Big Pie In The Sky Pizzeria

The service SUCKS girl at front with purple hair has no sense of customer service. Came in with a group from class placed to go order while waiting for the receipt (which took 15mins to retrieve) we sat down to eat our food, was rudely approached by purple hair girl & told we can not order delivery & eat it their. CUSTOMERS can eat whenever & however they please. She was very rude, approached us in a very negative way. PIZZA was dry & disgusting I will NEVER give this place my business again & I will spread the word .
For real authentic ITALIAN pizza hit Pizza spots in Atlanta :
Luigi“s @ Mall of Georgia
Italy’s @ Hamilton mill
Do yourself a favor don’t settle for less get the best. & get some smarter more respectable employees, my advice to store owner.

We came here while in the area and I have to say that the pizza was just okay. We ordered the carnivore hoping that it would live up to the hype but we were sorely disappointed. Being Chicago born and raised I’m sure didn’t make it easy for them to top my pizza expectations, but even my small kids weren’t blown away. The staff was really friendly and the place was clean. We would return simply because it was family friendly and the staff was accommodating.

Pizza good not great. Had cheese bread and Greek salad to start off will go back just for the bread and salad. Atmosphere was very boring needs something to liven the place up. Will order the pizza again but for takeout to entertain guest and my next function at the house.

If you want to be shocked by some huge pizza, come here. A friend of mine saw the Kennesaw location on a Man vs Food episode. I’ve been told that location is much nicer than this one. The pizza is decent, nothing we were crazy about. But still, it was fun to come get slices bigger than our heads.

Amazing pizzeria! loved loved loved it! pizza is thin and flavorful and everyone is this joint is wonderful. great atmosphere and I hope to be back here real soon… We ordered the 30″ inch and what a suprise.

I’ve been to this location several times for dine in and take out. The food is prepared in a timely manner and the slices are huge! In my several visits I’ve only had one issue, which was handled so efficiently by the manager it’s not even worth it to go into detail. Great options on the menu, I recommend West Coast Pesto and Bacon Cheeseburger. The pizza and service never disappoint!

Came here earlier in the week, but didn’t care for it. Got a single slice, and there was plenty of food, I just didn’t like it.
Came here tonight for a birthday party, and the parent ordered whole pizzas. What a difference! So good this time.

I love going to big pie in the sky! My husband and I can split one slice and be full enough. One huge two topping slice and a drink for 5 bucks? Can’t go wrong there. The carnivore slice is good, so is the four cheese.

Come for the novelty, stay for the pizza. This place makes HUGE pizzas, as you probably have already figured out. Quantity over quality is not a cliché that applies here– the pizza slices are actually very tasty! The lunch deal is a great value, you will be absolutely stuffed from your slice of pizza. I have brought many people here, and everyone’s been very impressed.

Great pizza! Had 1 slice and small salad and I was full! Our friends tried Carnivore Pizza Challenge and only made it through 2 slices that’s how big those slices are. Good prices and service.

This is one of only two places in Georgia where you can get paid to eat pizza!!!
Unbelievable right?! This happens to be the second location. The first of which is in Kennesaw and has been on quite a few lists for it’s world famous gargantuan sized Carnivore pizza. If you have ever seen a wooden pallet then you have a good general idea of how big the pizza is. It’s definitely something that you have to see to believe.
I imagined the pizza would just be average seeing as they’re known for the quantity in comparison to the flavor but I have to say that their pizza actually tastes pretty darn good. Although this is my first time eating here I can say that the taste is pretty consistent between both locations. It’s similar to New York style in the fact that it is thin crust but the larger slices look silly to fold, just to let you know.

I am officially addicted to this place when it comes to pizza. I always passed it by because I gave up on thinking pizza could be any better or special. We decided to order from this place for an office pizza party and we were all blown away. The pizza sizes are huge. I think people would have problems trying to fit the XL in their cars if they don’t have a SUV or something with a hatchback to put it in. The dough is what sold me. Nice and thin and NOT soggy like every other place in GA. Reminiscent of NY pizza, which until now I gave up trying to find. The crust is a lovely crunchy and chewy texture the slices are bigger than your head. Also, I did not know that this is the place they filmed the Man vs Food episode about their Carnivore Challenge.

