Tomato Pie Pizza Joint

Paragon, United States

4.7

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 765-558-3363
Website:
www.paragonpizza.com
Address:
100 W Union St, Paragon, IN, 46166
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
No
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Lunch
Bike Parking
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Very Loud
Alcohol
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
No
Has TV
No
Waiter Service
Yes
Caters
No

Today

Today 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Paragon) 00:08 Tuesday, 10 June 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Saturday 12:00 pm – 10:00 pm
Sunday 4:00 pm – 8:00 pm

Description

Specialties

This is a small town owner operated Pizza Joint. Fresh ingredients, scratch made dough and tomato sauce make this a pizza experince worth the drive. We have the worlds best Breadsticks brushed with Garlic & Herb butter and choice of Marinara or Jalepeno cheese sauces. Our dough is aged for 48 hours for maximum flavor. We cut our Salad fresh daily and make everything to order. Our team at Tomato Pie provide fast and friendly service. Everything at Tomato Pie is served with larger size portions so your going to get your hard earned moneys worth. I’m Kim Raia the owner and I have done a lot of research developing our recipies. I have taught the technique to my staff needed to operate a deck oven properly for that all important perfectly chard crust. This is for sure a skill we all take pride in. This is an Artisan Pizza and Pizza is our passion. I grew up working in my family business at Greiner’s Subs-​shops in Indianapolis since I was 14. Greiner’s offered products above and beyond typical sub-​shops, great effort was made to bake gourmet bread, and all ingredients were chosen for quality and taste, without compromise. Greiner’s has been operating since 1970. The owner, operator food service concept has dwindled over the years with the onslaught of corporate food marketing, as employees are trained in a static manner, akin to trained seals, as they greet you at the counter. Not so at Tomato Pie, you are coming to this place to discover something that is above the ordinary.

Meet the Business Owner

Kimberly R.

Business Owner

Born in Dearborn MI, grew up in Noblesville IN 1971 – 1981. Home schooled and lived on a sailboat with 2 younger brothers and parents for 5 years. 1986 Went to highschool in St Petersburg FL.1989 Graduated from Broadripple highschool in Indianapolis. Married in 1991, had two children. Resided in Morresville for 13 years. Moved to Paragon in 2007 Divorced in 2010. Currently reside in Paragon.

Nearby

Browse nearby places:
140
ft
Metro School District of Martinsville
140
ft
Kiefer Heating & Cooling
360
ft
Paragon Auto Sales
2300 S South R 67
380
ft
Peoples State Bank
2310 S South R 67
500
ft
Paragon Bible Baptist Church
269 W Union St
720
ft
Paragon Supermarket
309 W Union St

