Lil’ Anthony’s

Very good pizza. My only gripe with it is it’s a little expensive but quite worth it for the quality of the food. I would recommend this place to a friend.

Love trying local places over big chain. Sad this one failed in taste, portion, and quality. My calzone tasted mediocre and it was not cooked all the way. It was Very doughy and cold! My wife’s fettuccine alfredo was seasoned with pure ground pepper killing any sweetness an alfredo sauce should incorporate. Her portion size was a side order, but paid for full size dinner. Cheesey Garlic Knots were also doughy and barely had any cheese. I was there 3 years ago and the food was not that great. Figured we would try again and got the same result. Over $ 50 spent and wouldve got same result from a frozen t.v. dinner.

Ok well, I’m from NJ… I’m used to a specific way of cooking Pizza. In the oven, or in a brick oven. Lil Anthony’s is a bit different. They use this big, multi tier, spinning oven, that spits out a whole pie in 10 minutes. Literally, I waited there and it was done in 10 minutes.
This is great if your in a rush, don’t get me wrong… but you really don’t get that true pizza flavor that you may be used to. The crust doesnt get as crunchy. It basically blast bakes the pie (Not too far off from Domino’s or Papa Johns when it comes to the way it’s cooked). Like I said, I am from a state that specializes in Pizza, so I don’t mean to come across as harsh. Their pizza is good, just not great.
The service is good and everyone that works there is friendly. They are conveniently located next to a Walmart Market, Starbucks, and a few other food places. They offer lots of indoor seating at tables, or even booths. The restaurant itself seems clean and new.
I hate to knock the pizza because Lil Anthonys is a nice little spot, and the staff is friendly, but I can’t agree with flash baking a pizza pie. In my opinion, Pizza should be cooked slowly over 20 or so minutes, in a regular pizza oven, or brick oven. If you are in a rush, though, definitely stop here for a pie. They’ll have it out for you in minutes, and who knows, you may not be as picky as I am when it comes to a good pie.

This is an excellent spot to get a great slice of NY style pizza. I got a slice of sausage and was very impressed. The crust was just right. The sauce is good. They have lots of good lunch specials. The employees are helpful and courteous as well.
I’m also happy with the décor all the way to the restroom area. A little piece of NY and Italy in Florida.

Just moved to the area and me being from NY, I couldn’t say no to pizza that wasn’t from a big franchise. I think I went there around 7p to get a «slice.» No such thing at that time there. The guy tells me to get a slice I have to come before 4:30p. Laughable. I left and never been back since.

First time here. Ordered a pepperoni pizza to go. It was delicious! The whole family devoured it. :-)

I liked the friendly service that I received. They have a fairly priced lunch menu ranging from 3.99 up to about 7 bucks with different options. Most places stop lunch specials at 2 but you can get a special here until 3pm so that’s nice. The garlic no knots are soft and fluffy! Very good!

The menu was very appealing and sounded very appetizing to me. We ordered delivery, and the delivery man came in a reasonable time. The downfall was the pizza itself. We got the don tomisano Pizza. The base of the pizza is the dough and how it is cooked. With that said, it was doughy, raw, and not fully cooked. Sloppy and not properly executed. The place has a lot of potential, but the quality lacks. I don’t think I’ll be ordering from here again. I’m a great supporter of local businesses and mom and pop eateries, but if it’s not up to par I’m not wasting my time or money. Marcos pizza here I come!

This place is LEGIT! I ate what was probably one of the best calzones I’ve ever eaten (Cheesesteak Calzone) and the red chili wings (I ordered them extra crispy) were amazing! The only thing that I thought was average was the ranch dressing they used. It wasn’t bad at all, just not extra tasty and a little thin.

12.99 for a small calzone that comes with a really small cup of marinara sauce that barely covers the calzone. They charge an extra $ 1.00 for additional marinara. $ 10.00 for 10 wings. prices seem high to me. Food is good but not worth the prices.

Very poor service. ordered pizza at 7pm was told an hour wait, called back at 8:30 they said the guy just left 5 mins ago so should have been delivered by 8:45 at the most. 9 pm still no pizza.
They should have been honest upfront about the wait so that I could have gone to subway instead of having my children whine about when the pizza was getting here.

Best pizza in town! Outstanding service and fantastic atmosfhere. I tried the bianca pizza and really there is not other like this. Great for party events! The real italian pizza!!!

First time here. Had lunchchicken parmigian with pasta for lunch. Lunch special has it with fries. What is that about?
odd that Lunch Special With Fries No salad is $ 8.99 While Lunch Parm With Pasta and salad Is $ 7.99.
Salad was chopped and covered ½ of the plate. No attempt to hide the fact that there was really nothing there.
Serving came out on a salad plate. That’s how small it is. At best the chicken is ¹⁄₃ of a breast. I cut it into 4 bite size pieces. Asked what happened to the chicken with no response.
They didn’t honor posted discount.
Last I will come here for lunch. May never be here for dinner after this experience.

Best Pizza in the 32 828 area code. Service is always prompt and friendly and sometimes call when your order’s ready. Awesome pizza, sauce is tasty, crust is delicious. My only gripe is the toppings are sometimes inadequate (small amounts) but otherwise never an issue.

I work in the area so I decided to call and place an order for lunch. The telephone was answered with a automated greeting which I found odd. Are they really that busy? Okay, so when I did get a real person, the service was good. I placed my order and they surprisingly called to let me know it was ready for pick up. Nice touch!
I ordered Chicken Parm. The serving was quite large. It ended up being enough for lunch and dinner. They service side salad, which was a bit small, but tasty. Their bread was exceptional, hot, tasty and with lots of garlic.
I would visit again.

When we first moved to Avalon thought this was the pizza place in town even had family from out of town agree but lately the quality of food has gone down hill. Not sure what has changed but not a top choice any more for pizza.

Super delicious! The inside is gorgeous and the service was amazing. I have only been here once but I will definitely be coming back! :)

WORST CHEESESTEAK EVER!!!
Would give zero if I could.
30 min wait for 2 subs AND it cost $ 23 for 2 subs?! Sub was ALL bread barely any meat and that was dried out. Mayo came in the form of packets. Only reason I didnt take back was because my daughter had picked them up for us to eat while watching the football game and I did not eat anything all day so I was so hungry I didn’t care at that point and just ate my sub. I regret now that i did, since my daughter did not get a receipt because she paid in cash? So we had no proof or food to return and get money back. Bottom line, i hope this place goes out of business and something better moves in.

We 1^st came in here 3 years ago when we 1^st moves from NYC… and it has consistently been good pizza. Beats the Dominos and Pizza Hut that my husband and son like to order. The garlic knots are really good although on occasion they skimp on the garlic.
I have yet to try any of their entrees but will get to it.

The atmosphere is inviting and comfortable. The service was just perfect. Asked the right questions about my order to be sure it would be to my liking.
The food… Yes the garlic knots are amazing but the lasagna was heavenly. Perfectly put together with sauce and cheese just right. The side salad was fresh, and I’m very picky about my salads.
Waitress took some time to chat with me maybe because I was alone but either way she was delightful and kind. I will certainly return next week when my son arrives.