Formaggio Restaurant & Pizzeria

Seaford, United States

4.4

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 516-541-1140
Website:
formaggiopizzeriaseaford.com
Address:
1240 Hicksville Rd, Seaford, NY, 11783
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
1.4 miSeaford
1.4 miMassapequa
1.8 miMassapequa Park
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Lunch, Dinner
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
Free
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
Yes
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Seaford) 02:42 Wednesday, 16 July 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Saturday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Sunday 12:00 pm – 8:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Formaggio specializes in high quality classsic italian cuisine and pizza. Dine in delivery or take out. Catering is only prepared fresh to order (no picking up cold food and reheating!)

Related places

Explore similar places:
890
ft
Phil’s Pizza
820 Hicksville Rd
1
mi
Pappalardo Pizza Cove
1079 Hicksville Rd
1
mi
Domino’s Pizza
608 Broadway
1
mi
Pulcinella Pizzeria & Restaurant
624 Broadway
1
mi
Mario’s Pizza & Restaurant
655 Broadway
1
mi
Tarallo’s Pizza
1700 Washington Ave

Nearby

Near this location:
80
ft
Munchies
1246 Hicksville Rd
80
ft
Chicken Holiday
1246 Hicksville Rd
80
ft
Munchies Chicken and Burgers
1246 Hicksville Rd
100
ft
Chicken’s Chicken
1246 Hicksville Rd
200
ft
U S A Skate
1276 Hicksville Rd
210
ft
Steve’s Express Cleaners
1232 Hicksville Road