20 reviews of Tomato Pie Pizza Joint

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Indianapolis, IN
The food is good but I’ve had better. The prices are high compared to other great pizza places I’ve ate at. The food rates about a 7 on a scale from 1 – 10.
Place rating: 4
Indianapolis, IN
Very pleasantly surprised. The breadsticks were the best we’d ever had, and the pizza is solid too. Good beer selection and friendly staff.
Place rating: 5
Indianapolis, IN
Awesome pizza and breadsticks. Best I have ever had. Great Service! Thought this was maybe another off the wall pizza place but I was wrong. I was very impressed and will be coming back.
Place rating: 5
Bloomington, IN
Awesome pizza and service!!! High rating well deserved. Amazing that you there is such a great pizza place in the middle of nowhere.
Place rating: 5
Frankfort, KY
Was a little sketchy about the area but the place was so packed we ended up going to the back dining room. Was disappointed to see they didn’t have beer but did get sodas in a souvenir cup. The breadsticks were awesome. The wife loved them more than I did and that’s saying a lot. We opted for the thin crust and I’m glad we did. Awesome flavor all the way around.
Place rating: 5
Stinesville, IN
Best kept secret in Paragon In. Great staff, quality ingredients, they use real pizza ovens, not those lousy conveyor types that gives you crappie crust! Pizzas are delicious with lots of toppings to choose from and plenty on the pizza. Prices are very reasonable for the quality and quantity of ingredients. The only things I would like to see change is, the onions and green bell peppers chopped instead of sliced into strips, and serve cold beer. Now for the awesome! THE BREAD STICKS ARE UNBELIEVABLY DELICIOUS, tender, light and flaky, great plain, or dipped in your favorite sauce!
Place rating: 5
Pasadena, TX
I think I have eaten the perfect pizza! Seriously the best pizza I have ever encountered. It was an off menu item recommended by our friendly waitress. (I wish I would have noted her name!). She called it the Mama Mia. Blueprint: Meatball with double cheese and tomato sauce. We found this place on Unilocal on our way to McCormick’s Creek State Park. Thank you Unilocal!They also gave us complimentary breadsticks when they found out it was our first visit. I also highly recommend the breadsticks. The only negative about this place is we live in Houston and can’t eat here again soon!
Place rating: 4
Rio, WI
The pizza was great. The veggies were fresh and the crust was excellent. The service was a bit lacking. It seemed like there were too many staff in the kitchen and not enough paying attention to the dining room. I’d go back — but it would be for take out!
Place rating: 5
Indianapolis, IN
One of the best pizzas my husband & I have ever eaten, not to mention the amazing breadsticks and friendly staff! It has a small and understated dining area. Order enough to take home some, as this pizza is even yummier as leftovers. Breadsticks… order breadsticks! Worth the drive from Speedway!
Place rating: 5
Mansfield, TN
Just happened to stumble upon this place because we were starving in the middle of nowhere — but WOW! This isn’t just good for podunk Indiana, this place is freaking delicious! Large portions, great flavors, affordable but can add up quickly if you buy a starter and desert. But everything was more than worth it. Couldn’t have been more pleased.
Place rating: 5
Columbus, IN
Hands down some of the best pizza N stix I’ve ever had… We drive from Bloomington at least once a month to treat ourselves :)
Place rating: 5
Springville, IN
The breadsticks are wonderful the pizza has excellent topping & crust it is well worth the drive
The staff is awesome a small cute little pizzeria with some of the best pizza I have ever had! Try it!
Place rating: 4
Indianapolis, IN
Now that I’ve been a couple times, I can’t miss this place when visiting my parents who live in the area. The breadsticks are outstanding, and the pizza is freshly-​made! They have a ton of topping choices, and that’s really nice when you’re craving something a little different than your ordinary pizza. They now offer delivery via a third-​party website, but it’s worth the drive if you happen to be anywhere near! I have yet to try their «sammies», but I hear good things from others so I will have to remedy that soon!
Seriously, get the breadsticks. Best decision you’ll ever make.
Place rating: 4
Kokomo, IN
We were on our way north from Bloomington and checked Unilocal for a place to eat. We drove a little out of our way to try this place. I have to say, I was pleased with experience. Looking at the place from outside, I didn’t think my wife would even go in. Thankfully we did and found a very good meal. Twisted breadsticks were awesome, chef salad was very fresh and the chicken was a nice touch. We sampled the hot and barbecue wings which were good and hot, and finally the pizza. The crust was light and the toppings plentiful and the cheese covered it all. Very happy with the meal especially if you can get past the business appearance. A lot of people are going to miss out on a great meal because they will only see a less than commercialized building with no frills or fancy actors pictures. Thank the Lord, America still exists at its finest in Paragon.
Place rating: 5
Indianapolis, IN
Wow, why did I wait so long? Best breadsticks ever — fresh out of the oven, just the right amount of butter ‘n salt, and hot zesty cheese sauce. We had the veggie pizza and added spinach — just borderline on too much cheese, but if that’s your thing, you’ll love it. The crust was crunchy, browned to perfection and the cheese was bubbling when it came to the table. This is the kind of pizza you’d find in the big city — far exceeds Papa and the Hut, even Gatti’s lovers would like this. Gotta go back soon.
Place rating: 5
Asheville, NC
Really good pizza! You simply cannot go wrong here. Their breadsticks are amazing — best I’ve ever had! Yum! I come here every time I’m «home».
Place rating: 5
Mooresville, IN
This little pizza place may be a good trek, but is well worth the drive. Sure it’s small, you won’t find ambience or over the top service, but you will get phenomenal pizza and even better breadsticks. There are no words for these breadsticks. They are fabulous! Strombolis and salads are great, too. (Try the honey mustard!)
Make the drive, and order extras. You’ll want it for breakfast the next morning!
Place rating: 5
Caro, MI
Their pizza is amazing! Super cheesy would ask for half cheese if your not a big cheese fan. Their bread stick remind me of some I would get back home in Michigan – super good, hand twisted great with cheese and Mariana. Was surprised how good the BBQ boneless wings were – not your average frozen out of the bag generic wings. Wish they delivered but its worth the 15 minuet drive. Why I ever ordered from Papa Johns instead of here all these times is beyond me.
Place rating: 5
Indianapolis, IN
Well worth the drive from Avon! As the reviews before stated, the pizza is amazing, great quality cheese and the veggies were crisp and fresh. Breadsticks didn’t need any cheese sauce, hand twisted, baked to perfection, they finish with a brush of delicious garlic butter.
Place rating: 4
Mooresville, IN
Crazy good pizza. Fresh ingredients and perfectly charred crust. The breadsticks were hand twisted, soft and chewy. Service was friendly and helpful with my young boys. Definitely worth the drive. Will be coming back again.