Cornerstone Pub & Eatery

Not easy to find if you come in off of main st. Could use better signage that being said the food was good great Mac and cheese bites app great mushroom Swiss and chicken ranch sandwich we would come back again

We stopped here as out of towners, but would be regular if we were locals. Great fresh, homemade burgers, and crunchy, delicious fried foods. The room is spacious and open and family friendly. Definitely the right stop. (Service was amazing, too. Thank you, Rachel!)

Very average food that’s a bit overpriced in my opinion. This place has gotten more misses than hits with me (frequent screwed up orders in the kitchen or with the waitress, inattentive staff, etc) but if someone wants to come here to eat, I wouldn’t throw a fit.

I really like their food, basic pub fair, wings are great. The fact that they had delivery was a huge bonus, but it was or is totally unreliable. They advertise delivery, and then when you call, they say nope sorry. Plus staff was downright rude the last time I called to order.

When you want cold beer and great bar food, this is the place. The fish fry is outstanding and the burgers never disappoint. My family and I always receive great service, and while we’ve only lived here for three years, many of the staff know us by name. Give it a shot.

Always great food and best Happy Hour in town! I hade the royal burger — best I have had in a very long time.
Kids had a great time in the FunZone

It’s a sports bar with good food. The location is interesting if you park in Main Street. You will see a sign for the Cornerstone Kid’s arcade room. Don’t be fooled like us who were completely expecting a bar. You will have to enter the building to get to the pub. You will also see the Indian restaurant right next to the arcade place. They are just housed in the same building. There is more parking in the front of the building.
The atmosphere was nothing fancy. It was relaxed like other fellow Unilocalers have mentioned. You won’t have anyone to seat you. You can help yourself to whatever tables that are available. There is plenty of TV to watch a variety of games of your choice.
As for food we ordered the garlic Parmesan wings which was fantastic. It isn’t sauce-​y, but the wings were fried to perfection and generously spiced with garlic and Parmesan. I didn’t think I would like it dry, but the flavor made up for it. Next, we made good use of the Unilocal deal, buy one burger and get another one half off. We both got the royal burger and it came with bacon and egg. My only thing is the burger bun didn’t hold up to the richness of each ingredient. However, any burger with bacon and egg is a sure hit for me. The burgers came with ranch or Cajun fries. The Cajun fries are spicy, while the ranch fries are more salty. They were both good.
The service was excellent. I only saw one person working in the bar and serving food the customers. She did an awesome job though. She checked on every table every time and everyone seemed happy. I also appreciate her honoring the Unilocal deal even if she wasn’t aware of it.

I loves me some Cornerstone! These are seriously the best burgers in town. The wings special is always loved by the high school kids too which is great because it gives them a place to hang out and relax.

Great wings, relaxed atmosphere. We enjoyed live music by Mike Krug. Attentive service!

Just got sooo much better. I have visited several times since my last review and the food is still excellent and the service has been consistently better! Yay! Today is my first time back since they expanded. More seating and a game area, as well. Upgraded to five stars!

We went here with some friends after trying to go to another bar in Oconomowoc but finding out it was closed.
The experience was very disappointing. It was a pretty quiet night and it took me over 10 minutes to be served. During this time many guests who arrived after me were served before me. So, I finally was able to order and I put in an order for two beers. Big mistake. As I watched the bartender pour them I noticed that there was an unusual amount of foam in each glass (over 50% of the glass). This is a sure sign that the beer is being served warm. Not only is this bad for customers but it hurts the bar’s bottom line, too. Instead of checking the kegs and re-​pouring, the bartender just poured out the foam and kept pouring beer until the glasses were full.
Sure enough, not only was it warm, it tasted very very skunky. That was enough for us to leave and head home for the evening.
Next time we are in town I wouldn’t even consider going back. Bad service and bad beer are not a good way to do business.

This is a straight up classic Sconny bar. It also serves food, greasy, delicious bar food. There are regulars here in the afternoon, tap selection mostly serving domestics, and ESPN on loud all day. I ordered the cheese curds (underwhelming for Sconny standards) and the BLT, which was pretty darn good. The bread was toasted and buttery. There isn’t much seating outside of bar stool seating. Even many of the tables have barstools instead of regular chairs.

Was told this was a sports bar and grill. Only they had Fox crap on the TV’s (TMZ and Chef Ramsay’s Hells Kitchen) tonight. One of the customers had to request a change to playoff hockey.
The food. blah. Pizza? Tasted like a food service frozen cheese pizza that they tossed toppings on to call it «homemade.» Don’t order. There’s better pizza in the area.
Burgers? Passable. My bacon cheeseburger was missing the bacon. There’s better burgers in town.
Service was fine. All in all this is a bar with basic, ordinary bar food.

As usual, my review is limited to the fish fry, which was excellent. I had the broasted chicken/​fried fish combo, both of which were yummy! I chose the potato pancakes as a side, and they had good flavor. I still have a favorite place for potato pancakes *cough* (Nite Cap, Palmyra)*cough*, which is pretty hard to beat. The rye bread was the usual, nuthin’ special outta the bag from Pick’n Save type, coleslaw was good. No issues with service, server was attentive. Brother had standard fish fry dinner and 2 Guiness, I had a glass of cola with my dinner. Total bill– couple cents short of $ 30.
So, Rich, why not 5 stars? Not a big fan of sports bars. All the televisions with old games being played and critiqued, while the television with the news was given the right of sound so we could hear about another murder in Milwaukee.

I have to say this is one of the harder reviews I have written. I went there with my teenaged kids last Sunday afternoon. There was only about 7 people in the restaurant. We ordered burgers and wings. It took over an hour to get our food and I am not sure we would have gotten our food in that timeframe if I had not complained to our waitress/​bartender. Two men who came in and ordered 20 minutes after us received there food within 20 minutes.
What really upset me was there was no compassion and barely an apology.
I have tried 3 times to call the owner to let him know that I was not happy with the service and as of now he still has not returned my call.
The difficult part of this review is that when the food finally did come it was very good but my kids were at a point that they wanted to leave and never really had a chance to enjoy it.
A bummer how POOR service can cause someone to write a negative review on a place where the food was good.

Ok. Here it is.
This place has the best burger in Otown bar none. One of the best in Lake Country.
This place has great tap and bottled beer.
I’m upping my stars to five (not an easy achievement for any business) for a couple of reasons.
1. The burger I mentioned before has dramatically improved and consistently performed.
2. The owner of the establishment cares to not only read reviews of his restaurant, but also takes the time to both respond and adapt to his customers comments.
Kudos, Cornerstone. Best bar food in these parts for sure, and now more consistent than ever.

The Cornerstone is a nice place to meet up with friends, or grab a quick bite when you’re running around town. I’ve had their turkey reuben and it’s very good — and so much food I had to take some home in a box. Friendly wait staff, and reasonably priced.