20 reviews of Formaggio Restaurant & Pizzeria

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Queens, NY
Best pizza ever the sauce is great and the service is friendly ! I’ve been her twice with my sister and my 3 rambunctious kids we always get the cheese pie and some soft drinks !
Place rating: 3
Wantagh, NY
We ordered from here via Eat24 (for pickup) for the first time last week on my birthday. The high reviews made it seem like the best choice. The pizza was good, my kids and fiancé enjoyed it. I was extremely disappointed with the fried calamari and fried zucchini sticks. The fried calamari tentacles were so hard that I hurt myself when I first went to take a bite. The chicken francaise wasn’t bad, wasn’t one of the best I’ve had but I think it was decent. I really don’t understand why people recommend the chicken rollatini Marsala, it was some tiny pieces that seemed to have rough chicken and I really didn’t taste any ricotta cheese or anything. Garlic knots were okay. They do have zeppoles which is a great thing since a lot of places don’t offer that anymore. Overall, I think the food was okay but I don’t know if we would order from here again compared to other local pizza/​Italian places.
Place rating: 5
Merrick, NY
If you’ve never tried, or never heard of their boneless buffalo wings, you are really missing out. I was fortunate to discover them when I was in high school (over 10 years ago), and I haven’t stopped coming back since. The formaggio salad is always fresh and delicious. Hits the spot every time. Formaggio’s has a very loyal customer base. The same faces have been going in for years! Excellent food, great service, Definitely check it out
Place rating: 5
Massapequa, NY
Always order from here. Small Pizza Place with fine Restaurant Food. :)
Place rating: 4
Massapequa Park, NY
Went out for dinner in a Saturday night and really wanted a calzone. Thought we’d try a new place.
Was very glad we can here when we walked in. Decent amount of seating, cool décor, and music playing. Very impressed for a pizzeria.
Bread came out first with a garlic infused butter. The bread was warm and and butter was amazing. Not sure how they infused that much flavor into it.
We split a Caesar salad. Your standard Caesar.
We also split the gallant rollatini and a cheese calzone. The red sauce that came with both was very tasty. I was again impressed. Good ration of cheese in the calzone. Seemed small to me when it came out but I couldn’t even finish half.
The eggplant rollatini was also delicious baked with cheesy goodness on top in that excellent red sauce.
We decided next time we could just split the salad and calzone. We took a good chunk of the eggplant home. It also came with a side of pasta. I wasn’t mad I had leftovers to enjoy the next day tho!
Place rating: 5
Bethpage, NY
This is the best Italian food I’ve had. It’s just like going to grandmas to have her delicious food. I had catered food from here. I dealt with Charlie who was so helpful in deciding how much food I’d need. He actually tried saving me money. I’d say maybe I need a full tray. He advised me that a full tray would be to much food for the amount of people I was feeding.
The manicotti melted in my mouth. It was delicious. Chicken parm you didn’t need a knife to cut the chicken. Baked clams were the best I’ve had. There were more clams then the stuffing. Delicious. The antipasto, was fresh, from the lettuce to the sliced fresh mozzarella. The meatballs have flavor. Not plain chop meat like some restaurants have. My kids who were raised in an Italian family who’s grandma, was the best Italian cook alongside aunts who came from Italy, loved the food. Thank you Charlie for making my dinner go over so well !!!
Place rating: 2
Seaford, NY
The pizza was great. I would definitely return if it weren’t for the poor attitude of the employees that were on staff today. Very unwelcoming and rude.
Place rating: 5
Peoria, AZ
Yummy! I wasn’t sure what to expect from this unassuming restaurant with it’s tiny, empty dining area. But as soon as the food hit my tongue, I knew Id found my Italian spot! The pizza was perfect. The sauce is made from three different tomatoes and the flavors are all there — sweet and savory.
My mom and I split penne vodka. The portion was generous and the sauce was made on the spot.
The hot sesame bread with special garlic and herb butter were also bomb!
One of the owners (2 bros) was nice enough to chat with us for five minutes as we raved over his cuisine. I’ll be back! Most likely tomorrow!
Place rating: 5
Seaford, NY
I’ve been going to this place for years and let me tell you it is THE BEST! It’s situated in a small strip mall & has a small, old school Italian feel inside but don’t let its size fool you. Not only is the regular pizza to die for but the entrée’s are just as amazing. Lots of different meal choices that come with pasta and a salad. Everything tastes homemade and fresh and their sauces are always on point. Portions are big and prices are decent. Considering Long Island is full of pizza places they have a lot of competition, but this place is always the winner in my family’s book. Definitely a must try!
Place rating: 5
Greentown, PA
When I moved to the neighborhood 8 years ago I tried every pizzeria around, but none of them could hold a candle to formaggios!
The regular pie is usually the item I judge the place by and yes this slice fits the bill. The sauce is delicious along with the crust and cheese all fresh and perfectly proportioned to make this the best slice around!
Grandma pie is my next favorite and then comes Sicilian they are all so good! My family looks forward to coming to my house for events when we order from formaggios! The restaurants food is also very delicious I have nothing negative to say! Awesome food keep it up!
Place rating: 5
Levittown, NY
I have only had the pizza and it is great! The regular slice and white and vodka slice are my favorite. Highly recommend
Place rating: 5
Queens, NY
This is our go to delivery Italian food spot!!! Hands down the best Italian food around for delivery. Last night I picked up a regular pie and 4 slices of Sicilian.
OMG!!! The pizza is better than the Kitchen cooked food. Hands down the best pie on Long Island. We LOVE Formaggio!!!
Place rating: 5
Merrick, NY
Great pizza.
If your looking for a tasty slice drop in. Charley cheese is always pumpin out fresh pies. Friendly. Clean. Great for the whole family.
Place rating: 4
Midtown West, Manhattan, NY
Always on the look out for a good pizza place, and I found this one on Unilocal.Solid plain pie, and the margarita specialty pie is good as any. Looking forward to trying the grandma. Will update further
Place rating: 2
Massapequa, NY
Actually, the food isn’t bad. Occasionally, the sauce had that metallic can taste… But all in all, we liked the food.
I stopped ordering after a bad experience with delivery. After waiting for 30 plus extra minutes for an order, I called to see why… And was met with a nasty attitude. Frustrated, I drove to the place to see why I was dealt with in that tone… Only to be met with the same confrontational attitude.
After ordering weekly for years, I stopped that day.
I’ve found another place that appreciates my business, and told most of my neighbors to switch..
Place rating: 5
Freeport, NY
I have been going here since 2001. I love this place. They are friendly, accommodating (I am a picky eater) And most of all their food is awesome! I have moved out of the area and will still go their because of how great this place is. I have never had any issues with them and never will.
Place rating: 5
Massapequa, NY
This is not only the best pizza in town but quite possibly the best Italian around. Cozy dining area with quick and attentive wait service. Some menu items that are must try’s are the chicken Marsala, chicken parm, eggplant rollatini, baked ziti and not to forget the side of boneless buffalo wings that are quite delicious! Oh and the bread with the special butter is amazing!
Place rating: 5
Brandon, FL
The most underrated pizzeria around. It is located in a little strip in the corner but has been making delicious pizza for many years now, I always go for the Sicilian. For dinner the penne alla vodka is killer and would recommend it to anyone. I cannot wait for the next I’ve that I am in town to grab a bite to eat at perfect little pizzeria
Place rating: 4
Washington, DC
I’ve eaten here for years and have always had delicious and high quality food.
Place rating: 3
Syosset, NY
This is in small shopping strip center somewhat quiet, with a few unrented stores. Any Unilocaler’s likely zipped by it. lol Inside, nicely updated it has the look and feel of a well kept, small pizza place, nice enough to have a relaxing lunch in. Casual but nice. Massapequa is big Pizza town and Formaggio is one of many well known places just diagnal from the infamous Phils, and along Rt 107/​Hicksville Rd., at least 6 places, and just down Jerusalum Ave to Broadway are a million more! but they seem to have the fans to keep them all busy.
The sicilian looks best here. I tried the plain slice, light and fresh was good.