NY Firehouse Grille

Great food, great staff, and great establishment. Always an enjoyable time every time I step foot in!!!

Really good wings! Craving those PB&J wings right now. Didn’t sound too appetizing to me and they looked kind of funky when we got them (melted peanut butter on wings… LOL) but they were sooooooo good! Waitresses were also very friendly and helpful with recommendations on the menu. Good casual hang out spot to get your grub on and watch a game. Will go back.

You can’t go wrong at Firehouse. The ribs are always great and are light on the sauce, so you can add enough yourself.
The wings come in various spices and I love spicy. I’ve found the 5 alarm is pretty good and manageable. I have yet to try the «Waiver» wings. If you do eat them, it’s not like you get a t-​shirt or picture on the wall, so there’s not much incentive to eat them unless you just like that kind of spice. Just remember, even though you may get it down in one direction, it still has to come out the other direction at some point, which could be MUCH more painful. Eat them if you live locally or have no problem with public restrooms.
There is enough variety for the whole family to get what they want — from mac n cheese, to fajitas, to vegetarian options, to Dad’s carnivorous fare.
The chili was not as good as I would have hoped. Lacked spice and the flavor was not very full.
Pricing was very reasonable for entrees and sandwiches, but some appetizers get very pricey — almost the cost of an entrée for some.
You can sit at the bar and meet the locals or sit in the dining area which has mirrors — so everyone gets a TV view.
Definitely a neighborhood gem.

Had a wonderful time tonight at the Firehouse Grill. Started with Sarachi Honey wings, which were wonderful. For dinner had brisket tacos which were a great mix of sweet and hot. Better than. the Taco Dive Bar. Top off with Jamaican Coffee. A fun, relaxed atmospheric with great service. Can’t ask for better after a stressful day.

All the reviews were spot on! Wings that are as hot as they say and hotter! Very friendly crowd and lots of sports on the TVs. Will definitely be back while I’m here.

Love the firehouse grill. Wings are great, sandwiches, ribs, burgers, and fajitas are all very good. Friendly and attentive staff. What more can I say, this place is excellent!

Great, great wings — they actually know how to make them spicy (I’ve worked my way up to Hazmat). The other wing flavors are also very tasty and varied (who would have ever thought of PB&J wings).
Nice atmosphere for what is essentially a bar. Very friendly staff — great deals during NFL Sunday too!

This is definitely a local pub in Peekskill. BUT if you are from out if town you are made to feel like a local as well. The bartender Dominic is fantastic. Great personality and can hold a conversation. Takes care of his fellow workers. Food was delicious. Try the brisket. At first I was skeptical of the vibe but then was made to feel right at home. Recommend.

.great place for wings and beer. All the food is delicious! My favorite place to go. Wyatt Earp wings are a must try, also white street! Great crispy saucy wings. Nachos are really good too. Great specials almost every day. Must try.

This Is A Great Place To Go To For A Great Lunch Or Dinner!!! Nice Place To Stop Into For A Berger And Beer!!! Great Place To Bring That Firemen In Your Family Out For A Great Firemen’s Meal. Real Nice Place!!!

Macaroni and cheese on a burger… you can’t beat that! The waitress was really nice and attentive. The beer selection wasn’t that impressive and the burger wasn’t too seasoned

Came here to catch the Jets Game with my Sports Fan Brother. I’m not really into sports but am sure into Beer. The place is quite laid back and has a simple feel to it. IT has a restaurant portion and Bar section and plenty of TVs to watching grown hell beating the crap out of each other over a ball. Pretty sweet. At the entrance they have this loop of pictures showing various internet Memes and applying them to the restaurant. A pictures of Morpheus from the Matrix popped up stating «What if I told you… You could put Mac and cheese on your Burger?“I Was instantly sold. The ambient must bring a lot of younger patrons.
The hostess (Who also ended up being our waitress) was really nice and gave us layout of the beer selection and had us try on the darker beers I never tried before. They have a create-​your-​own-​burger section in the menu which lets you select the meat (you could even have salmon), cheese and condiments (I obviously went with the mac and cheese). The burger was delicious and filling and went really well with the beer.
After we were done we went to the bar to finish watching the game but encountered a problem. My brother went to buy the round but realized he had forgotten his wallet at home. The tattooed bartender asked for the ID and denied him service. I figured I would buy the round then as I had my ID with me. The bartender then came up to me and snapped at me that I wouldn’t be served if I didn’t provide an ID for both me and my brother (Who was already drinking a beer that we got with dinner). The guy was totally in the right but I could had totally done without the snotty and condescending attitude.

Great neighborhood bar/​restaurant. Kind of place I feel comfortable coming alone and hanging at the bar to eat and have a drink. Not many places I would do that at. The wings rock here. Love the Ninja Warrior. Keep up the great work.

