OK I have been coming here for 5 years. You do an unreal job. Here is what I do not understand. I have went to two of your other stores and they are terrible. Gahanna experience was awful. Terrible service and the manager there(Brandy?) was drunk at the bar with her boyfriend. Went to Canal location and felt sick after eating. Later I see that this location was on the news for having 47 violations from the health department! Who ever the is running this location in Pickerington needs to teach the other stores hot to do business. I will never return to those stores but wanted to say kudos to Pickerington as you are awesome. I have NEVER had a bad experience coming here!
Daniel P.
Place rating: 4 Pataskala, OH
This is hands down one of the better pizza joints in the area! Prices are a little higher than some in the area — but certainly better bang for your buck in terms of pizza! We have ordered a handful of times and have never eaten in — but would imagine the experience would be the same! This is our now go to place for pizza!
Crissi B.
Place rating: 3 Pataskala, OH
I love their pizza! I’ve never had a bad thing to say about their food! When you order pickup however I’ve had some issues with my order not being done within the time frame they gave me and having to wait another 20 minutes there.
Myles S.
Place rating: 5 Columbus, OH
Pretty awesome pizza. The owners are very interactive with the customers. They always check up on the tables frequently. The pizza is thin crust and it taste amazing. Also my friend was allergic to gluten, and to our suprise they had amazing gluten-free crust! I highly recommend this place!
Dwight P.
Place rating: 4 Pickerington, OH
Really good pizza. Eat in and munch on the popcorn while you wait on food. Lots of sports on the tvs.
Betty E.
Place rating: 5 Pataskala, OH
Great food. Pizza subs all is good, service is great. We live in etna and drive to pickerington to get this pizza… love it
Patrick G.
Place rating: 4 Downtown St. Paul, St. Paul, MN
I’ve been here less than ten minutes and already have a drink in front of me. These ladies are on the ball.
Candi M.
Place rating: 4 Pickerington, OH
Excellent Pizza! My husband stops by here 2 – 3 times a week to pick up a pizza! Excellent and yummy
Keri H.
Place rating: 4 Pickerington, OH
Great pizza, website could be better but this is my Friday night go to! My entire family loves it.
Candy W.
Place rating: 5 Pickerington, OH
Love this place. Monday night is a great night to come in. Great specials
Chrissy D.
Place rating: 5 Pataskala, OH
Half price single item pizza mondays. Great pizza. Great service. We come once a week!
Rebecca R.
Place rating: 2 Pickerington, OH
Service was friendy, nachos were really good, wings were dry and small cheese pizza had to be convinced it wasnt a frozen pizza. Not a winner.
Sheena A.
Place rating: 5 Reynoldsburg, OH
Never fails when I get their baked spaghetti, best in town and neighboring town. I absolutely love the baked spaghetti it’s cheesy and saucy and just plain GREAT. I thought I would try a place closer to me and they were an epic fail compared to grapevine. If you have a chance to try it I highly recommend! !
Tommy C.
Place rating: 2 Pickerington, OH
Decided to try their pizza and Italian sub tonight. Pros the pizza has a nice crust and cheese. That is where it ends! If you like hardly any sauce(which if you do happen to get some it lacks flavor) and lots of grease this is the pizza for you! The sub was ok at best. The pepperoni they use on this sub is the exact ones they use on their pizza which are small and not fit for a sub. Not the worst I’ve ever had but far short of the best! My recommendation go somewhere else of you want a good pizza and sub.
K H.
Place rating: 3 Pickerington, OH
It was okay a little forgettable.
Nate H.
Place rating: 4 Washington, DC
Love the pepperoni pizza! Great beer specials also.
Christopher G.
Place rating: 2 Orient, OH
Stopped by for lunch this past Saturday just because it was on our way, and it was convenient. We ordered a 14″ pep & mushroom, which was cut 3 times each way. Every«outer» or edge piece(13) had little if any toppings on it. And all 4 corners had nothing but a splash of sauce. The only pieces that had any substantial toppings were the 4 inter center pieces. Inconsistency seems to be the emerging problem with this restaurant. Too bad too, because its obvious they have the potential.
Ruth M.
Place rating: 2 Brice, OH
I can only in my mind give this two stars. My husband really likes this pizza and I don’t think it’s the best pizza I’ve had, but it’s pretty decent. If I had to choose, my favorite thing on the menu would be the garlic cheese sticks. I’m partial to any garlic cheese sticks, so while there isn’t anything overly special about them, they are tasty! On to the service — since I’m typically the one who calls in(we’re usually carry-out), it never fails — the person answering the phone sounds either a) like today is their last day on Earth and they’re stuck at work or b) like they put salt instead of sugar in their morning coffee and they’re overly bitter. Basically, not once have I spoken to anyone who’s even close to friendly. I’m a pretty nice person and am always appreciative of people I do business with, but when they cut you off and hang up while you’re thanking them, it gets very disconcerting. And being busy and handling several calls/carry-out customers in a row is not an acceptable excuse.
Kristin C.
Place rating: 5 Columbus, OH
The pizza here is fantastic. Loads of toppings from edge to edge, a perfectly seasoned sauce and anchovies for my Dad. Every time I come down to Picktown, I make sure to swing by here and get a pie to go.