Hooligans Irish Tavern

Put In Bay, United States

3.7

Open now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 419-285-8000
Website:
www.hooliganspib.com
Address:
421 Catawba Ave, Put In Bay, OH, 43456
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
No
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Lunch
Parking
Street, Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Good For Dancing
No
Alcohol
Full Bar
Happy Hour
Yes
Best Nights
Sat
Coat Check
No
Smoking
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wi-Fi
Free
Has TV
Yes
Dogs Allowed
No
Waiter Service
Yes
Has Pool Table
No

Today

Today 11:00 am – 12:00 am
Open now
Local time (Put In Bay) 23:04 Sunday, 25 May 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 12:00 am
Tuesday 11:00 am – 12:00 am
Wednesday 11:00 am – 12:00 am
Thursday 11:00 am – 12:00 am
Friday 11:00 am – 2:00 am
Saturday 11:00 am – 2:00 am
Sunday 11:00 am – 12:00 am

Description

Specialties

Hooligans Specializes in Home-​made Irish Fare, as well as American Pub Grub! We are certified by Guinness, and always pour the Perfect Pint! Hooligans features Draft beer, and is the home of the 20oz Pint!

History

Established in 2009.

Hooligans is part of The Boardwalk Family of Restaurants.

Nearby

Near this location:
20
ft
Village of Put-In-Bay
431 Catawba Ave
40
ft
Put In Bay Brewing Co
441 Catawba Ave
50
ft
Lake Erie Island Historical Society Museum
443 Catawba Ave
80
ft
Beer Barrel Saloon
324 Delaware Ave
80
ft
Mojito Bay
441 Catawba Avenue
100
ft
Mossbacks
371 Catawba Ave

