Best bagels in town! Customer service is top notch and their party bagels are awesome! Owners are the nicest people who know customers by name and treat them like family! Don’t miss this place!
Moira F.
Place rating: 5 Mount Sinai, NY
Excellent service. Excellent food. Very family oriented. Everyone is always smiling and makes you feel at home
Chuck G.
Place rating: 4 Sound Beach, NY
I cannot fib — I was less than thrilled to learn that this area would be home to yet another bagel joint. I pass this location daily on the way to work and watched this sleek looking strip mall rise little by little from the dirt it was built on. Strathmore recently opened its doors for business. I stopped in expected to be underwhelmed. I was surprised. It feels much more like a modern coffee bar than a Long Island bagel store. It’s clean and inviting. The staff are friendly and the place runs like a well oiled machine. The bagels are nicely prepared, not too doughy — not too crispy. Tasty. Fresh. I tried the lox cream cheese and was surprised that it has small bites of lox in it instead of the typical ‘pink’ salmon flavored smooth spreads I’ve grown to expect from other area bagel places. I’m definitely going to add Strathmore Bagels to my bagel store rotation and look forward to my next visit. Another consideration is the $ 8 minimum for credit or debit cards. Although increasingly more common nowadays at eateries, it’s definitely annoying… particularly at a place where a bagel and a cup of coffee does not even total $ 5. I’ll limit my visits to when we grab bagels as a group at work.
