All Good Things

We loved the original store concept with classic rock and roll music vibe/​décor and the Yankee game on the television. Mostly gone.
Stopped by recently and it appears new ownership has taken over. Purchased 2 small ice creams in a cup, with one topping, and a small bag of chocolate. It came to $ 16.50! The candy in the bag was stale. Tasted months old. The ice cream was good but no way in hell worth $ 6 for a small cup. Outrageous. Also, they’re staying open during construction which is senseless. Even the pinball machine went up in price? Cmon.
Extra star for nostalgia but we informed the family that we are changing our post dinner dessert stop. What a shame because we visit Italian Village once a week and we live down the road.

The ice cream was average and the prices were outrageous. Crazy-​$ 9.50 for two small cones. Baskin Robbins has nothing to worry about.
Shame on me for cheating on my diet.

This is the best place for camp visiting day treats. Last year I bought a pizza sized chocolate chip candy topped cookie. I am brining another this year. It was a huge hit.
Still the best tart yogurt.

Having 2 little kids and a husband with a sweet tooth this place is like heaven on earth. Delicious ice cream, tons of different candies and fat free frozen yogurt are reason enough to go to All Good Things! The staff is very nice and the Owner Brian always greets my kids with hellos and hi fives. Looking forward to the warm weather so we can spend even more time at our favorite ice cream /​candy store!

really great ice cream with pinball machine in store

After enjoying several outings to All Good Things last spring when we were visiting from Los Angeles, we contacted them to deliver an ice cream cake for our daughter and son-in-law’s anniversary. Not only was the cake beautiful and super delicious, but it arrived just when Ryan said it would. Thank you Ryan for helping to make their anniversary celebration so special.

Meh. So the way I see it there’s E&B and Ben and Jerry’s. I was super excited to be trying the ice cream but it was a super letdown and I’m not sure if that’s due to this particular location or just not liking the flavor. The ice cream was way too soft, there’s soft enough to scoop and then there’s melting. This was not the middle of a heat wave by the way. So I wasn’t necessarily understanding the textural problem. The caramel moose tracks were pretty good (except for melting almost immediately) but everything we tried that was vanilla based (vanilla with yellow cake and red velvet for example) tasted like stale Breyer’s. The little one picked mint chocolate chip, carefully avoiding grasshopper pie so as to not eat ice cream loaded with gluten only to realize almost at the end of the cup that mint chocolate chip included crushed up Oreos. Not a minor gripe, it should indeed be stated in the description of the ice cream. My mom got banana and maybe if it was called bananas foster or something it would have been great but as it was if you’re expecting a pure banana flavored ice cream and get bananas loaded with cinnamon it will be an altogether unpleasant experience. Again, list the actual flavors. Then she was told that’s just how they make their banana ice cream. Fine, then change the name to banana cinnamon.
There were bonus points for sauces being on the table in squeeze bottles. They also had my favorite chewy candy ever which I never remember the name of. That’s basically where the two stars come in. The vibe of the place is slightly strange like Woodstock threw up on it. I get the whole idea, but I haven’t listened to Phish in a while and I was ok with that. The counter help discussing how annoyed they were to be there and loudly talking about when they can leave and how they planned on closing early if they didn’t see more customers within the next few minutes. Good to know if you ever planned on making a late night ice cream dash. You’re better off going to the supermarket for Breyer’s or Turkey Hill (no not even Ben & Jerry’s) or just go to that other chain place as it’s about equal. Don’t go out of your way.

Such a quaint fun place! Lots of candy and a nice selection of frozen yogurts and ice cream. They also have a photo booth which adds to the fun. Seems like a good neighborhood store. A bit pricey, but will definitely return. Raspberry ice cream was the best!

THIS IS A REVIEW FOR THE ICE CREAM ONLY… AS I HAVE NOT TRIED THE FROZEN YOGURT YET.
When I used to live in New Rochelle, I would go to JCC for a swim and a shvitz and then drive across the street to enjoy a delicious Yuppie Roll from the old Italian Village. For dessert, I would usually go to Last Licks for a chocolate cone. While the people were nice and the sports stuff was cool, the ice cream was never that great… actually I thought 31 Flavors had better ice cream and that is not saying much.
Fast-​forward 10 – 15 years… living in Manhattan you seldom hear about restaurants, especially ice cream shops in Westchester… but after hearing some buzz (partly from my mom who lives in New Rochelle) about this relatively new ice cream shop that opened up at the old Last Licks location, I wanted to try it. My impressions are as follows:
It is like they took Last Licks and transformed it into something totally different, and yes, much much tastier. Gone is the mass produced stuff that Last Licks called ice cream. Happy to report that it has been replaced by super premium mounds of deliciousness… finally, not some gimmicky sports shop, but a chill/​heady place to go and get INCREDIBLE ice cream. They get their cream from a small outfit out of Massachusetts called Emack & Bolio’s (the original Ben and Jerry’s concept). Going to college just outside of Boston, I had the good fortune of being exposed to E&B’s back in the mid 90’s.
Living in Manhattan and being a fat ass, I regularly sample some of the best artisan ice cream and gelato around, so I know what I’m talking about. Actually, recently there was an article in the NY Times basically revealing the not so well guarded secret that commercial ice cream is the dumping ground of the dairy industry. I won’t eat crap ice cream anymore… life is too short. If you care about what you’re putting into your body, Emack & Bolio (they have a Soho location too) is really a step above 99% of the mass produced commercially available ice cream on the market.
Specifically, the Purple Cow ice cream is nothing short of spectacular. I also love the Darkness on the Edge of Town Chocolate. It is off the menu, so you have to special request it, and from what I understand they don’t have it that often, but it could be the best chocolate ice-​cream I have ever tasted. I hope they make it a regular menu item. I have now been there several times, and can vouch for the cookies and cream too. Would I get it again? YES. Oh, and I am told their birthday cakes are also dynamite (I have not tried one yet)…will do an update for the cakes. Granted, Carvel’s Cookie Puss will always have a warm place in my heart, but in truth, that is some schwag cake containing rBST cream! I rather pay a couple extra bucks and know I’m getting cream from healthy cows not injected with tons of hormones.
Now if only Italian Village would bring back the Yuppie Roll. And if you’re in the city jonesing the best gelato anywhere, try the DARK chocolate @ il laboratorio del gelato on Ludlow.

Decent ice cream for a reasonable price. The workers are understanding of your desire to sample different flavors of ice cream. They will also hook you up with toppings, which is always great.
The last time I was here, they had a bunch of seats from the old Yankees stadium, which I thought was pretty cool.
Note: I am not a Yankees fan !

Ice Cream, frozen yogurt and candy fill this store where ‘Last Licks’ used to be.
They feature smooth and creamy Emack & Bolio’s ice cream and the the Cosmic Crunch is out of this world!
I love the décor, the helpful staff and I’m so glad this didn’t end up being another empty store front!
Job well done! I’ll be back!