Stefanina’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had this place is incredible. Some of the best pizza in the country.

The wife and I were pretty disappointed with this place tonight after trying it for the first time. We had a simple order consisting of one pizza and one appetizer that I picked up. I wish I would have looked at the food before I left. Our pizza was burnt and the appetizer was cold. The pizza was also missing toppings and had little flavor. Needless to say, we will continue to drive past this place to a different establishment when we order out.

I’m a college student who loves pizza just like anyone else. As you know St. Louis is known for their «cracker like» pizza with provel cheese. Imo’s is what comes to mind to most people when St. Louis style pizza is brought up in a conversation.
However, Stefanina’s is my favorite by far. Stefanina’s’ has St. Louis style pizza. I got a half Pepperoni/​Sausage Xtra large that fed me and my parents. It was gooey with provel cheese while the dough has a magical texture. I also fell in love with their hot wings, they were juicy and not dry. It was a good pre game for the main course.
The atmosphere at Stefanina’s is very homey. It’s small but that’s what I love about it. There’s plenty of room between tables for privacy so a date here is not a bad idea! There are three big televisions and will be put on whatever channel you desire if you wanted to watch sports… Etc.
The service was phenomenal. Quick service to get your food. Everyone is very friendly overall. This is my FAVORITE pizza place in St. Louis and will continue to eat here! 5 stars.

If you love st louis style pizza then you have to go there. They have the best st louis style pizza and they make their thin crust there so it’s fresher tasting. Compared to other offering similar items they have a larger menu and better bag for you buck plus they just taste the best. They are family owned like most st louis style reaturants you get the family feel or have it delivered to your home in 30 mins. They are by far my #1 choice in st peters and st louis.

Nice little neighborhood place. Good house salad and St Louis style pizza — much better than Imo’s, in our opinion. A real favorite with our teenagers. Service is always fast and friendly. Great for a quick bite.

I get the meat lovers every time and it’s just amazing. I love my bacon crispy and my cheese is always perfect. They use the classic St. Louis cheese: Provel, which I recommend to anyone who hasn’t tried it as it was designed to go on pizza!

Received a recommendation to go here from the front desk of the embassy suites. It did not disappoint. The young server was so nice when we came in. Gave us a great recommendation of what to order and it happen to be on special. The prices were so reasonable considering how big they are. We had the house special and BBQ chicken. Thin crispy crust that was amazing if that is how you like. If I am ever here again and craving pizza it will be a destination. The young lady also gave us a recommendation for BBQ, so that is what is for dinner tomorrow.
Thanks for the great experience stefanias! Give them a try if you are in the area.

My family loves their pizza and wings! Pretty sure the pizza sizes are big, bigger and huge ass pizza! I really can’t comment on anything else on the menu because we are yet to try it. If it is half as delicious as the pizza though, it will surely be top notch. They have the option to dine in or carry out so no matter your mood this is the place for you. Oh and you provel haters can rest easy. They offer mozzarella only options for you lame ducks.

Only locals like this place because they grew up with it. It is NOT authentic Italian food by any means. They use canned/​jar sauces from Costco or Sam’s club and don’t do much with it. It’s just cheap… cheap quick food.

I was turned on to Stefanina’s pizza when I moved into the area. From the Stef salad to the pizzas loaded with toppings, you cannot pass this up. The price is comparable to other chains, but this pizza stands out from all the others. Give it a try and it will become your new favorite.

