Sagamore Liquors

Oyster Bay, United States

2

5 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 516-922-9490
Address:
257 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY, 11771
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
1.1 miOyster Bay
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes

Today

Today –
Local time (Oyster Bay) 22:13 Thursday, 26 June 2025

Business hours

Monday –
Tuesday –
Wednesday –
Thursday –
Friday –
Saturday –
Sunday –

Related places

You might also consider:
2.7
mi
Wine Markets International
170 Berry Hill Rd
2.9
mi
Grand Wine Cellar
40 Cold Spring Rd
2.9
mi
The Wine Special-List
16 Split Rock Rd
3.1
mi
Syosset Discount Wines & Liquor
119 Jackson Ave
3.3
mi
Our Hobby Liquors
35 Ludlam Ave
3.4
mi
Marquis Liquors
29 Birch Hill Rd

Nearby

Near this location:
1
ft
Pine Hollow Cleaners
259 Pine Hollow Rd
1
ft
New 4-U Nails
263 Pine Hollow Rd
110
ft
Morgan Gentry’s
129 Pine Hollow Rd
130
ft
McDonalds 12104 Sullivan
245 Pine Hollow Rd
130
ft
McDonald’s
245 Pine Hollow Rd
220
ft
Sprint Store at RadioShack
179 Pine Hollow Rd

5 reviews of Sagamore Liquors

No registration required
Place rating: 2
New York, NY
This is your average liquor store it is somewhat clean and has a decent selection for how small it is but the staff is very unfriendly when I asked for a specific bottle one of the two gentlemen at front just pointed against the wall on the right side and said go look it’s there. That is kind of obnoxious you should have just come out from behind the register and showed me like they do in most liquor shops especially since there was another worker with him. In addition the prices are pretty high but that is kind of expected in an area like this.
I only stopped by here to pick something up for a party and probably won’t return. I would have given a higher review if the workers were nicer.
Place rating: 1
Oyster Bay, NY
Not only is the place overpriced, the cashier/​owner overcharges beyond the listed price. Paid twice as much as the sticker said and realized it only when left the store. Will never go back.
Place rating: 3
Greenlawn, NY
Little overpriced, but go down the street and you’ll find the prices are the same. It is oyster bay… Can’t comment on service, as I usually know what I want.
Place rating: 3
Huntington, NY
We needed some supplies for an upcoming party and decided to give Sagamore Liquors a try. We found a local coupon for 10% off on orders over $ 15. (this coupon can also be gotten on the back of nearby Stop-​n-​Shop receipts). Prices were above average but that’s par for the course in Oyster Bay. We asked the man behind the counter to point us in the direction of various items and he showed where they were. Overall, a bit pricey but a decent experience, none the less.
Place rating: 1
Oyster Bay, NY
Overpriced (isn’t everything in Oyster Bay?) and the guy at the register has no clue.
I had to go in there for an emergency bottle of something during one of my bbq’s and some poor lady was asking the dolt behind the counter what kind of wines went with this or that — he had no clue what wine is apparently.
I set her straight and do you think the guy bothers to say anything like thank you? Nothing — just a blank stare. Couldn’t even toss me 5% off for the help? Loser.
I’m never going in there again.