Bottle Values

They have my favorite wine from the North Fork at an INSANELY discounted price! While you will not find every single brand of wine or spirit, you will find a GREAT price on what they do have, and a knowledgeable staff to boot!
The shopping center’s parking lot is a JOKE, so take caution peeps, but worth the hassle!!! 50% savings over the same bottle from the winery that is all the way out east =‘s I’ll make the closer drive to Bottle Values and save the cash!!!

My new favorite local store. Huge place. Tastings all the time helpful staff. New wines all the time and good prices. The only complaint is the selection. While there r tons of wines I have often found what I want is not there

With a great selection and even better prices, you can’t go wrong with Bottle Values.
The employees and management are phenomenal.
Every person went out of their way to help me choose the perfect single malt scotch.
Thanks!

This is literally the Costco of liquors, its awesome. Everything had a discount on it whether it was a rebate or money off through the store. The staff was also super nice. I am literally never going back to another liquor store again!

This store is to liquor stores what Costco is to a dollar store. Massive sections containing more wines and liquors then I have ever seen in one place. The store is broken up into massive aisles with super market style identifiers for the various types of liquors in each section. Every time an employee passed us we were asked if we needed help and all seemed EXTREMELY knowledgeable about everything throughout the store.
The prices were also fantastic, having a number of options in many categories to match our party budget. We had a great experience and look forward to coming back to do a wine tasting.

This place is great! Huge selection, clean and good to great prices. I had a recent experience there where I purchased a bottle of single malt scotch. I typically enjoy Macallan 12 & 18 year but I was intrigued by a new brand they had on the shelf so I purchased it. I opened it up before dinner and it was hands down the worst liquor of any variety I have ever tasted! My son who recently graduated college and has consumed some of the worst alcohol during his frat days wouldn’t go near it. In fact, if I spoke within three feet of him after I sipped the scotch he’d jump away and tell me to get away! Anyway, you get the point it was that awful. I have never thought of returning unopened anything in the past much less an opened bottle! But throwing out $ 40 like this was really eating at me and I couldn’t even give it away. So I called Bottle Values knowing there’s no way they would take it back and to my incredible surprise they cheerfully said no problem for a credit or an exchange! I was stunned and went back for my Macallan and a few other items. They’re my go to liquor store from now on. BTW, I consider this a mulligan and I don’t plan on making the return thing a habit.

At first glance this place looks like a perfect warehouse-​style wine & liquor store — bright, clean, new furnishings, cheerful staff. However what makes this type of store work for the smart consumer are 1) attention to quality of product and 2) pricing, and this store fails on both counts. Lately I’ve been favoring cheap Italian whites & so I picked up a couple of bottles of $ 9 pinot grigio. I didn’t expect much, but this was overpriced rotgut. I expect the buyers to supply me with decent stuff at a decent price — and the prices of the booze I checked out was barely competitive. You’re better off paying a little bit more at some strip mall liquor store.

Bottle Values is by far the best wine/​liquor store on Long Island. Great prices and variety and helpful/​knowledgeable store managers and staff are just a few things that make them stand out from the hundreds of other wine and liquor stores on LI.

Updating my review and this place only gets better. They have extended their inventory of Bourbon and Single Malts and improved the selection of wines. They also have frequent tastings and events. Prices remain very good.

LOVE THIS PLACE!
If you really love wine, you would enjoy going here. The prices are better than anywhere else hands down. My favorite wine to drink is Menage Trois Red Blend because it really is a great value wine. Typically you will spend $ 10 for a bottle, here it is always 6.99 a bottle. To find a red wine that I can have with dinner for that cheap, I will take it by the case.
My bf bought Johnnie Walker Double Black for much less here than anywhere else. Worth a trip but expect to spend a lot on all the great values.

One of my fave wine and spirits stores on Long Island! I can always find whatever I’m looking for at reasonable prices. The staff is friendly and if you join their bottlevalues club, you’ll receive coupons via email from time to time. They also hold frequent tastings and advertise those via email as well.

Great store with the best prices on wine. They dont carry many brands. The owner lives in the community and cares about his patrons satisfaction. Give them a try.

Beautiful, brightly lit store with the best prices for most major brands of vodka I’ve seen on Long Island. The selection is not as much as a regular liquor store but it is by no means limited. It easily fits the description of a big box liquor store. I bought a handle of excellent polish vodka for $ 20 with a $ 10 mail in rebate! People loved it more than the Grey Goose I had out for new years eve.

Wow so chip chip chip chip

I don’t know how this place stays in business but I’m glad they are open.
This place sells wine and spirits at what might be the lowest prices allowed by law.
They dont have the largest selection but if they carry your brand, you’re gonna pay less.

If you like wine like my family does… bottle values is the place to go. I was visiting a friend in the area and passed by this great store in Bethage. It is in the middle of a shopping center and it caught my eye. I went inside and it was beautiful. Bottles of everything from floor to ceiling! The prices were amazing from $ 6 up to the really good stuff. The experienced staff helped me choose just what I needed for each occasion. I also picked up some wine glasses at a great price. The store is huge! The prices are lower than the local wine store in my area and it pays to make the trip. It’s one stop shopping. I will make the trip each time I need to restock my house.

When you have a super saver card/​membership to an establishment that sells ONLY liquor and wine, you know you have a problem.
But I proudly embrace my problem at Bottle Values. I am proud to fill up a shopping cart with various goodies. The prices are good, the selection varies but for the most part, you find what you’re looking for. Signing up for the super saver is also very simple. They scan your ID and bam, you’re enrolled.

I love this store for all of my liquor/​wine and gift needs. Their prices are unbeatable. The store is huge and everything is labled and easy to locate. They have shopping carts for easy shopping. The employees are informed, polite and eager to help you.
They have the BEST prices anywhere on the Island for liquor/​wine/​bottle openers etc.

This place is supmarket size large. They have a good selection of wine, and the Manager says that it is always adding more selections. The place is new so they still have alot of space to fill up. It has a lot of potential. They have free wine tasting a couple of times a day. Their prices are very resonable. 3 Stars for now. As the selection improves, so may the star rating.