Original Anthonys Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Pizza pretty good. Margarita pizza very good. New bone out chicken wings were horrible. Overdone chicken tenders with sauce on the side.

This is our favorite place in central Florida for white pizza! When we get it delivered it always arrives fairly quickly and is nice and hot. I highly recommend!

I cant wait to order another Calzone! I have a auto repair business down the road and they asked if we could do a little welding for them, it was simple and did not charge them, in return they brought us 2 amazing pizza’s. They have earned our business and we are happy to welcome them to the community.

Can’t say enough BEST CAPRESE E. V. E. R. All else is very good but the Caprese is to die for and I get it every time I visit.

First thought: They seemed to be understaffed. It was a Friday night during the dinner rush and the service was friendly. Food was good. I had a calzone and my husband had the chicken parmesan. His could have had more chicken and less pasta. Garlic knots were delicious.

This is my favorite place for quick Italian food! The pizza is awesome and we order take out from them frequently. I have eaten most of the pasta dishes and they are great too. Friendly servers some of whom I know by name. The owner goes from table to table to inquire about the quality of your food, etc. That’s a plus for me. Lunch specials are offered during the week. Highly recommended but they could cool off the dining room, it’s usually warm from the pizza ovens.

If you like Calzone this is the place to order from. They make the best I have ever had the pleasure to eat. Their half order is great for a single meal, but you will probably be sorry you didn’t order a large so you can have some too eat again tomorrow! You won’t be sorry you tried them.

Been here 5 or 6 times since they’ve opened this past year. We’ve been happy every time.

Ordered a fully loaded sicilian for $ 24. Dough tasted like it had freezer burn and ruined the entire pizza. Did not taste fresh at all. Very dissapointing.

Best Pizza in Oviedo. Servers and staff are friendly and attentive. Pizza is great, garlic knots are awesome. I would have given 5 stars but it’s consistently 78 – 80 degrees inside the dining room. Turn the air down!!!

I’ve been in this restaurant before and the food was great. When I was in last night, this was a totally different story. I ordered two items, diet Coke and a pizza slice. The diet Coke was terrible and when I received three different glasses, it was BAD. The last diet Coke, I was informed the one cook ‘poured it straight out of the bottle’. All I know, it wasn’t diet Coke. I ordered a slice of cheese pizza. I arrived in the restaurant before 7p.m. and when I asked where my order was twenty minutes later, I was advised they were ‘busy’ in the kitchen. When I did get the slice, it was burnt on the bottom. All in all, it was a bad last experience. No, I wasn’t given a break on anything. I paid full price and didn’t have the time to argue with the employees. I would not recommend this place. They are normally very good but not this time.

Read about Anthony’s online and decided to order from here one evening. As a born and raised New Yorker I’ve spent several years in Florida searching for great pizza.
1^st Star — When we arrived to place our order we were greeted quickly by a member of the staff and directed to the counter. The menu was explained to us and they basically said we can make the pizza however you’d like. After ordering our pizza for take out, they offered us a booth to sit in and took our drink order so we wouldn’t be parched while we waited for our food to be ready to take home. Very thoughtful gesture. Very much appreciated.
2^nd Star — They know their stuff. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been to pizza places down in Florida when you ask them: «How big is the pizza?» and they tell you: «This size is cut into four/​six/​eight/​ten slices». That is NOT right. Genuine, authentic pizza is 8 slices every time. It is the diameter of the pizza that determines the size of the slice. Anthony’s knew their stuff. When I gave out my test question, they replied: «The medium pizza is 8, 14″ slices and it’s perfect for two people to split». On that basis alone, I knew this pizza would be delicious.
3^rd Star — The night that we arrived the place was busy and had clearly hosted a large party of 20 or so. They were cleaning up the dining room. My boyfriend and I were just waiting for take out and the waitress asked if it would be okay if she cleaned the table next to us because she didn’t want to interrupt us. Very thoughtful. Very appreciated. We didn’t mind at all.
4^th Star — The pizza was cooked to perfection. We had Veggie Lovers and added sausage and pepperoni. I would not recommend take out for only one reason — you have to resist the smell of the delicious pizza all the way home. Loaded with toppings the crust did not break, the cheese did not slide off. The pie was fresh, crisp and heavenly.
5^th Star — Parking for this location was easy. There were a ton of parking spaces available right outside the store front. I loved that they gave a magnet instead of a menu to take home (they offer both if menu’s are your thing) because a magnet on the fridge is much easier access for our household.
I’ll definitely be returning here and highly recommend that you give them a try.

Clean and super friendly staff, my sons pizza was a little cold but mine was fine so I’m gonna chalk it up to that he is a little guy and they didnt want his too hot. Overall its a decent place for a quick bite

Not impressed. Stopped in on a Saturday at 11 am. I was the second person in the restaurant with my dad. Guy came and took the drink order, get the drinks and order one 12 inch Hawaiian and two slices of cheese. Really simple. We didn’t get our food for 35 minutes, which on a Saturday with two tables is ridiculous. Couldn’t even enjoy my drink because there was some sort of oily film on the water, and trying to track down the waiter for some help was not working. Disappointed in the place, I always look for the local options when dining out and thought this may be a real hit. Pizza was ok but nothing spectacular. The film on the water really threw me a curve and killed the whole vibe. Not unwilling to try again but it will be a while till they sort out some service issues.

Great food and service! Not only is the pizza great but the entrees are fantastic. Whenever I order delivery the drivers are always very nice and respectful. I love this place and would encourage anyone to go. It’s a friendly neighborhood pizza restaurant and I hope is never goes away.

Ordered here again, second time didn’t get knots we had ordered them. They asked if they could substitute italian bread for them. We waited over fifteen minutes from when they told us it would be ready, and they didnt have knots ready. We did see knots go to a table while we were waiting, they dont appear to set the food aside properly. Also they don’t estimate time food is going to be ready good at all.
The food for the most part is good, only one time a cheese pizza was really doughy and undercooked, while the pepperoni was fine.
I would avoid ordering from them on a Friday, and Saturday they had a takeout line of twenty people the other day. A lot of pissed off people with no food. So I would recommend off hours, and don’t expect your food to be ready when they tell you.

Ate here last week for the first time. I got the wings and fries that were very good. My son got a chicken parmigiana sub which he loved. My wife got raviolis and she really liked them. Service was a little slow and the beer selection is not great. We would repeat