Extremely OK pizza. Got the buffalo chicken and it tasted pretty old too.
Whitney S.
Place rating: 5 Phoenix, AZ
Stopped in at 11:30pm. You don’t get hours like this in Phx! The pasta and pizza were very good for a hole in the wall.
Gee P.
Place rating: 5 New York, NY
one of my fav pizzeria’s in NYC — always fresh and really tasty.
Shirley Z.
Place rating: 5 Piscataway Township, NJ
Spinach calzone is excellent. Nice owner & staff too.(Didn’t take a pic — sorry)
Jacob W.
Place rating: 5 Franklin, TN
The night crew is the absolute best. They know exactly what customer service is — the food is great and the employees are just as great. I will keep going back here as long as I am in New York!
Hugh K.
Place rating: 4 Aldie, VA
Been going there for years. We stop by every time we come to New York. One of the best holes in the wall in NYC. Great plain cheese slices.
Maggie L.
Place rating: 5 Portland, OR
This is the best pizza that I have ever eaten and I usually don’t like pizza. The crust was crispy all the toppings were huge and the sauce was tasty. I got the pepperoni with mushroom. I love how their service line moves along so quickly and they have a process down on the line. Every since coming back to Oregon, I have been missing their pizza. I regret not trying their meatball and lasagne.
Brick W.
Place rating: 3 Downtown, San Diego, CA
This place was quaint and had a small business feel to it. This is what I like in a place like this. Just had a slice of pizza and moved on. The pizza was good and fair priced. I was happy that the red pepper and parmesan cheese shakers worked well and I didn’t have to unscrew the lids to get to the pepper or cheese.
Kristina L.
Place rating: 5 Portland, OR
This place is awesome — I placed the order through Seamless. I wanted half/half pizza, but when I got my order — it wasn’t what I originally requested. I called to let them know about the mistake and they were extremely nice. Without even me asking for it, they promised to have the right pizza on the way asap. I got it in less than 30 min. Even though they didn’t got the order right the first time, I’m still giving them 5 stars with 100% confidence — they corrected their mistake(and part of it is the fact that the app doesn’t allow to specify if you want half/half pizza, and you are only able to leave a special request for that), they even gave me two free drinks with the corrected order(I didn’t ask for that either), also the prices are really good… but most importantly the two different kinds of pizza I tried were both DELICIOUS!
Omar R.
Place rating: 5 Moncton, Canada
Best pizza made by human hands, period. Go try it for yourself. Great cheese, not too much sauce. I just had my first piece in twenty years, same taste, heavenly.
Nikki M.
Place rating: 5 Webster, TX
After trying a few pizza places while we were in NY, this one was my favorite. We stopped in after visiting the memorial and before going up One World Trade. I got the veggie pizza with tomatoes, onions, broccoli and a few other toppings and it was sooo yummy. The crust was the best part! It was just thin enough and still really crisp. The place is rather tiny and fits maaaybe 10 people so you might want to consider just getting it to go. Also, dont mistake the salt on the tables for cheese! We almost made that mistake. I wish we had places that serve this deliciousness in Houston!
Crazy Bernie S.
Place rating: 4 Prather, CA
I’m giving it 4 stars which is generous. Pizza tastes good and the place is just a stand there like a chooch and shovel it in joint. 2 tiny tables with a couple of chairs. This place is on the street leading away from ground zero and the Majestic can be seen in many video shots of the people running away from the dust cloud on 9⁄11. It’s part of our history and the fact that they survived that day makes this place a piece of American history and a symbol of our resilience.
Bryan M.
Place rating: 3 Brooklyn, NY
Strangely(majestically?) a slight step above the dolla slices elsewhere. Cheese slice $ 2.5, fill the void and brag that you’ve had a slice of New York Pizza, in New York City, d-oh.
Chris N.
Place rating: 5 Newtonville, MA
In town again for a tournament. Checked in to the hotel and walked over to the World Trade Center site. We saw Majestic and stopped in for a quick bite. Fast, friendly service! The pizza was very good as well as the pasta. Garlic knots were wicked garlicky. Would definitely visit Majestic again.
Anthony L.
Place rating: 4 Rotterdam, NY
Pizza is good. People were nice. Small little place but cool. Went here twice on business trip to nyc and enjoyed both times. Garlic knots. 3/$ 1. They were awesome too. Only reason they lost a star was because soda is $ 2 for«large» fountain drink which I know everyone charges that. Just too much.
Chris D.
Place rating: 4 Financial District, NY
Just as much as I love good food, I love good service. That’s exactly what I got at Majestic. After missing a Seamless delivery from Majestic on a late Friday evening(my phone didn’t ring, I feel asleep, I felt terrible), I called the next day to see if anything could be done. I wasn’t sure what to expect — if anything at all, since it was pretty much my fault I missed the delivery. However imagine my surprise and delight when they offered to send me my exact order again, on the house! I made sure I kept my eyes open, answered the phone, opened the door, received the pizza(tipped extra… be kind to your delivery people!) and marveled at the enormity of my large veggie pizza with extra cheese. It was great pizza, too. Needless to say I wholeheartedly recommend Majestic for pizza in FiDi.
Stuart B.
Place rating: 3 New York, NY
Serviceable pizza parlor with minimal seating. Prices are standard. They use a tad too much sauce, but it was acceptable. Definitely a step above the $ 1 slice joints.
Meghan W.
Place rating: 5 West Covina, CA
Randomly walked into this place when coming from the 9⁄11 memorial. A typical pizza joint, hardly any space to stand but WOW that pizza was amazing. The perfect amount of sauce, cheese and grease. I tried many other places near Times Square(where i was staying) throughout my trip and nothing compared to this place. Wishing I made a special trip down there for one more slice. Best pizza in NY!
Jennifer A.
Place rating: 5 Maple Shade Township, NJ
Found this place in my way back from the 9⁄11 memorial. It’s kinda like a hole in the wall quick bite type of place. I loved it and the pizza was amazing. Nothing fancy, just great authentic New York pizza. It’s not even a expensive. Just a couple dollars for a slice. I plan on making another trip to the city just for another slice.
Hannah C.
Place rating: 4 Astoria, NY
This is the epitome of an NYC pizza joint — it’s small, tiny, barely any space to stand when it gets crowded, and just when you think it can’t get any worse, the pizza maker stands 3 feet high on this platform because there is no space for him and the oven on regular ground. Definitely one of my favorite pizza joints in the area!