20 reviews of Hooligans Irish Tavern

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Brook Park, OH
Hooligan’s always seems crowded and small, but if you can get a table, it’s worth it. My meal was so good, it was exactly what I needed to accompany the spirits I imbibed.
We started with a wonderful cheese plate– lots to choose from, plenty to share. I also had the reuben sandwich was messy, but I could still handle it. Delicious beef piled high with all the fixins.
My favorite part was the Jamo-​rita. It’s a margarita made with Jameson. I usually do not drink Jameson, but it was so perfectly blended. I can’t wait to go back for another! When does the season open?
Place rating: 5
Toledo, OH
AMAZING service! We didn’t really eat much because we were there to drink. Corey was super cool and is a fantastic asset to the island. Our waitress was great as well. Both from Ireland and fun, fun, fun!!! It rained all day, but we sat on the covered patio and had a great time. Totally forgot to finish this review in the summer.
Place rating: 4
Fort Wayne, IN
Loved this place. Irish décor was so fun to look at and the food was amazing! my only complaint was the loud crowed sitting next to us. I for the Piggy melt. A cheese toastie with mac and cheese, pulled pork, and slaw. very good! freshest guinness I’ve had in a long time. poored perfectly.
Place rating: 5
Miami, FL
This was a great experience. Our server Elle was AWESOME. She was on top of everything and went out of her way to make this a great dining adventure.
Thank you Elle! You’re the best.
Place rating: 4
Sheffield Lake, OH
Excellent food, decent service, fun music. Loved the onion rings and whitefish sandwich.
Place rating: 4
Fort Wayne, IN
Very happy with our visit. Great food and drinks. They have bloody Mary’s that come garnished with a grilled cheese sandwich! Server was super nice.
Place rating: 3
Cincinnati, OH
We were a table of 10 sat around 11am in a nearly empty restaurant. My main complaint about this place was the timing. Our service was increadibly slow. We all ordered mixed drinks which took at least 20 minutes to arrive. Overall our lunch took two hours and there was hardly anyone there.
That said the food was good. We got multiple appetizers and burgers. Aside from getting chips when fries were requested once we finally got food we enjoyed it.
A restaurant pet peeve of mine is when they nickel and dime you– $.25 for ranch is not a big deal but there was a lot of extra charges like this at Hooligan’s.
Place rating: 4
Mears, MI
If i could give half stars I would give this 4 ½. They were very quick for lunch we had out app out five minutes after order and our food wasnt far behind it (we ordered them at the same time and got our food before we finished our app). My reuben was delicious perfect amount of moisture and tangy-​sweetness. The chips tasted fresh and were just done enough. My friends got fish n chips which they enjoyed, they come as full sides of fish (2) come wrapped in newspaper.
The app was the irish nachos which were delicious the brisket was tender and there was the right amount of cheese. Would def come again
Place rating: 3
Cleveland, OH
The food was good but nothing out of the ordinary from any other Irish Pub. The service was above average for a local pub.
*The must try are the Bavarian pretzel sticks. The Hooley cheese blend that comes with them is spectacular!
Place rating: 3
Greenwood, SC
Had lunch with the family. They seemed to be thrown off a bit when we rolled up with a stroller, and they had a hard time trying to figure out where to put us. The kids liked their food (kids menu burger and chicken tenders), and my wife enjoyed her turkey club. Do not order the «nachos». It is nothing but a salad with potato skins. Just another restaurant, nothing special.
Place rating: 1
Berea, OH
Tourist trap. Shoulda known better but we took the advice of a shop keeper. $ 12/​person without the price of beers. Food was garbage. Had a party melt and I’ve had better at Denny’s. Beer from the tap tasted horribly off too. Wife had fried fish and they don’t even serve Lake Erie walleye or perch. Avoid it.
Place rating: 4
Marietta, GA
I was here yesterday for the USA vs Belgium World Cup match. It seemed to be the place with the biggest TVs and I was not disappointed. I was happy with the beer selection and decided to come back today to try the food. The pretzel stick appetizer with cheese dip is a MUST. Also, my kids got the chicken fingers with chips… The chips were so good I had to order a basket for myself. Very happy with the service on both occasions.
Place rating: 5
Ruskin, FL
I am normally not impressed with Irish pubs, because as in Ireland, the food is nothing special. Fortunately we discovered this gem when trying to find somewhere to watch The World Cup soccer match.
They have loads of great beer and even flights if you want to sample some. The loaded nacho appetizer was fantastic! They use potatoes instead of traditional nacho chips and then load it with a brisket kind of beef, red peppers, lettuce and their special cheese. It is to die for and super filling, which is why we ended up just ordering the cheese plate instead of a meal. The cheese plate was presented really well. 4 kinds of cheese with various crackers, large group of tasty grapes, sweet walnuts, strawberries and a mustard dipping sauce. We loved it.
We had several servers because we were there for hours and they were very attentive, as were the two managers who stopped by frequently.
Give this place a chance!
Place rating: 3
Monroe, MI
Kinda pub, kinda bar, kinda needs more dedication to the Celtic spirit! Most people are here to get their drink on and not looking for décor.
Place rating: 3
Tonawanda, NY
I think that a little more effort would make this place worthy of 3*. It’s not difficult to make Irish /​pub food good; it was a bit over cooked and led me to an overall impression that food wasn’t that fresh. The menu perfect as I prefer a smaller menu, it has just the right options, and good ingredients.
Beer and atmosphere very nice, service fine, overall average.
Place rating: 5
Peninsula, OH
If you can overcome the embarrassment of ordering a sandwich called the, «Piggy Melt,» then you’ll be handsomely rewarded with a really flippin’ good meal! It’s a sandwich with bbq pork, mac & cheese, and cole slaw. The Reuben is also tasty, but honestly, go for the Piggy Melt. Great Irish pub atmosphere and pretty typical island prices. If you’re traveling in October, this is one of the few restaurants open in the later evening hours. I’ll be dreaming of that Piggy Melt all winter!!!
Place rating: 2
Reynoldsburg, OH
I wasn’t really too impressed with this place. came here expecting a big menu and lots to choose from, but it wasn’t very choosy, and the food was beyond ridiculous. I don’t complain when I come to PIB to party and eat, but $ 12.50 — $ 14.00 for a HAMBURGER? As if!
Service was super slow, waited ten minutes to be seated, and this was on a Sunday around 2:30 in the afternoon.
Drinks are over priced; I’d rather drink at a bar than come here to pay $ 6.50 for a beer.
See ya next time, Hooligans!
Place rating: 4
Durham, NC
Cheese soup and pretzels with cheese dip. Sounds good to me. Both were very tasty and the Magners Cider is delicious. Our server was very friendly and funny. I knocked the sugar all over the floor and she was sweet about it and didn’t make me feel bad. The porch is a nice place to sit, though there were a lot of bees buzzing around (this was October).
Place rating: 4
Pittsburgh, PA
Nice Irish bar and restaurant. Stopped in for lunch on a busy Saturday
. food and service were very good. The best place to sit is on the front deck if you can get a seat
Place rating: 3
Euclid, OH
Very typical Irish pub with your regular ass pub fare. It reminded me of every other Irish pub that I’ve been to. Dark woods, a little bit of stained glass, the freshly puked-​on by a leprechaun look.
Service was pretty excellent considering our party of 12 loudmouthed drunkards. We even had car bombs with our meals. Our server was super friendly and sweet as pie.
The reuben was pretty standard. I enjoyed it. I think I scarfed it down fairly quickly.
I’d go again if I ever found myself stuck on PIB.