One slice will fill you up! Amazing food and a great price! My boyfriend got The Carnivore, I got the West Coast Pesto, and we split an order of cheese sticks, all for less than $ 20. We ordered to go and got our food in less than 15 min. We will definitely be back!

Enjoyed the mammoth sized 30″ pizzas that our group ordered for our event. Great novelty experience as well just with the size of the slices. We ordered 2 of their specialty pies — the Carnivore (all the meats) and a 4 cheese. The meaty concoction was ok, but the simple blend of cheeses made the other one excellent. Great service by the staff although it did take about 15 minutes longer to get our order from what we were told when we called it in. If picking up takeout make sure you can actually transport pizza boxes this large.

We visited this place after my boyfriend was hyping it so much. I mean big pizzas, where could they really go wrong? We ordered a slice of pizza (I had pepperoni and my bf had carnivore), breadsticks and a side salad. Huge mistake! I filled up on the salad and didn’t really get to enjoy the pizza. They’re right, the pizza is bigger than my face and the cheese sticks were the size or a large pizza you’d get a papa johns. All in all, the food was great!
My boyfriend came back for the pizza challenge with his coworker. Needless to say, they didn’t win, but they did have a week’s amount of left overs.

Four stars based on the value of the lunch special. OMG what a slice of peperoni ! It was crispy with ample toppings and filling like eating two slices from other places.
I will return and just have to get the 30″ for the crew at work.

I am currently sitting in this restaurant watching my girlfriend eat her slice of pizza because my slice of pizza never arrived. We stood in a long line while an employee who just started this morning worked the register. by herself. When it was finally our turn we stood at the register forever while the employee tried to figure out how to use it.
15 minutes later my gf’s slice arrived. She asked for marinara several times before going to the counter to get it herself. I had to inquire about my slice numerous times as well before I was finally told that the order had never been sent to the kitchen. When it finally had (seconds before) it was incorrect.
I asked for and was provided a refund with no offer to make the slice correctly. After I sat down the new employee and told her I was writing a negative review I was suddenly provided my slice of pizza.
All in all a miserable experience. After speaking with the new employee I do not blame her as much as I blame the person training her. Allowing a person to work lunch rush at a popular restaurant on her first day by herself is idiotic at best.

I have been here for lunch only a few times, so the review is strictly on lunchtime.
I think someone else mentioned that each piece of pizza is HUGE! It makes New Yowk pizza look tiny like Rhode Island pizza. This, along with a drink and I can skip dinner (and a couple pounds). $ 5 is a great price for that. Service is pretty good.
The place is normally packed at lunch time, and that makes some people turn around, but I find it well worth it.
I work in this area and it greatly lacks a variety of good pizza, so I am glad that this is now here.

«I think of dieting, then I eat pizza.»
Lara Stone.
Yeah, I had the same thought, then I wen’t to Big Pie In The Sky Pizzeria instead. Whats interesting about Big Pie In The Sky is that while it doesn’t claim to be a NY Pizzeria, it offers a great thin crust pizza which is much closer to «NY Style» than most of the pizzerias in the area that present themselves as such. Yes, the pizzas here are gigantic, but they are also fantastic. This could easily become my favorite pizzeria when i am in the mood for thin crust. Service at the counter is good. Décor is minimal and the focus is more on function than aesthetics. No alcohol at this time is the only bummer, which sucks because whenever I think of dieting, I also drink beer.

Stumbled across this place when in town for business and:
1) The slices are HUGE. The $ 5 lunch deal is totally worth it, enough to feed one normal man.
2) The bread on the sandwiches is actually half decent.
3) The sandwiches themselves (chicken parm, meatball) were pretty bad. Soupy red sauce, most definitely frozen, not real chicken, etc. Bottom of the barrel stuff here.
4) The pizza wasn’t that great either. But it’s HUGE!