Rustic Pie Co

Omg that’s all i can say. Visiting from out of town and holy moly I’d come back just for these pies… we bought 3 and an amazing ginger cookie… get there early they go fast! Made from scratch in house!

Went there for lunch today. The turkey sandwich was great. It came with pasta salad, which was also great. I took a lemon sour cream pie home. It was amazing. I will definitely be back.

I was told about this place today so my wife and I went to check it out. It is sort of off the beaten path, but well worth the effort when you find it. We hit at the right time of the afternoon as the crowd was light. I guess the rush is in the morning! We had the chicken pot pies and piping hot out of the oven. MMM. Then we had the cherry berry pie. The crust you can taste the butter, the flavor of the fruit shined right through to your taste buds. No sense looking for another place to eat pie, but right here. Can’t wait to get back over there and sample some more generous slice of home made pie.

A delicious array of pies all baked fresh with minimal REAL ingredients — The way pie is supposed to taste!
They have everything from Classic Apple to Seasonal Fruit. My personal fave is the Lemon Sour Cream pie — deeeeelish!
The crust is perfection and the fillings are not too sweet — really allowing the flavor of the fruit to shine through!
Don’t miss their lunch either — classic cooking that tastes like grandma’s kitchen. Bread baked daily from scratch, simple (but amazingly delicious) vegetable soup, chili, chicken salad & grilled cheese sandwiches and chicken pot pie. The specials rotates on a daily basis, so be sure to check the chalk board menu when you arrive.
The staff shines as much as the delicious treats here — feels like family when you walk in the door… EVERY time.
Trust me when I say that the Rustic Pie Company is one of the best hidden gems in Prescott!

Amazing pie, loved the coconut! Great service and a nice little outdoor seating area.

A local recommended this place. It was good. We had homemade chili and rolls. We took apple pie to go. It was yummy. The owner and staff was very friendly. The atmosphere was nice. We plan on going back since we are from Phoenix.

Fabulous! Warm, friendly service, fabulous chili and bread. We ended up taking a loaf home and I kid you not — that’s what we had for dinner that dinner. We went from a nice polite family of four enjoying a civilized repast to tearing into this loaf of yumminess, flinging crumbs all over the table.
I can hardly wait to go back for some pie.

This was the absolute best choice I made in Prescott! It is based in what looks to be an older house. It’s very small inside and the seating is limited, but traffic seemed to flow at a decent pace. It honestly wasn’t even full when we went on a Wednesday afternoon and then again on Thursday. The pies are displayed in a cold case and some are on racks to the side that seem to be cooling. The prices are extremely reasonable; you can get a slice for about $ 4 and full pies start at about $ 14 or so. They also make cinnamon rolls, cheesecake, and different breads/​rolls. I noticed that they had a food menu which had a list of sandwiches and pasta salad sides, and another customer was eating a beef pot pie that looked good. The coconut cream pie was delicious. It had a crumbled crust with a great amount of flakes mixed into the cream. We also tried the mixed berry, the pear and the double-​crusted apple, which we opted to have warmed up. Definitely add this stop to your list. You can tell it’s family owned and their customer service is very genuine to prove it. Parking is no problem with some on the street or in the Fry’s parking lot directly across the little side street that they are located on.

Five star experience. My boyfriend and I dropped by on a short trip to Prescott and tried a couple slices of pie. He had the apple pie (with the yummy crumbly topping) and I had the cherry blueberry. It was SO good that we placed an order for a whole apple pie the next day, and sat down and had a couple slices when we went to go pick it up. This time he had the coconut cream and I had the pear. Each one was better than the last!!! When you look at the pies and when you taste them, you know that they are obviously made from scratch. The flavors are very balanced and not loaded with gobs of sugary goo the way you would expect a pie made with canned fillings to taste. Loved it and everyone that has tasted the apple pie we brought home agrees. We are already planning a drive up to get more pies: D Everyone is also very friendly which just puts the icing on the cake (er, pie). Also, GREAT prices for whole pies.

This place is great! Their pies are so delicious!
We’ve also had the homemade chicken pot pie, chili & sandwiches on fresh baked bread. All were very good! Highly recommend this place!

Great place… Not just pies here.
Had the chili dog and turkey sandwich that were awesome.
Sandwich is on homemade bread.
Great variety of pies and cobblers.
I’ll definitely be back when I’m in town.

We were visiting Prescott and saw this cute place. Wow am I glad we did. Their pie is made from scratch in the on site kitchen. I had the brown sugar berry and my husband had the butterscotch. YUMMY!!! Too bad we live in Vegas.

Love it! Pick up something every time I’m in Prescott. Great taste and friendly service.

We stopped in for lunch. Sandwhiches were outstanding. Freshly baked bread was great soft with a crunchy crust. Service was very friendly. Prices were good. We will be back to try the soups and pies

Husband and I stopped in on our way back to Phoenix for a slice of pie and coffee based on the reviews. Needless to say, here’s another 5-​star review for Rustic Pie Co. We both drooled over our selections– coconut crème and key lime. Incredible. Everything is homemade from scratch and you can definitely tell. We also left with lemon poppyseed and coffee cake muffins. We’ll be back for a whole pie next time!

I had heard about this place from co-​workers shortly after moving to the area and they ordered a couple pies for office birthdays. The pie is to die for! My husband and I decided to check it out for lunch.
I had the chicken salad sandwich and he had the turkey sandwich. Both came with pasta salad. The sandwiches were fantastic, and you get a lot for your money. We then ordered a piece of pie — both were awesome! I am hooked on the chocolate pie. My husband had the pear pie and he agreed it was amazing! Great place to go and check out.
Due to it being such a small place, if you have a big party, you might order to go.
The staff was super friendly and we had a wonderful overall experience.

We hit this shop the day before Father’s Day, so in three defense, they were wiped out. That being said, they were wiped out. We each (3) of us ordered differently to share. My daughter got thre pecan pie — amazingly awesome and my favorite, wish I had my own piece. My wife got the chocolate truffle. Chocolate pie is not my fav, but it was light and tasty and she and my daughter really enjoyed it. The different pies I wanted to try were all out, so I tried a raspberry/​blueberry pie. It was tart but tasty, but I was a little disappointed. For a berry pie it was decent, but I would have rather had the sour cream lemon or peanut butter pie. The owners were friendly and very helpful. It was a little warm — a real hot day and no a/​c. Hopefully on the next try some options will be available, if not its pecan pie or bust.

Had the rhubarb crumb, yum. This is the kind of place you want in your town, simply delicious. The rolls are great too.
They have every kind of pie you ca think of but mostly fruit with some cream as well. Mixed berry, apple, cherry and more. Go there and enjoy!

OHHHHHH My!!!
Their Pies are Beyond YUMMY! Next to fry’s on Fair Street… you have to try, and then you’ll be HOOKED!

Customer Service: Outstanding — friendly, caring and attentive.
Food Quality: Exceptional — Fresh, top quality, made from scratch.
The interior is very pleasant, although it is a small place. There are a couple of tables in a small adjoining dining room where you can sit and enjoy coffee or tea and some pie or fresh baked goodies. They all serve soup with homemade rolls that are dense and delicious.
There are so many kinds of pies that they make, I don’t know if I will ever be able to try them all. But the couple I’ve tried were so good I’m thinking about taking on the challenge.
On my last visit, they did not have the pie I wanted, but they offered to make one for me if I wanted to come back in what was a very reasonable amount of time. Nice!
-
I you feel this review is Useful, Funny, or Cool, please check the boxes below. Thanks.