Mike & Tony’s Gyros

If you live/​work/​are ever in Pittsburgh and like Gyros. Look no further. I have eaten Gyros from a lot of places. This place is without a doubt in the top 3. You can call ahead for a take out order. The special comes with a Gyro, fries and a drink. If you aren’t from the area its worth the trip. Stop in a give them a try. You wont be disappointed.

Great little gyro shop. You wont find a better one around just need one in the east side of the city

Far from fancy and downright delicious. I highly suggest their gyro &/​or chicken gyro. To put it simply, It is absolutely the best in town. Cash only. What this place lacks in ambiance it makes up in taste.
After 10, they only serve traditional gyros & fries. They don’t care because they’re THAT good. While I wish they’d serve chicken into the night, I get it. When you’re as famous and flavorful as these are, you just don’t have to go overboard to keep customers happy and coming back. The food is that good.

Best gyros in Pgh… Even better after a night of a few drinks! Check this place out if u love hot fresh lamb and the best cucumber sauce ever!

Mike & Tony’s is one of those urban holes-​in-​the wall that does one thing REALLY well: crank out excellent gyros. Four stars for that. Sure, it may look like a glorified food truck with tables (and it basically is), but if you’re looking for a good Greek taco, this is the place.
Like your favorite swarthy food truck guy, they give zero f-‘s about your opinion. After all, it’s not Mike and Tony’s ambiance, or Mike and Tony’s lounge — the sign says what you came here for — and if what you’re after is a fantastic gyro you’ll leave happy.
By the way: bring cash or expect to be «voluntarily robbed» by the shakedown ATM (it’s behind you).
Even after all that, once you take a bite of the gyro, you still won’t care. And you’ll be back.

Best gyro in Pittsburgh. The night time crowd is a bit tense so it’s better to go during the day or for dinner. Gyro, fries and ice tea.

I love love love the gyro here. Every time I start to eat one I always contemplate ordering a second because they’re so good. But they’re also filling enough that I never need more food, except maybe a few fries on the side. I don’t drink, but this is my go-​to spot when I’m DDing and making someone buy me food. They’re always quick and friendly and the food is consistently delicious!

Mike & Tony’s are the best Gyros ever! They are full & seasoned perfectly. Every time I walked in, I’m meet with that wonderful aroma. Staff could be a little friendlier but I guess that what you get when dealing with SouthSide & staying open until 3am.

Worst gyro on the South Side. At one time it was a good place to get a good gyro, not now. The place is utterly filthy After eating came the stomach cramps then came the diarrhea.

My family has been coming here since my parents were kids. Every single time I order Gyros here its at different times of day with different staff and its the same great taste every time. They mainly do one thing and they do it well which is what makes them so great. Everything is original, its quick, they always have fries ready to go and they aren’t looking to charge you out the ass. They serve generously and the food is prepped right. Yeah theres minor annoyances like not being able to pay with a card and parking is terrible in that part of south side but you know what, for at least 24 years now the food has been great every time and for that consistency they deserve a good review.

best gyros ever hands down. love the salad and the vinaigrette dressing. fries are sometimes good too, depending on the age of the frying solution. make up your mind ahead of time if you’re eating out or in, they don’t play around!

Decent gyro for the price, but definitely not the best I have had.

A solid gyro!
Went here yesterday for lunch and grabbed a gyro and fries to go. It was less than $ 8. When I got home everything was still hot and nothing was greasy or mushy.
They do not skimp on the meat or the tzatiziki which is great because most places I have to ask for extra sauce!
Everything was delicious! Remember to bring cash, but if you forget they have an atm in the restaurant.

I gotta say, this place really does hit the spot. just don’t tell your personal trainer you’ve been here. Your arteries will definitely resent you for a few days after a nice long visit to Mike & Tony’s. Probably the best gyro in Pittsburgh, although I’ve only tried a one or two others. The cash only thing is annoying (mob ties?).

