Lennys New York Pizza Company

Have gone here a few times, and ordered take out a few as well. This last visit was the last straw, new to down here, but regardless, the service was awful. The «server» had a cocky attitude about himself that was uncalled for, took too long to get the order which he cut me off while ordering, 15 minutes later I’m finally seeing our drinks after placing the order. The poor girl he had working as a server was following him around like a wore out puppy cleaning up his messes. I felt bad for her, lack of service was huge! Then because there was lack of service, every time the server was trying to do one task another table would flag her down before she could continue to do another… took way to long! It’s a shame because the food is great. I’ve ordered delivery before and it’s come to me lukewarm. Time to find another pizzeria.

Unreal! Lenny’s pizza is thee best hands down. It’s far from our house, several towns away so we stumbled upon it late one night last year… This guy made us a pie PAST closing time when he was closing up. Told the guys to stop and head back in to make us a take out and it was freakin’ awesome.
Every time we go back, these people CARE about the food and service. Delicious, clean and the prices are the best.
Lenny’s doesn’t try to rip you off like Everrry single place peddling a 16 inch pizza calling it an extra large, for seventeen bucks!
Lenny’s has a 24 inch pizza! Oh my goooooodness!
They also serve slices as big as your head and THAT’S the way pizza should be! And, their ginormous pizza is priced like other’s tiny useless pizzas!
We are going to try the dinners that look incredible while gliding by us in the dining room and seem to please all those enjoying them, and portions look really nice too!

This is by far my favorite pizza in the area and is the only place I’ll ever get pizza from! Lenny’s has really brought the New York slice right to us in Ormond beach, and thank god. The bad wrap Florida has when it comes to pizza really stands true– especially to a New Yorker, so Lenny’s real
New York style pizza is heaven sent. It stands next to some of the best NYC pizza I’ve had. Lenny’s is also In my opinion home to THE BEST buffalo chicken slice I’ve ever had– it’s sweet and spicy– you have to try it and you’ll be obsessed too. Not only are their slices huge and amazing but the Italian food is not like other pizza places Italian foods with cheap ingredients and sauce that tastes like it came out of jar. It compares to some of the best Italian restaurants in the area. I’ve had the chicken parm, lasagna and ravioli that are all made with quality ingredients and taste like the best homemade you’ve ever had. You also need to try there burger with cheese and caramelized onions that is wrapped in dough and baked as the bun– need a say more. I also got to meet Lenny himself! I love the food so much I was so happy I got to meet the man behind all the magic. There was a mess up with my order and Lenny could not do enough to accommodate for the confusion, it is nice to see a business owner that is as professional as Lenny and cares for his customers satisfaction the way he does. Not only will the food exceed all expectations but you will feel like a welcomed and appreciated customer that will keep coming back!

I’ve only ordered to-​go, but if you want the biggest pizza in FL this is the place! Their extra large is like over the top gigantic, but it’s perfect! We
Ordered a simple cheese, and we had left overs for days!!! Great pizza!

Disappointing. The «garlic knots» are just dinner rolls covered in garlic butter. Had the meat lovers calzone and it was cold all the way thru. Surprisingly because it took long to be serviced. Won’t be back. DaVinci’s is much better.

Have been here several times in the past months. Pizza used to be seriously outstanding. Last night? Ehhh, ok. Service is always friendly, hence the 3^rd star. I still think the staff is too casual… on many levels. The big downside last night, besides the just ok pizza (which I can’t put my finger on why), was that the staff was outside the kitchen door smoking. … and the smoke wafted into the dining room the entire time we were there. Not very appetizing. We do love the house salad and dressing!

Great pizza last night. Super friendly owner. Some of the best pie locally. Great Subs too. Dine in or pick up. Almost as good as Petes. In Ormond you can’t go wrong wit Lenny’s pizza. Fuggedabout the rest.

My boyfriend is OBSESSED with Lenny’s pizza, (i’m not a huge pizza fan) but he finally got me to go and 1. garlic knots = AMAZING and 2. Sicilian pizza (since I am not too huge on thin crust) = AMAZING. Not only that but we had 3 different waitresses/​waiters making sure our drinks were always full and that we were satisfied. I love when we find great service and this place has it! Will come again. Also. our dinner was $ 12!!! Two drinks, two pizza slices (they’re huge), & half order of garlic knots and we were stuffed.

