Fratelli’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

My go to for Pizza or a cheesesteak. Their rolls are great, pies are big, not too greasy, full of flavor.
Usually a friendly face at the register.
Younger guy usually asks how our Weimaraner is doing, in store/​out of store, good lad.

Good Pizza but a little on the pricey side clean place and good staff! Buffalo pizza is very tasty. I normally get the basic pies such as pepperoni, sausage, meatball and onion. Very good!

I’m only reviewing this place for their buffalo chicken pizza. Literally the best buffalo chicken pizza I’ve ever had. As I’m from the area, me and my friend only go here for this one pizza and it’s a disappointment when they don’t have slices! I have tried many buffalo chicken pizzas before but nothing has beaten Fratelli’s yet.
The place only gets 3 stars though because the rest of the food kind of sucks. Their salads and bolis are basic and the the rest of pizzas, even plain, are nothing special.

Buffalo chicken pizza is the best pizza for you and meee.

The best pizza around. It has a thin, crisp crust and just the right amount of cheese. They use a nicely spicy pepperoni. Their cannolis are good, but order it without the chocolate sauce, which is only Hershey’s chocolate syrup. The filling is fresh and delicious. I live close by and my delivery orders are always piping hot.

I’ve eaten here several times and really enjoyed it! The first time I got slices Of pepperoni and buffalo chicken pizza. They were good, but nothing mind blowing. If you’re looking for a quick slice or two, this place does the job. The second time I got a veal parm sandwich; that was VERY good and I definitely would have it again. The last time I got food from here, I got a Cajun chicken ranch wrap. I was expecting it to be spicy but it wasn’t. It did have good flavor though, and it worked well with the ranch dressing. I think they could put a little more chicken in the wraps, but all in all it was a good wrap. I also think their prices are a bit high. $ 6 – 7 for a wrap is kind of much. Despite that, I give this place two thumbs up

I was a loyal Fratelli’s customer until about 10 minutes ago. My boyfriend called to order our «usual»: a buffalo chicken pizza, half with chicken, half without. We’ve ordered this at least 3 times from Fratelli’s and each time it’s delicious. Every time we call we have to clarify that we DO NOT mean half plain/​half buffalo chicken, as we know that cannot be done. I’m not a fan of meat on my pizza but I love buffalo sauce… so we order the entire pizza buffalo chicken style, just half without the chicken! Sounds pretty simple to me. For an unknown reason that «can’t be done» today. I’m not sure why you couldn’t make a simple order (especially since you’ve made it in the past) but an explanation would have been nice. Goodbye forever Fratelli’s.

absolutely disgusting. i ordered a pizza here for lunch. i always order food here as they are up the road from me. i found a fly cooked into my cheese. yes, a fly!!!&)&
when i called to complain the guy said — «what? you dont make mistakes at your job? we didnt do it on purpose.»

The best pizza and Italian food in the area. The tortellini carbonara with bacon Alfredo sauce is my favorite meal. It is so good but I have to limit myself to 1 order a week or I wouldn’t be able to fit in my pants again. Don’t miss the place.

Best tasting pizza in town! Great sauce, crust is never soggy, toppings are fresh, delivered sooner than quoted, every time. If you’re around, stop in for their pizza!

Best pizza in town!
Always has been my go to for good pizza.

We live in Dunellen and have tied all the pizza places in town and very near-​by fr the last 15 years. We’ve driven past Fratelli’s thousands of times and always thought it was funny, there were always cop cars there — but in a «ah-​ha» moment we realized thats because the cops know where the good food is! lol
A few weeks ago we got one of their menu’s in the mailbox. We figured we would try. Yes, they deliver to Dunellen — star 1!
First order was a speciality pie — it was really great!
We order meals, Chicken Piccata and Sausage and Peppers. Got here fast, hot and was delish!
Next order we sandwiches — those too — awesome!
Final delivery order was another pizza — a traditional «garbage pie» — oh my it was so good, and the crust stood up to all those heavy toppings!
Then we stopped in — a late lunch. The place is clean, neat, everyone was friendly and the food was wonderful!
We’ve found our place! Only took us 15 years! lol

Nothing special. Just your typical Americanized pizzeria/​restaurant. Their entrees are overly smothered in sauce and cheese, their pizza drips tons of cheap oil when you pick up a slice to eat. I also had a slice of their «Old World Style» pizza and it was FULL of way too much garlic and oil. Don’t bother ordering from them, it’s not worth your money or health.
The only upside is their delivery man is very sweet, courteous, and accommodating.

I have friends who live nearby and they often order from Fratelli’s when I’m over. The food is tasty and the variety i’ve tried has been good — mussels, chicken francese, salads, etc.

