Tilly’s Tavern

just there… watered for 45 min for a cup of soup and one half of chickgin wings
owner cane out a customeromers
nd told us to Leave… he is the has to make his verservisers to pay for HIS fuck ups… Tillys owners are a PIS… good for u… maybe u should care about your customers… or not
villy NEVER go there again
the «owner «is a PIS

Andrew M’s «hit or miss» comment was spot on. My largest gripe with this place is the inconsistent, dismissive and careless staff (some of them, not all — mainly the young girls).
Also, if you’re very hungry don’t order any sandwiches. They aren’t all that cheap, and the cook/​staff puts VERY little meats, etc. in them. I complain almost every time I order a sandwich, and only one waitress took my sandwich (Reuben) to have more meats, etc. added. My little kids make heartier sandwiches. No joke.
BUT…
We love this for some strange reason. The food (especially the fish) is all very tasty, they have off-​sale beer/​wine/​liquor, and the patrons are a good bunch. We also like the atmosphere. We’re pretty loyal to Tilly’s even with their pansy-​like sandwiches, and just order different stuff now. Overall, it’s convenient and we enjoy supporting our local mom-​and-​pops, so to speak, rather than corporate chain restaurants. But Tilly’s still needs to get some things right.

We have been here twice now and very happy with both visits. Our first, was just my Wife and I. Very good food and extremely great service. Atmosphere was very down homey. Our 2^nd visit we brought our 2 year old daughter with. They were short staffed this day, but you could not tell. Our waitress, being extremely busy, went above and beyond. She made our Daughters meal first and let it cool. Lily was very happy with her meal. As were my wife and I. Tilly’s has become our new local regular spot! Keep up the great work!

i have to update because Tilly’s is under new ownership yet again… and this time I honestly noticed that there was just a little bit more sparkle to the place… so they obviously did a good cleaning and are keeping it tidy.
They have fresh breaded mushrooms so we ordered those and they were really good… a little on the salty side but I guess that encourages you to drink more…
I wanted a big ginger drink but again another bar that can’t keep some cans of ginger ale… so I settled for coke as a mixer.
They do have Stella beer on tap —and serve it in the right glass…
Glad this place is hanging on and making a go of it…

I’ve tried Tilly’s three times now. Every time we’ve gone, it was with another couple that just love the place and visit all the time. My first visit I had a burger and it could have been in my top 10 burgers of all time. It was great! Second time, hoping for the same experience, ordered a burger again and it may have been the worst I’ve ever had. Way over cooked and ultra dry. Third visit last nite I tried the beef nachos. Plenty of toppings but the beef tasted like they bought it from Taco Bell and added a bunch of salt so they could call it their own. Also, it wasn’t a very large order. Noticed the menu offered a half order and wondered if they made me a half order by mistake but charged me for a full order. If they didn’t screw it up and that was a full order, the half should be on the kid’s menu it was so small. My wife had a chicken sandwich that she said she really liked but with it she ordered cheese fries, and they forgot the cheese. By the time she pointed it out, the crowd had picked up and there ended up being a bit of a wait to get new. I like the bar’s look with it’s brick walls and wood floor. They also have a small patio for dining. Just wondering if they should change their name to Hit or Miss because you really don’t know how your visit’s going to turn out.

One waitress working on mother’s day. What was management thinking?? People walking out not being served

Awesome food! Awesome staff! Awesome atmosphere!
I would give it 5 stars, but the location is a bit of a downer. I think they’d do great a little closer to Rochester.