Nima’s Pizza

Loved this place. The staff was friendly as was the owner. My husband got a cheesesteak not expecting much and he loved it. It was huge and well done. We all enjoyed the food. The service was great and we didn’t have to wait long. If I’m in the area, we will definitely be going back there.

The chef cursed me for asking to make a different steak sub… so I walked across the street and Marks pizza did the sub with a smile… do yourself a favor and never ask for a change on their sub’s …

Skip the pizza and get the calzone. Yummy and big enough for two to share. Plates are good here also and you can get a half plate which is nice.

Huge Calzones. Super yummy. A very popular stop when hill cumorah pageant is happening, so if its pageant time… You better be prepared to wait.
There are only 2 pizza choices in Palmyra and Nimas is the best option overall.

It took over an hour to get two pizzas!!! Seriously– it takes 5 min to place toppings on already made dough, 10 min in a extremely hot oven= 15 min total to receive a cooked pizza. The management and staff are inadequately trained to handle amount of people over four tables and it is very obvious. When you know a lot of people are coming to your small town to see the ANNUAL hill cumourah pageant that has been happening for several decades, you should prepare the staff and restaurant for handling rushes especially when you are located in downtown Palmyra. Instead of making the situation better by giving some kind of appetizer to ravenous customers that are cranky for waiting over an hour for pizza, they were non-​apologetic and did NOTHING to make the wait shorter. They put our pizzas in waaaay after at least four tables came and went. What was managements response– to give us a free pizza. While I appreciate the last minute effort, I think the whole situation could have been fixed waaay earlier.
Foodwise, the pizza was decent but after waiting over an hour, any pizza would be good since you are sooo hungry. This place needs to get their BUSINESS together. No pizza is better than NYC pizza but the service was ATROCIOUS! TRAIN your staff! Get your act together!

Agree with Ladd. Huge calzones can easily feed 2. They are quite good, too. Not much choice in Palmyra for food, but you can do a lot worse than Nima’s.

Love love love Nimas. I love that authentic thin crust pizza. The sauce is amazing. I love this place with my whole heart.