Casey’s Pizza & Sub Shop

They opened for special event on a Sunday to support a fundraiser. Very nice of them. Really liked the gluten free pizza options, which included pizza, sub buns, and bread sticks. Niiiice! The antipasti salad was very good. Bonus points for including real green olives and home made dressing. Hubby’s steak sub was OK, a bit dry. But, we really liked the place. What sets this place a part– the home made fresh ingredients. This includes the bar. As we walked in, staff was squeezing fresh fruit for juices. Even the grenadine is home made (whaaaat?). What absolutely blew me away (and earns 5 stars on its own), is the classic cocktail menu which had hand crafted cocktails which I would put up against any of the chic new locations downtown– at a fraction of the price. Perfectly executed, the scofflaw (a Parisian whiskey based cocktail) was only $ 6.50– but amazing. I probably had too many! Overall I would give 4.5 stars since I thought the pizza prices (especially the Gluten Free), was a bit pricey for a vegetarian pizza ($ 3 up charge, If I recall). But, overall, a great evening and we will be back. So glad we tried it!

We are in Port Huron on a short vacation and wanted pizza. Ordered for take out. Pizza was ready when I arrived. Took it back to hotel. We loved it. Nice and hot and it was loaded with toppings. A+.

My wife and I had the Caseydilla and BLT pizza. Both were awesome and our server was nice and quick. We will definitely be back when we come to PH. We sat in the patio as the weather was chilly. Make sure you stop in if you have time and are hungry.

Excellent atmosphere! Love the outdoor patio. Need vegeterian options, none on the menu

Casey’s is fun. The food is very well done, great bar staff know their cocktails, and a long list of crafted beers.
However, prices seem a bit high.
The open air bar room is relaxing and with plenty of TVs and activity.
It is very well run! Try it soon.

I can’t believe I’ve overlooked Unilocaling about Casey’s: We go there every week to 10 days year-​round, and it’s not because we lack options. Port Huron has a growing number of locally owned casual restaurants suitable for date night.
Unlike many restaurants these days that simply open a container and heat food prepared elsewhere, Casey’s makes almost everything on site. The freshness makes a difference in every dish. Seasonal specials keep the menu fresh. You can’t go wrong with Casey’s deluxe pizza, thin and crispy, but when you want a salad, you’ve got great options.
Co-​owners Casey and Carrie Harris are very involved in the business, and I have no idea what one reviewer was referring to in the mention of prior failed ventures. Before this, they operated a successful Port Huron B&B, but eventually needed all the rooms for their growing brood. It’s wonderful to see an owner going table to table to ask how everything is, as Casey and Carrie frequently do.
Casey’s has two personalities: the large fluorescent-​lit room where you take the team to chow down after practice and order at a counter — or the patio, with sit-​down service and a welcoming atmosphere that Jimmy Buffett would love. I don’t recall loud music; however, the place does fill with the sounds of people enjoying themselves.
It looks like Casey’s will reserve space for groups, and when I’ve seen tables with birthday balloons or other decorations, it always looks like the people are having a great time.

The quesadillas were huge!!! Enough for 2 – 3 people. Pizza was great. Service was fast. Definite recommend.

Great downtown gathering place for a few or a group. Full bar & good menu. The pizza is great! Good seating in bar & separate restaurant seating for family. Bar has roll up glass doors for sidewalk café feel, weather permitting.

I stopped by Casey’s today on my way back to Detroit from Port Huron. I had initially planned to have a slice before hitting the road, and saving the rest for dinner when I got back home. Unfortunately — fortunately? — I ate four slices before even leaving the restaurant. It was THAT good. Oops. Delicious pizza, extremely quick service and reasonable prices. I’ll be back if I ever happen to be in Port Huron again!

Unbelievable food in a great atmosphere. I’ve yet to have anything bad here. Thursday — Sunday in the summer they have fresh Guacamole — trust me, it’s worth it.
The real reason to come is the drinks though. Bob the bartender makes killer drinks, and is by far the best mixologist in PoHo, possibly Southeast Michigan. I don’t mean an occasional G&T or Sex on the Beach: I mean old school, Prohibition-​era, lip smacking, hanging with Frank and Dino good cocktails. Every Thursday he makes a special throwback drink that no one under 70 has heard of, using things like Rye, Absinthe, and the freshest ingredients in the fricking state. My favorite thing to say to him is «Surprise me Bob” — and he always does. The recipes for all these are on the random coasters you’ll find everywhere.

