Pudgy’s Pizza & Pasta

I like there pizza and good service also — there Mexican food is really good after the new owners took over, the rice

Are great home ordered pizza from them it was very good by the way I would recommend them.

Love the food! Especially the Mexican! Best the clock on Tuesday is awesome! Saves a lot of money! The girls who work there are very helpful!

This review pertains to their employees. Rude, and unfamiliar with products. While the food is good, the turnover in unqualified and incompetent staff force me to give such a low rating. They’ve lost my business. Avoid, unless you like dealing with rude waitresses!

The food is very good and the people are nice & accommodating. What more can you ask of a small local deli? We had a plain pie, a specialty one and a Sicilian with sausage, along with salads and garlic knots. Everything was very good (and on time). My nephew asked where we had gotten the food because he was impressed. Yum, Pudgy’s.

A local favorite for my kids, I get «the face» if I ever bring home pizza from any place else. Staff is always attentive. The only drawback is the place is tiny and on a home football night it can be a tight squeeze even for just picking up take out.

I ordered a large pizza with black olives and pepperoni. It was a great tasting pizza! Being from California and not being to the east coast in over 8 years the pizza truly delivered! I will definitely order pizza from this place again. My toddler loved her piece as well. Even though it was too big of a slice for her!

My favorite in pine bush ! Best food ever. We go there at least once or twice a week. Reasonably priced. Best pizza place in pine bush.

Good variety! Quick service! I use them whenever I need something good and quick on a weekend! I usually take out.

Great food !!
Specials everyday that wont break the bank .
Beat the Clock on Tues, Call at 6pm pay $ 6 bucks large pie !
Professional and courteous staff .
Cant beat the catering prices too !!
Benzee

The Mexican food is real good. The chicken enchiladas and steak tacos are delicious! Pretty good pizza too, I always get the chicken bacon ranch.

I love the pizza here! simple and delicious the staff is very nice and catering. I’ve also recommended this to some of my friends and workmates definitely a place you gotta try if you come here

The food we got here was pretty good. My wife loved the spaghetti she ordered. I got the chicken wings since they were on special Wednesday.
I would suggest getting something to-​go since there isn’t much of any eating area.

Awesome specials and lots of them. The food was great and waitresses were even better. We are only in town for a few days, but we will be back.

Poor quality ingredients and food. Would recommend going elsewhere for a much better pie.

I came in for a meal. The place was so small that the two girls behind the counter did not know who was needing help next. The menus are tucked away so you cannot see what they have. Trying not to take to much time I decided on an Italian Sub. Drinks are around the corner of the counter in a cooler, which is not bad, except when there is seven people standing there waiting to order or for an order. The meal was not spectacular or anything different than you get from the local gas station. Service brought my food out, but gave me no napkins or anything else. So I take it is a self serve and figure it out type place. They must get a ton of people for the lack of service or dedication to the presentation. I was not impressed with the cleanliness. This town is so stuffed with pizza places that they have an additional claim. Pudgy’s is Italian, American– not sure what kind of food that is since we all come from a different country, and Mexican. Very confusing and you can tell in their lack of a specialty.

Best pizza you can get locally. I don’t live in Pine Bush, and I will gladly take the 23 minutes to drive to Pudgy’s for quality food. I’m a Bronx girl, and outside of NYC it’s very hard to find good pizza. Pudgy’s was a welcomed surprise for me and the family. Pizza is always made fresh, with quality ingredients. Even better the service is great! They are there to serve their customers, and you don’t need to be a regular to be well regarded.

We called Christmas Eve, ten minutes before closing time and they allowed us to place an order for pickup!
We really appreciated that the person taking our order was friendly enough and didn’t discourage us from placing an order even though it was a holiday and so close to closing time.
We were staying in a hotel nearby. And, originally, based on Pudgy’s previous reviews, we decided to go with another local pizza place. But they were closed. So we decided to ‘risk’it. Pleasantly surprised!
We ordered two medium pizzas (they were actually quite large) and 3 orders of wings. .one honey mustard (not very mustardy, more of a sweet sauce), one parmesan (crispy and delicious) and one spicy hot wings (spicy, not too gooey, and also delicious!). Each order of wings came with a side of ranch as well.
The pizzas had generous toppings. They use canned mushrooms (info for anyone that doesn’t care for that), but everything else is fresh. The veggie pizza even had thin slices of breaded and pre-​baked eggplant! Supreme pizza was generous with meats as well. ONLY downside to pizzas was they both had VERY LITTLE tomato sauce. Plenty of cheese, but very skimpy on sauce. We were a family of 5 eating together and we all agreed on that point.
My husband was the one that picked the pizzas up. They were ready when he arrived. He said the person behind the counter was pleasant enough, so no problems there either.
If you’re in the area, give this place a try!

We’ve eaten here quite a bit. It’s not bad, but it’s not spectacular. The pizza is plain and not enough sauce for my tastes. It could also use a little more cheese. The garlic knots aren’t bad, but could use a little more flavor in the dough itself. They do have some good wings. Their prices are good. Their beat the clock deal is a great value that you can’t really beat.

I used to live in this town and have been to every pizza place they have had. I asked my friends where to go for some pizza and they said Pudgy’s since it was my yearly visit to NY from AZ. I ate it about 3 – 4 times that I was there, it was okay but nothing special, every time we got a pie it was just so-​so and even my friends said so too who eat there regularly. I was going to eat in the first time I went but it was so hot in the place because its small and crammed, it was literally cooler outside, they do have 2 small tables out front to eat which is nice.
I think if they made the pizza that my friends said they used to and got better ac in the place it might go up a notch or 2 on the star scale. I will have to pass on Pudgy’s next time I come to town and give one of the other pizza places in the small town of Pine Bush my money.