Zepp’s Pizza

Should have notice the warning signs…
Ordered over the phone and arrived a couple minutes early for pickup. Gave them my name and they didn’t have my order. Kept apologizing while they acted like they knew what we ordered and who I was. They kept calling me by the wrong name the entire time. We ordered two simple large ‘deep dish’ pizzas — nothing tricky! One was a pepperoni & sausage, the second a pineapple and ham, plus an order of jojos. After waiting another twenty minutes they hand me two large boxes and a small for the jojos, thank me and again call me the wrong name. Off we go home, very hungry.
Sure enough… we get home to a plain large pizza that wasn’t fully cooked, sauce on only half of it, without any pepperoni and sausage. The second one with pineapple and ham was also half cooked with very little sauce. There was about one piece of pineapple and two bitty pieces of ham per slice, which looked like were thrown on just prior to putting the pizza into the box — not even cooked on the pizza.
These were not deep dish, they were just thick crusts. There was no edge around the pizza, it was cooked on a regular tray just like the hand tossed pizzas are. Around the outside where it was cooked was like eating a dense piece of cheese bread (as there were no toppings or sauce). The center of both was a doughy glob.
It was the most awful pizza I’ve ever had and threw both away. I don’t know what these other reviews are talking about, maybe I was there on rookie night, not sure.
At least the jojos were good!
LESSON LEARNED: ALWAYS CHECK THE PIZZA BEFORE YOU LEAVE.

This is by far, the BEST pizza, wings, Stromboli and Calzones you can find! The facility is always clean, the staff is gracious & helpful! The food quality is ALWAYS consistently WONDERFUL tasty & hot! Nice job Jon Zepp for running an outstanding local business!!!

Always good pizza. We love the deep dish and wings. The wings don’t have sauce on them so everyone can have the amount they like. The workers are almost always teenagers, but are always friendly and kind! Our favorite hometown pizza place!

Consistently good local shop Not some big chain store. Cheesy — good veggies. Crumbly sausage is not super flavorful but the ham and bacon are awesome.
Closed Sunday’s so a bummer during Football season but they run great specials everyday — especially Friday’s 2 large 1 toppings for $ 20. Check their Facebook page for the deal of the day.

First time there. Got pizza and chicken combo. Fantastic! Will most definitely be back!

Great pizza! Friendly service. A family favorite since moving to North Canton! We enjoy the hand tossed with sausage, pepperoni, and mushrooms.

Love the deep dish pizza & my husband loves their wings. Very friendly staff and the food is always great!

Our new favorite pizza shop! The pizzas and Strombolis are super fresh! The salads are plentiful and fresh too! Our family of seven loves everything we’ve had! Highly recommended! You won’t be disappointed.

Awesome sub sandwich (Italian is best) and very friendly staff. Great selection of toppings for pizza. By far the cleanest pizza place I’ve ever been to. Take out only. That’s my only complaint. Otherwise, its perfect.

Love Zepps pizza! We have never had a bad experience here. If you like sausage on your pizza, you’re in for a treat! It’s grown sausage and not those little balls of sausage which taste odd. Their chicken wings are a bit odd (fried chicken with sauces to dip into) but delicious nonetheless. They are super friendly and a great local business to support.

Their spinach feta pizza is made perfectly but I thought I’d go for something different thinking the rest of their food would be as amazing as their pizza. My kids didn’t care for their fried chicken (their coleslaw is tasty) but thought the Italian chicken sub was good. (Meat was in cubes.) The steak sub tasted okay. The large garden salad had four tomato wedges on a spring mix. I received two packets of Paul Newman’s Italian dressing. I will go back to ordering pizza from them. Maybe they had an off day?

Zepps is known for their fresh ingredients and dough that is made daily. Their wings are flavorful, crispy and come with sauce on the side. I personally love the hot wing sauce. Their bbq pizza is the absolute best I have ever eaten. The sausage pizza is the only sausage I would eat. It’s crumbly and full of flavor. I have never found any fat in the sausage. We really like Zepps food and the quality of their food.

2.5 stars.
The motto of this place is fresh, local, and handmade. These are probably all true — but that’s where it ends.
The dough for the hand tossed style was thinner than average I would say — yet still seemed to have a decent amount of uncooked dough near the cheese. It really wasn’t chewy and was absolutely flavorless.
The sauce was almost nonexistent. What little sauce was there tasted like tomato and that’s all. This pizza as a whole lacked seasoning badly.
The cheese was good — nice ratio and seemingly good quality. The toppings were fine as well, appropriate distribution and quantity.
I was kinda hoping for better here, because everyone likes the fresh/​local/​handmade type of place. They just need to make several improvements to the dough and sauce.