Casey’s General Store

This place is sub par in my opinion. Most of the staff are nice and friendly but the daytime manager (tall, red curly hair) has a real attitude. My wife asked for help on purchasing some lotto tickets and the manager acted like she didn’t want to be bothered with anyone. Needless to say, you will not have to worry about helping us anymore.

I shouldn’t even be giving this store a one star rating. Went there for the first time I Drive to my parents about the donuts so we decided to go try we’re extremely disappointed and contacted the company. They sent us a coupon for free donuts so we decided to give it another try. They advertised even on their board for the cake donut with vanilla icing and sprinkles which both times we have gone they never had. The donuts were disappointing they tasted like they were made 2 days before I will never be returning ever again. I have always had a great experience at other caseys stores but the one on 135^th in Overland Park sucks. They need to make changes or the store will go out of business and I know I will not be returning as well as any of my family and friends. They have lost our business. Thank God for Lamar’s.

Just drove out of my way for some pizza which this place is known for and all they have is 3 old pieces. They have 3 warming cabinets and those 3 sorry pieces are the only thing they have. My workers and I are very disappointed in this brand new location.

This new location offers custom built subs, burgers, pizzas, pizza by the slice, soft-​serve ice cream, and a wide variety of coffees. On my first visit, two pizza slices and a drink cost just $ 5.29. My pepperoni pizza slice was especially tasty, yet not too greasy. The service was friendly, and the interior was clean. This could be a great stop for a quick bite or a refuel 24/​7, but on my second visit to this location to pick up some pepperoni slices, I found the pizza by the slice cases (which can hold approximately twelve pizzas) empty except for three sausage slices. Several other people were waiting for pizza or subs. I’m dropping my rating two stars from five to three.