotless. Nice to be able to get just a slice as the pies are around $ 28.

Pagliacci is one of our favorite pizza joints in Seattle. The food is good, service is prompt and friendly, locations are convenient.
I have eaten pizza from Pagliacci about 10 times in the past 5 years. We have eaten in the restaurant, gotten carry-​out, and also had it catered for lunch at work. Each time the pizza had been consistently good and satisfying.
My favorite is the simple margarita. I have also enjoyed pepperoni, Hawaiian, Brooklyn bridge and chicken spinach. They have nice selection of pizza choices. I love the Pagliaccio salad! The lettuce, toppings and dressings are tossed together and has an amazing flavor! One of my faves.
The service is always super friendly. Last time I went on the website and placed my order online. Which made it super convenient. When I went in to get the pizzas, the worker even asked me if I would like to take a peek to make sure I like the pizza and confirm it is how I ordered it. Top notch, thank you to him for being so considerate!
I think that their pizza and crust is good, but not great. I have lived in Chicago for 4 years and my husband was born and raised there, so we are pretty picky with our pizzas. We were not blown away amazed compared some other pizza joints we have visited in the other cities; however we appreciate that Pagliacci is consistent, convenient, fresh, and friendly.
Will be back here again for yummy pizza goodness.

Same great pizza I get from their Stone Way location by my apartment but this spot is closer to work. I almost solely get the spicy chicken or Salumi spicy pepperoni. The last time I ordered from here they were out of the spicy pepperoni but didn’t realize it until right about when I got there to pick-​up my order. They explained the situation and gave a discount on my entire order (I switched over to the double pepperoni). The double pepperoni is a great pizza if you can’t get the spicier version.
This was also my first time trying one of their salads… it was HUGE. Tons of veggies and chicken. It was a really tasty salad. Luckily I didn’t fill up on the salad so I could demolish my pizza.
I’m a fan!

Here’s why I love Pagliacci: The summer heirloom tomato pizza is delicious (only available in the summer unfortunately); the Caesar salad rocks; the lasagne is tasty; the breadsticks are yummy; they are right up the street; even though they are right up the street, I still get delivery; they always deliver faster than they say they will; the delivery guys are always friendly.
Yes, they aren’t cheap. But… they have specials and they are worth it. Like upgrading from a small Caesar to a large for free.
Pagliacci rocks.

The pizza is good but way too expensive. The service is terrible. They have screwed up my order or completely forgotten about it for the last time. I’m over this place. And by the way, stop saying, «the g is silent.» It’s pretentious.

«Riddi, Pagliaccio!»
Pagliacci Pizza makes their pizzas fresh with fairly interesting topping combinations on their menu. They’ve even got a see-​through kitchen with authentic pizza dough spinners. Nice!
I’m also a fan of their Italian movie posters, but of American films. Who knew the «Sixth Sense» or «LOTR: The Fellowship of the Ring» was released in Italy? The only movie I wish they had was «The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly», which was originally an Italian flick.
If the dining area were a little bigger, the tables a little nicer, and the atmosphere a little busier, I would rate the ambiance more highly. As it is, 3.5÷5 stars. The «busy-​ness» of a restaurant is a funny thing: Too busy and you’ll feel cramped, but too empty and you’ll feel less comfortable. I wish some folks would have followed us over from the overly full Flying Squirrel Pizza Co., which we left due to the long wait.
We ordered the large Brooklyn Bridge pizza. On the downside, the wait was a little long for one pizza (more than 20 minutes), especially since there were more people working in the kitchen than there were guests in the dining area. Also, while fresh, I found their pizza to be a little greasy and their crust a little tough.
Overall, though, the food was tasty (⁴⁄₅ stars) and worth having again. So «Vesti la giubba» and come on down to Pagliacci’s!

My husband and I were sick of other pizza places and just really wanted a big tasty pizza with good cheese.
Pagliacci was recommended to me by two people so we went ahead and ordered the pepperoni and the original pizza. It was just what we wanted.

Good pizza, bit nothing outstanding. Delivery took longer than expected. Appreciate the little containers of pepper and cheese. Good choice of toppings. Crust os surprisingly good but the slices are fairly small. Good, but doesn’t totally stand out.

It is a chain, but if it is really good then who cares!!! The surprising crust is fresh and cooked perfectly everytime. It is so nice to see someone hand-​tossing dough like it should be done. The slices ready to go always seem fresh and they have a good place to people-​watch and comfortably hang out. We also appreciate the unique options (sardines, sea salt, etc) but also the traditional margarita whenever we are in the mood.
They also have fast delivery service if you are lazy.

As you walk in the door, the first thing you see is a display filled with pizzas, salads, and bread sticks all of which will immediately make your mouth water… which is probably why they have the glass panels covering everything up.
The very helpful person behind the pies will assist you in picking a couple slices, or pairing one up with a salad before you slide down the counter to the friendly cashier. This person will gladly take your money thus completing your order and sending you off in to the spacious dining area to enjoy your freshly made meal.
The pizzas here are thin crust, New York style pies and feature a good variety of toppings from classics like pepperoni to more locally flavored concoctions. My favorite thing to order is a slice of pepperoni along with a small ceasar salad which is just enough for a good meal that is filling yet I don’t walk out wanting to take a nap.
You can order by the slice or whole pies and there is also a selection of pastas available as well, but i have never ordered any of those so not sure how they rate.