Romeo’s Pizza. Mentor on the Lake. High expectations for the food(pizza). Guess I should have been an owner or stock holder in the company. I ordered the Tuscan Pepperoni pizza. That had two kinds of cheeses. What I received was a large pepperoni pizza with very little cheese. over priced for about 5 dollars. Compared to the pepperoni one topper pizza price I should have been charged. Problem? Hardly any cheese and a $ 16 pie that consisted of a pizza that was easily comparable to Marco’s Pizza medium one topping pepperoni. Number #1. yeah. WOw. Possibly because they’re laughing about take they get from over charging on a gimmick and overstated reputation. Upon calling they said it was what they always give for a cheese amount, and they offered a discount. Sorry, I’m not being conned twice.
Timothy S.
Place rating: 2 Cleveland, OH
The sauce is so sweet that you can hardly taste much over it. Don’t bother with the deep dish, it is just a super thick crust. These guys haven’t been to Antonio’s and def never Chicago. $ 6 for 6 wings… I’m done with this place.
Azraelle R.
Place rating: 5 Akron, OH
Amazing italiano! Some of the best pizza ever! Great sauce! My favorite pizza in Cleveland! The crust is so fresh tasting! I personally recommend picking it up I had problems with delivery once and never did it again is literally a block from where I stay so no big deal!
Lani M.
Place rating: 4 Cleveland, OH
Best gluten free pizza in the area. It’s over priced but for someone who has to eat gluten free, there’s no other option. The crust is very thin but it still tastes great. I have even grown to liking their gluten free pizza better than the regular pizzas. 10⁄10 would recommend.
Brian K.
Place rating: 4 Cleveland, OH
Romeo’s is on the level of Pizza Hut or Papa Johns. If you want gourmet pizza, go down the road to Antonio’s. If you’re looking for cheap pizza that is also delicious, look no further. The sauce is a bit unique, so it won’t fit everyone’s taste. Highly recommend the Buffalo Chicken pizza.
B R.
Place rating: 2 Cleveland, OH
Place an order by phone for two medium pizzas for takeout 15 mins prior to pick up. Arrived, sales person had to get a manger to ring up sale. Seemed clueless as to my order. Once I paid, waited aprox 20 minutes for pizzas to come out. Was told that the order wasn’t quite ready; i.e. they missed it and never filled it. Sat for aprox. 20 mins in a hot pizza shop while they filled my order that I had called in 15 mins prior to showing up. No apologies, no coupons, didn’t seem to care that they screwed up. Pizza was good, crust crunchy on bottom, vegitarian pizza was loaded, no skimping. However, service bad, wasted my time. Benefit of doubt, labor day weekend and may have been slammed.
Benny F.
Place rating: 1 Cleveland, OH
I use to be in the Pizza industry and this pizza fails due to the sweetest sauce I’ve ever had on any pizza in my life. It also Fails as the crust is tasteless and cardboard like. The Cheese was the only saving grace of this pizza. I would give it two stars but when a $ 5 dollar georgio’s Pizza beats you thats just sad. Their crust and sauce destroy romeo’s. This is a review for the 130th location… but i’m sure the pizza taste the same at any of the other locations.
Owen m.
Place rating: 5 Mentor, OH
This pizza is close to me, so I get it almost once a week. I have to agree with the last review Cynthia, this pizza sauce is pretty unique. It’s hard to describe but I’ll do my best. It has a subtle sweetness to it, rounded off at the end by what is distinctly basil, and possibly some rosemary. The cheese is quite chewy, and typically cooked until brown on the top. Most of the fresh vegetable toppings you can tell are prepared in house, while some are as expected canned. The boneless wings also aren’t bad, although fairly run of the mill. This place is a classic standby for me.