A & M Pizza

My boyfriend and I stopped here ¹²⁄₅ after being in the car for 6 – 7 hours and we were STARVING. I LOVE Italian foods so when we found this place we figured we would stop there. Prices were very good. The food was AMAZING! I highly recommend it. The restaurant was kinda empty. Although the only problem I had stopping here was the staff. They were nice but kinda creepy. I’m not sure if they were bored or what. I would recommend this restaurant if anyone is in that area.

Best pizza in the county, hands down. The staff has gone down hill and you can get lucky or bummed out depending on who handles your food. Amazing sub rolls. Fresh baked daily with a perfect mix between soft and crusty. Pizza is great with great amounts of cheese, again depending who makes it.
Dinners are standard, not to rave about. If they had delivery, they would dominate the Palmyra and Hershey.

Worst pizza shop I’ve ever been too and will never come back! I’m not a local to this a&m but was on my way to an auction in grantville and needed somewhere to eat quick at the auction started at 1pm and it was already 12:30! I ordered a small veggie hoagie (as I don’t eat meat from places that I’ve never been to before) and my buddy ordered two plain slices. The hoagie I ordered was disgusting as they put a quarter of an inch of mayo on each side of the roll and the vegetables were 100% canned veggies and they were soaking wet from the juice from the can, trust me I know my vegetables I’m from Lancaster and have a 6,000 sq. ft. garden of my own. The only thing I can say that was good was the roll, as it seamed like it was baked in house and it was moist and had good flavor, too bad it was soaked in mayo and therefore I could only eat the ends! My buddy that was with me was enjoying his two slices until he found a hair sticking out of one of the slices. Needless to say we both threw away 75% of our meals and left discussed, please don’t be patrons of such a place! They do not care about the quality of food they are serving! I don’t understand why such an establishment even exists.

Two of the worst slices of pizza that I have ever had. The pizza consisted of pretty much no sauce and a huge thick clump of cheese that had absolutely no taste.
If you use a credit card under $ 10.00 they charge you a .50 fee. Also fountain drink refills are .80. Horrible horrible pizza and very customer unfriendly /​cheapskates.

Standard pizza & sub takeout, with plenty of options. I tend to get stick with the pizza, which is mighty tasty.

The food is good at this place but the quality is INCONSISTENT. I normally ask for pizza a little darker. One time, they burnt it. Another time, one side of the pizza was cooked but the other side was under cooked. Sometimes, the cheese on the pizza is unevenly distributed. It isn’t a bad place to eat but don’t expect to get the same quality always.

Love this place! We stayed in Palmyra for a baseball tournament and spontaneously stopped here for a bite to eat and got very lucky. Everything we tried was good… Italian sub, pizza and chicken salad were all great. Service was very friendlyand quick and the prices were very reasonable. We actually stopped there twice during our weekend stay… it was that good.

I used to be a regular here, but as the staff has slowly changed, the quality of the food has gone down. Most things are greasy and the sauce is watery and has no flavor.
Even more an issue, the attitude of the young men at the counter is TERRIBLE. The last time we ordered take out, it was made pretty obvious that it was a major inconvenience for them to ring up my order and hand it to me. There are way too many pizza joints in Palmyra to bother spending any more money here.

This is the go to place for me and my friend whenever I visit home. I feel like it has become more of a habit than a testament to how amazing the food is. The menu is HUGE and if anyone has watched Kitchen Nightmares sometimes having such an extensive menu is not necessarily a good thing.
We always always always get the rigatoni with meat sauce meal. It’s your typical stuff and tastes you know, okay. The sauce is a little reminiscent of Chef Boyardee in that there aren’t any actual tomatoes and gives off a much more tomato-​pastey sort of consistency. Again, I think it’s more of a nostalgia thing with us. The other day we tried to branch out of our comfort zone and got turkey subs. They were crazy salty and had way too much mustard in it. It was kind of a disappointment.
In terms of sides, I’ve only tried the fries and they’re you know, typical fries. The prices are pretty decent though. It’s a fun place if you just want to sit and chat and get some cheap food.
The wait is usually pretty decent too. We went during a lunch rush once and waited about 15 minutes for food. Generally the wait is normally 5 – 10 minutes

we do not live in the area but stop here every time we pass through! the friendliest staff we have ever encountered. great customer service goes a long way. :)

Eating here for several years but disappointed the last few visits. Tonight’s experience included: spaghetti that took twenty minutes to make — it came out ten minutes after the rest of our food; thousand island dressing that tasted spoiled; a hair in my salad; too hot in the building (this is always, always, always a problem); less than enthusiastic and borderline rude employees (and this wasn’t the case in previous years — new management?); so-​so food. Not thrilled and not returning anytime soon. Bummed out.

Been going here for over two years (usually weekly). Always friendly smiles and a greeting. The place is always clean… or being cleaned. They don’t waste any time on keeping a good appearance. The beer coolers are always full unless they are out of something, but that rarely happens. They have the BEST beer to-​go prices around (single bottle to 12 packs). The food is great and it is the best in the area. They have turned me into a loyal customer!

Soggy crust, flavorless pizza.
They make you feel like you are bothering them when you walk in to order.
We drive 2 miles past this place to go to another pizzaria. if you think this is good pizza you don’t know real Italian food.

A great restaurant! My husband and I recently moved to Palmyra and have already been here twice. The 12 inch spinach calzone was delicious. LOTS of cheese and spinach for $ 6.45. Their chicken cheesesteak is awesome. The pizza was good too. We got a hawaiian. a medium was $ 10.95. Although there wasn’t much pineapple to speak of.
Customer service wasn’t too shabby and the atmosphere was comfy. great place to grab some pizza or can get it to go. I haven’t tried anything else but they also have hot subs, burgers, pasta, dinners, etc. Pretty big menu. Give it a try!

My neighborhood pizza place. I highly recommend it to anyone. Gizmo subs, pizza, meatball subs, and large greek salads… its hard to go wrong. Havent tasted everything on the menu yet tho…
Plenty of seating, staff is very friendly and also multilingual. That could be good or bad.

I had the cheese pizza here and boy was it good! The crust was thin and the cheese was gooey– you just can’t go wrong with that.
The only thing that I don’t like is the 50 cent refills on fountain drinks.