OMG what a place! :-)
Casey’s is to good to be true.
Second time in two days we’ve come here.
First day we had gotten the wraps and man were the good. Very filling and the Asian wrap was original.
Today we just finished off a large half veggie, half BLT.
Simply put, best pie I’ve had in awhile.
The crust was toasted to perfection
The veggies were nice and fresh, crunchy in every bite.
BLT was sauced perfect so that you had the full rich flavor in every bite
AND THATS JUST THE FOOD!
The ambiance was wonderful
A blend of being at the beach, in your garage, and at the fire pit. But done with class.
With games to play while you wait, I can’t see Casey’s every going outta business.
Thank you for the wonderful experience.
BEST PLACE TO EAT IN PORT HURON!

Haven’t yet had the opportunity to try the pizza here, but the subs are Abso-​flippin’ amazing! Great place to sit outside on their patio for lunch. There is a bar outside and is cozy with couches and chairs to lounge and chat with friends. Make the trip!

Glad to see that they offer gluten free pizza, but after 4 topping choices (per server they were included) beware. no topping are included in price. My 12.99 pizza became almost 19.00 (!.39 each topping), and the toppings were very sparse, need to be a more generous if your going to charge that much. Also not a lot of toppings on greek salad.

«Kind of blah» is kind of wrong in my personal experiences, not just here but throughout the country. For a pizza parlor, Casey’s is stunning. You’d have to travel far and wide to find something on par with it, nevermind better. If this place were between my two favorite restaurants on the planet, I’d still visit them from time to time. The toppings are fresh, and they actually carry hot peppers unlike a lot of pizza joints. The price is a bit higher than you might like, but given the quality of what comes out of those ovens, I’d charge the same thing.

Great food! They had a nice selection of beers and the atmosphere was clean and lively. They had a chalk wall that kids can draw on and outside they have bocce ball courts! We went in the dead of winter so I really didn’t get to see them; when I am back in the summer I’m hitting this place up to check it out.
When you first walk in, it doesn’t give you the most inviting feel, it’s just kind of blah. the bar in the back is where it’s at.
Service was great as well. Thanks Casey!
p. s. When I come back and rock the bocce ball court, if it’s all I hope for, I’ll up to 5 stars. But it’s awesome that they even have it to begin with.

Casey is a great guy and a smart owner. His business has exploded in the years since his last few failed attempts. I’m glad to see such a great man have a solid business that serves outstanding pizza and salads. Pizza never disappoints me from Casey’s its always freshly made with great indregiants, and done in a timely manner. His prices are very competitive and his lunch specials are very easy on my wallet. Where can you get a soda, slice of garlic bread or sticks and a slice of pizza that’s about the size of a ¼ of a large pizza for under $ 8.
Keep up the good work and keep serving the downtown area a great lunch.

Love the pizza here… and so far I can’t think of anything that I haven’t liked. Be warned that if you get an item with jalapenos that their vendor supplies them HOT and SPICY! I’ve learned to back off on those when I order the Southwest BBQ Wrap (yum) or the Paulie’s Hot N.Y. Italian Fat Boy Pie… now that’s a mouthful and a tasty one too. We’re heading here for lunch later today and as always, I’m yay and yes about that!
~~~~
I am also a fan of the fact that Casey supports the community as much as he does. When a family member suffered a traumatic injury a few years ago he was right there to support the fundraiser planned to help with medical expenses. A gesture that has never been forgotten.

This has become one of the signature places of port Huron! Great place to go for lunch! Second best pizza in town!!! Try the godfather sub!!! One of the best deals in town!!!

Clean and well maintained, this place should be a downtown staple for years to come. The food is good but not extraordinary. Reliably well assembled, the food will not offend most tastes, but does lack a little pizzaz. This is OK though, its a family friendly place thats great for pickier eaters.
Its great to see Casey still working in-​house and hasn’t delegated everything like some restaurant owners might be tempted to do. He’s very pro-​community, he used to play hockey for numerous Port Huron teams and you’ll see his jerseys prominently displayed in the restaurant.
Nice job Casey!

Yum-​o! Casey’s has great salads. We order at work on Fridays and I haven’t had a bad salad yet. They even deliver!