Passes every NY pizza test we have :) great for kids too – giving them dough to play with while waiting. House salad – fresh, real lettuce and big portion! We will be making this a regular spot — even with the drive from Palm Coast :)

Great food and friendly staff. Waited 45 minutes for our dinner. The downside was the darn flies flying all over the restaurant! Waitress said it was because the a/​c was broken and the kitchen door had to be left open. The problem with that is it was pretty cold in the restaurant and I could feel the a/​c blowing on my neck! Wonder if flies are a health hazard? Next time we will order takeout.

This is the Best NYC pizza! You can either order by the slice or sit down. The have the best large salads and can’t forget garlic knots. Yum!

Went to Lenny’s for the first time and it was NOT a good experience. Walked in to guys cursing each other out in the kitchen and customers who had been waiting TWO hours for their pizza. I tried to look past the profanity but the managers attitude was HORRIBLE. I leaned to my fiancé and said maybe we should come back and try it another night and the MANAGER over heard me and replied MAYBE YOU SHOULD… *FLAG ON THE PLAY*!!! I’ll NEVER come back again!!!

Heard great things about this place, so we had to come. Place was pretty busy as it is a Saturday night. The food in the display looked good and it smelled even better. While waiting to order, started hearing the kitchen crew cursing at each other and arguing. Oven doors were slammed and slick remarks.
The cashier tried to make a joke saying, dinner and a a show but it was not humerous. The manager came to the register asking a customer for his ticket as he had been waiting for 2 hours. The manager was yelling at the kitchen staff that he has given away too much food tonight. My fiancé leaned over to me saying that maybe we should come another day. The manager barged in saying, yes you should. Don’t know if we will ever go back to try the food.

Really huge slices! The taste of the pizza was good. Everyone k. Our group enjoyed what they had. The iced tea tastes like powdered instant Lipton rather than fresh brewed. Other than that, no complaints.

I ordered my Pizza exactly 8:11.20 pm it FINALLY arrived at 9:36 we’ve waited well over an hour and live 4 streets down. It arrived cold and old looking. The crust hard as a rock. HIGHLY DISAPPOINTED in this. I called and a guy named Greg answered and I told him that we are unhappy and what can he do about it. He said «oh, well next time let me know and I’ll take care of it» thanks how about right now?! Oh wait you closed already and didn’t give a crap! NEVER AGAIN WILL WE ORDER FROM YOU! How about that Greg? Thanks for pissing my pregnant wife and I off.

In town for a few days from Jersey for a visit. We decided for something quick and take out. Best thing we did was pick Lenny’s! We had the margherite pie and garlic knots. My husband is a New Yorker and was not happy too get pizza in Florida but one bite and he was proved wrong! Next time we are in the area this is on our list of must dos!

Ordered a large pizza and garlic knots for take out was told 45 minutes. Left and came back to pick up about 40 minutes later. Was told they couldn’t find the order then they found it said the garlic knots were ready but the pizza would be another 20 minutes!!! Luckily we only live down the road. Went back and still had to wait about 15 more minutes. Very disappointed the pizza was not fully cooked. Didn’t have a good crust just soggy.

Let me first start with the pizza. The new yorker in me was in heaven. It’s hearty and flavorful. I loved it. The garlic knots are epic. The staff is super friendly (my server was Jeremy, he was great) and as a foodie, it feels like whoever made this food truly loves to do it. They brought my table the Buffalo and gorgonzola to try and I wished i had another stomach to put a full order in. Most of all, the atmosphere is very nice. Very well decorated, a great place for families. Go immediately if you want some great pizza. I’m going to be a regular.

Incredible food with huge portions. The garlic knots are amazing!
My table ordered stromboli, lasagna and chicken parm, all of which were great. The atmosphere is casual and the owner was frequently seen visiting tables and ensuring a great product. I will definitely be back and make this my go-​to Italian place in the area. Great work guys!

Don’t sleep on this place.
Opened 6÷23÷14
Right next to Dunkin Donuts which is great.
The pies taste like Beachside Lenny’s.
Big New York pies. All of the ones I have tried have been wonderful.
I tend to get the slices.
People I know get goosebumps about the buffalo chicken.
When asked, they don’t use a special water from New York :).
If they get enough demand they will bring gluten free crust as well as ravioli.