I have to start this off by saying this was a whim of a stop for me tonight. I was really looking forward to pizza, and had a place picked out using our Unilocal app, but it doesn’t seem to exist. So, on our way to a second spot, we passed Stafanina’s and decided to turn it around and try it out.
Walking in, this place is small. I mean, little. I counted 8 tables in the entire place, with a patio of about 4 – 5 more tables. Small isn’t a big deal, it’s just, well, small! We were waited on relatively quickly, but it was apparent that the service would be an issue from the get-​go. I ordered a beer, my wife a soda, and the waitress returned with my beer and a water. When asked if the soda was on its way, our waitress gave us that «what was I thinking» look and apologized, and immediately fixed the error. No big deal.
We ordered the potato skins to start, and an extra large pepperoni pizza. The potato skins were edible, but nothing special. Again, I asked for some ketchup when they were brought out, and the young lady smiled and said she’d be back with the ketchup. As she walked away, my wife noticed we didn’t have any napkins on the table, and commented that we needed them. The waitress returned with napkins and utensils, no ketchup. It is important to note this was a different person than the one that took our order. We never did get our ketchup.
The pizza was, in a word, excellent! Absolutely some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. The crust was perfect, the cheese was fantastic, everything about the pizza was delicious.
As we sat and waited, and waited for a to-​go box, we watched as our server, Allie, ran her behind off taking drinks, food, napkins, etc to tables. Of the six or seven employees we observed in the restaurant, Allie was the only one truly working to take care of customers. We observed two employees standing at the counter, just watching and not really doing much of anything. One of them was, in fact, the same girl that had promised to bring us the ketchup. (still waiting!)
Maybe three stars is a bit harsh, but given that the entire place had a total of 12 tables, and the speed at which the service took place, I would call it highly disappointing. The pizza is excellent, and the next time I’m in the mood for a good thin crust pizza, I will keep this place in mind, but I most likely won’t dine in again. I do want to thank Allie for her efforts, she did her best given the amount of support she was receiving, but in the end, the customers shouldn’t have to wait for their server to «remember» them. For that, three stars.

Great Pizza and Italian. I cringe when I rate pizza joints. Saint Louis style, thin crust is my favorite. Steph’s does pizza very good. They offer good variety and great pastas. In my opinion, they are among the top three pizza joints in St. Charles County.

Their pizza is very good, but their cannelloni bites were my favorite. They were a great app to start the meal off right! Its reasonably priced, and there are many locations around the area to enjoy. This place is a good bet!

My husband and I had not eaten Stefanina’s in 10 or so years, so thought we’d try it since we couldn’t remember if it was any good. Traditional pizza didn’t sound very good so I ordered the 12″ small taco pizza and my husband got the 16″ large pizza with pepperoni and extra sauce. Because we live close, we decided to save a few bucks and go pick it up.
Our order was ready within the stated 20 minutes and held its temperature well until I got it home. My husband said the crust was a little disappointing; he would have liked a crispier crust, and there was too much loose flour on the bottom that got all over your hands. He asked for extra sauce but it didn’t seem like they added more. Everything else about the pizza he got was good though.
My taco pizza was the JAM! I always think taco pizza sounds like a good idea, but it rarely ever meets my expectations. Something is always bland, soggy, or just generally off. Not so with this rendering. This taco pizza is OFF THE CHAIN! I ate SO much more of it than I should have and talked about it ALL NIGHT. I even commented the next morning how surprisingly good it was. If taco pizza sounds even remotely good to you, you NEED to get this pizza!

One of the best places in St Charles. Two locations. Much better than your standard fast food pizza. Sit down and enjoy some GREAT pizza.
Fast service and large portions.

The only thing better than bringing home a Stefanina’s pizza is eating one there. The best St. Louis style pizza anywhere. The new location on Jungermann with a nice sized seating area is a winner. As always, tons of toppings, crispy, thin crust, and oh that gooey provel cheese. Fast service also!

Being a staunch Imo’s fan, this place takes the cake for thin crust pizza. It’s the only place that no matter what variety you get… my mouth still waters before I can dial the phone.
Not to dive too much into standard pizza detail, this place has an amazing cheese + sauce combination… drool…it’s a little tangy, but not tangy if you know what I mean. I’m a fan of the loaded pepperoni of course, but the veggie is pretty fantastic. Its square slice thin crust but a little thicker than Imo’s and its own original taste. If you’re looking to spice up your normal St. Louis style, check it out. There are several locations, this is just the one I’ve been too most. Every one is the same quality and style… enjoy.