Awesome wings! They have a crazy variety of flavors and the new cannoush (siracha) are to die for. We used to love ninja warrior but they haven’t been great the last few times we ordered them. The bbq, hbt, and Parmesan dry rub are all great. They also have some crazy unique flavors like maple bacon and pbj. Trivia night is a blast and the staff is super friendly. Takeout and dinein are easy and good comes quick when it’s takeout (10 minutes, tops). I don’t recommend, however, the French dip. But seriously, the wings are the best!

I like The firehouse
good for family or Gals Night Out
food is tasty and good portions
friendly staff, good service, good knowledge of menu and how items are prepare
parking lot is a mess! desperate need of repair

****I’m not sure why Unilocal is taking me to the Peekskill location, this review is intended for the Elmsford Location…
It’s Friday night and we don’t know where to go, so we decide to give NY Firehouse Grille a chance. We go on in and the host sits us tucked away in the corner– waywayway back. So we take in the décor, the lighting and the total ambience, which is ok.(I definitely see my husband coming here with the fellas). We waited and waited and waited some more until my husband flagged someone (who I think might be the owner– not sure who she is), and said to her that we’ve been sitting for a while and have been completely ignored, however the couple behind me were seated way after us and they were placing their orders. WTF!!!
This person quickly sent our server and we started with drinks right off the bat. Then soon after, we placed our orders. I went for the Lobster Mac & Cheese and my husband went for the Burger with Blue Cheese.
Well let me tell you, NY Firehouse Grille kind of redeemed themselves, honestly their Mac & Cheese was finger licking good!!!
Thanks, although service lacked in the beginning, you redeemed yourselves.

Stopped in Monday night. They have a great variety of wings on the menu. But a friend of mine recommended a flavor not on the menu, PB&J wings
Sounds strange but truly they are delish!
Lots of flat screens for watching the game. Friendly staff. Lots of interesting brews on tap. I enjoyed the Rocky Mountain IPA
A truly enjoyable venue

Haters don’t know what they are talking about. :X
Monday night, 35 cent Wings is the bomb and my friends and I legit get 5 + rounds of pitchers of shocktop and about 5 dozen wings. The bill has yet to top $ 75. Heavenly!
I adore the dusty ranch and my friends always try something new– last night it was wizard, cajun and some salt n vinegar blend. Delish! I’ve yet to get dried out and small wings; they are all decent size and meaty as mr meaty. (And i’m already craving them again at 10am the next morning!)
Lets not forget $ 2 tacos, tequila and trivia night Tuesdays! I go home happy and at $ 15 a person for a few tacos and brews– you cant beat it!
Yeah its a locals spot but come with your friends and who cares, its a fun time!
If you are coming here for salads and meatloaf, well DUH, youre in the wrong place. WINGS WINGS WINGS
[i am totes also looking forward to next years WingBowl!!]

Returned for dinner with my Redhead wife.
This visit, we both chose the burgers, one vegetarian and one beef. Well made and generous size on brioche roll with lettuce, tomato and red onion. Was cooked medium/​medium-​well; asked for medium-​rare. See pics.
The side salad is included instead of the fries. Really good.
Only disappointment was $ 10 for a martini using well gin. Really outrageous for a well drink. Maybe I shud have complained.
Beers are always good value. Chose this time the Goose Island IPA. Excellent.
Winter Gripe: main dining room was cold. All patrons were wearing their coats, and few women wore a winter hat. Really. Bar area is warmer and okay if you want to sit on stools.
Friendly servers.
If you think this review with photos is useful, funny or cool, I’d appreciate your feedback by clicking below.

This is the first time I’ve been here since its under new ownership. I love how they changed the entrance and bar area. It’s a much better flow than the old joint.
Hubby had a BYOBurger with a fried egg on top and loved it…
My 18 month old had her favorite (chicken fingers) … I of course tried them and they were crispy and delicious. Her meal came with 2 sides so we ordered fries and house chips (they were out of yogurt or I would have ordered that). The house chips were horrible. I’m sure they are freshly made but they were very stale and def not safe for a child to eat. (BTW this is the reason for the 4 star rating vs a 5)…
I had the French Onion Soup which was yummy and the White Street Boneless Wings — Teriyaki, Honey BBQ and 5 alarm (heat) … It was hella hot btw! I had to stop eating the wings bc the combo of the soup that was actually hot temperature wise was killing my mouth with the spice… (Will eat the leftovers tomorrow) :)
Our waitress was really nice and the staff all seemed to be very helpful…
A bonus — if you’re a firefighter, police officer or ems you’ll received a 10% discount with proof of service — ie your badge.