Cookie Proper

These are hands down the best tasting «guilt free» cookies you will ever eat. I’ve had too many to count of the David White Marble cookies, which is their rendition of a cookies and cream cookie and my personal favorite.
If you are interested in ordering cookies for a party, potluck, or as a gift, the owners Lanny and Alex also do a great job catering events. I had 3 dozen cookies ordered for a small get together and the cookies were prepared promptly, and in very nice boxed and individually bagged packaging.
Keep your eyes peeled for them at various Bay Area events and buy a cookie if you see them! You won’t be disappointed.

Had the cookies at Queen & Nathan wedding 9÷26÷15 and the cookies were great. Was wondering if you made any cookies with nuts?

I was thoroughly surprised with Cookie Proper’s cookie quality. With so many «organic» «all natural» «healthy» «fortified» cookies out there in the world (especially in the bay area). I wasn’t sure another cookie company would be able to compete. I met the two awesome friendly humble guys behind cookie proper on alameda’s customer appreciation day. They gave me and my friend a taste test of each of their cookies and was already blown away. I ended buying six cookies and eating them before the end of the day!
Review for the cookies only:
Ok so I’ve only tried the cookies, but their other products looked amazing as well.
This might be silly to say, but their cookies taste like an actual COOKIE! You have to admit when you eat those «fortified» «vegan» «organic» «gluten free» cookies, you’re really not eating cookie. It’s not something that shaped like a cookie. When I want to enjoy a sweet delight, I want it eat for the taste not for the health benefits. The cookies were very well made. All cookies were soft chewy heavenly goodness. They definitely did not skim on the ingredients. Each cookie was loaded it up with chocolate, peppermint, or toffee. It was baked to perfection — soft centered, but not overcooked on the outside where you got the annoying hard crust. But the cookie held together well — so it didn’t fall apart mid-​bite. I was also told by that they use half the butter and coconut oil in their cookies to make it more sustainable. Awesome!!!
The only con I would say is that it was a bit too sweet for me. But to each his own right?
Overall:
Amazing people with an amazing product. I would definitely recommend these cookies to whoever wants an actual cookie!