I waited on forever and I only ordered one gyro. Everybody else had more orders and they were out the door quick. I feel like that’s not fair if you have customers order one gyro than you should get them out first then take care of the big orders last. Only because there the ones that take more time.

This is a very straightforward, no-​frills place to get your gyro. Like many places in the area, it’s pretty appropriate for crashing after barhopping or getting some drinks at neighboring joints. Prices are cheap, and portions are pretty big. The gyro meat is quite tasty, and they give you a lot if you order the plate – literally overflowing onto the salad part of the plate. The sandwich was okay too (we got the steak), though the meat portion seemed a bit less and it was a bit messy to eat by hand. So my verdict would be to go for a plate if it’s late at night and you’re looking for a filling meal. It’s great how both the sandwich and plate also come with combos with things like salad, fries, and fountain drink.

Great value and excellent taste! I got a few gyros which were loaded with tastefully seasoned meat. I ordered two because usually it takes that much to fill me up, but I was full after the first one :)
Their feta /​olive side was also favorably portioned with enough to share between two people.
They’ll get me next time in in the mood for gyro.

This is a great place to stop by for a quick bite, either for lunch break or late night after party munchies. They throw together a tasty gyro in minutes. $ 5 will get you a gyro packed with layers and layers of meat. I never thought I’d be saying this but there was too much meat. The meat to wrap ratio was just divine. The meat was beautifully seasoned, although slightly a bit salty. The sauce tasted straight up like yogurt. I wasn’t very impressed. I wish there was more «Tzatziki» in the Tzatziki sauce. Overall, the gyros at Mike and Tony’s really gave that bang for my bucks. Will come back!

Oh Mike & Tony’s, how do I love you! The saddest part of moving out of Southside was the fact that I would no longer be able to walk a block to indulge in the deliciousness that is Mike & Tony s. If I was forced to eat something for every day the rest of my life, it would be the gyro special with extra onions. There is just something about a gyro from here that makes me so happy.
Service is always quick and really friendly. Gyros are hot and fresh and always taste amazing! I love their fries too, always goes good with a side of ranch. If you get it to go, they send you off with your gyro in a plain brown paper bag, just like a typical school lunch. Only this is way better than any school lunch i’ve ever had.
Basically, you need to try Mike & Tony’s. I sincerely miss being able to go there whenever I craved a yummy gyro, and I tell anyone and everyone to check them out!

I have been a fan of this place for years! I love love love love love love this place. love! (get the picture?) =]. I have become a serious regular there– to the point that when I wasn’t there for a month, an employee noticed right away lol. Amazing gyros!
My boyfriend and I order the same exact thing every time we come here. I get the chicken gyro special with ranch instead of cucumber sauce and an Iced Tea as my drink. The boyfriend orders the gyro special with everything on it and a Coke.
The food is always consistently good!
I adore the chicken gyro. They marinate the chicken for hours and it is obvious when you take a bite out of it. It’s full of flavor and it’s juicy! Since it’s cooked on the grill, it has that charred taste to it slightly and I love that! The ranch is awesome too, although it is a little runny. The pita bread is amazing too– soft, but at the same time it doesn’t get very soggy if you order take out.
The fries are delicious too– although, sometimes the cook (depending on who is working) over fries them and they are a little too crisp for my liking.
My boyfriend LOVES the regular gyro. Never anything to complain about there.
We are addicted to this place and do not plan on venturing out to try other gyro places. We already found our favorite!

A gyro under 5 bucks? Yes.
It was filling, tasty, and quick! My friend and I biked to South Side for the sole purpose of obtaining a gyro. Under her recommendation we went here and let me tell you — it was worth the life risking bike ride. The bike ride isn’t bad, I’m just a horrible biker, so getting here is actually quite easy. We ordered our gyros, went to wash our sweaty hands and came down to sit to our freshly made gyros. I love, love the gyro bread, the fluffy goodness that cushions your jaw with every bite. I would advise everyone to get this. EVERYONE.