Recently moved to the area and Fratelli’s is the closest pizzeria to me and lucky for me their pizza is pretty great! I’ve really only had the plain cheese but then again I am pretty much a plain cheese kinda guy… except when it comes to bacon.
I’ve also tried a couple of sandwiches from Fratelli’s on occasion such as the chicken parm and have been impressed. I wouldn’t say that they are cheap but I also wouldn’t say they’re expensive. They seem to be pretty average for the area. I’m happy to say that I have a good go-​to pizzeria just a stone’s throw away.

Attention Fratelli’s:
You are not only on my office’s «shit list,» but you are on my personal list of no-​go places as well.
Per my last review, the quality of your food offerings has decreased quite a bit over the past 1 ½ years.
I can now say the same thing about your pizza. While the taste is still acceptable, I have noticed that you have been cutting corners in that area as well. We ordered several pies a couple of weeks ago for a company function, and I was frankly disappointed. The pizza was only sparsely topped, with less than half of the toppings given on a single pie compared to five years ago. It was also certainly less cheesy than it was back then.
As I’ve said with other disappointing establishments, we will not be back unless your management responds with an appropriate response to this review indicating plans for change. I will add a corollary, however: we ordered from Gianna’s a couple weeks ago as well and were very satisfied with their general food offerings. It is possible that you haven’t noticed the degradation in food quality, and as a former frequent patron, I would highly recommend doing a taste test of your competitors as a means of comparison.
You are truly a Piscataway institution, and we would love to give you another chance.
Sincerely,
Calvin A.

Well if you live in the Piscataway area you would probably get your pizza at fratelli’s. I always just call ahead then pick it up a few minutes later. Don’t get anything delivered from here. I think they only have 1 delivery person and he serves a large area. So you know by the time you get your pizza it’s not gonna be warm anymore.
Besides the fact that delivery system sucks everything else is good. The pizzas and garlic bread are delicious. The service is friendly enough and reliable. I’ve been getting my pizza from then for years and they haven’t messed up an order yet.

DELIVERY IS UNACCEPTABLE
Ordered here tonight (2÷21÷14) for the first time and sadly the last time — for delivery anyway. Called to place an order at 7:05pm. We finally called to check on the status of our order at 8:04pm, the staff seemed a bit clueless when calling to ask where our food was. The girl that answered and I quote said «I think your order went out.» Um, it’s a yes or no question! We called again at 8:20pm and the girl that answered finally decided it would be a good idea to actually check to see where it may be. And again she said it was on it’s way. They never once apologized for the food taking almost 90 minutes to get to us, they just kept saying, «it is on it’s way.»
Our house is 5 minutes away it shouldn’t take an hour and a half to make a wrap, meatball sandwich, and wings. We’ve had takeout from other towns delivered in less than half the time.
When the food finally came, it was warm and satisfactory. Moral of the story… DON’T ORDER VIA DELIVERY!
I’m sure pick-​up and dine in would be much better.

I’m not sure if Piscataway has a «main street,» but I kinda think there is a stretch of stelton road that acts as it. It has a post office, small plaza with a clock, and library in the vicinity. On that same road is Fratelli’s Pizzeria. Its a neighborhood fave, also walking distance for people like my classmates.
Ambiance: Despite being a neighborhood fave, this was my first time to visit and it looks newly renovated and pleasant. They have pizzas with different toppings on display.
Food: I consider a plain slice of pizza the standard or the one to be judged when it comes to a pizza place. My first impression: GOOD and worth eating again if you are in the neighborhood. Its a thin slice, like that of what I call the «New York» pizza, which is thin slice and not thin crust. But the flavors are there and I would definitely try their other pizzas or dishes on next visit.

I remember when this location used to be Poppy’s Pizzeria… like 35 years ago, and while Poppy’s was pretty good (pizza from 35 years ago I can remember, but birthdays, forget it) Fratelli’s is SO much better.
Where you grew up in Piscataway usually determined your pizza place of choice and while this wasn’t MY first choice (I was a Dominick’s guy), I DID learn to appreciate it… and now when I’m home for a visit, I’ll usually every few times just to get a taste. I love pizza, well let me be more specific, I love good pizza and Fratelli’s fits that bill. I’m not someone who likes a lot of toppings on my pizza so I’m usually a plain slice or a sausage slice kind of guy, and I have full confidence in recommending these guys if you love pizza the way I do.
I can’t speak to their sandwiches or their ‘special’ slices, but the plain and sausage slices are delicious (and their garlic knots are excellent as well)…a little pricier than others in town I think, but delicious nonetheless.