Anthony’s Deli

New Windsor, United States

4.6

13 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 845-569-8707
Address:
287 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY, 12553
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
No
Attire
Casual
Noise Level
Quiet
Alcohol
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Has TV
No
Waiter Service
Yes
Caters
Yes

Today

Today –
Local time (New Windsor) 14:34 Friday, 30 May 2025

Business hours

Monday –
Tuesday –
Wednesday –
Thursday –
Friday –
Saturday –
Sunday –

Related places

You might also consider:
1
mi
Newburgh Pork Store
327 Windsor Hwy
1
mi
Mama Theresa’s Italian Specialties
357 Old Forge Hill Rd
1.1
mi
Midway Deli and Market
264 Quassaick Ave
1.3
mi
Manhattan Deli
2424 State Rt 32
1.6
mi
V & S Deli
11 Riley Rd
1.7
mi
C And L Deli
5328 Route 9W

Nearby

Browse nearby places:
90
ft
Cilantro Tapas & Bar
287 Windsor Hwy Ste 100
220
ft
The Flag Guys
283 Windsor Hwy
240
ft
Margherita’s Hair Zone
293 Windsor Hwy
290
ft
Kuprych Steve Remodeling
279 Windsor Hwy
370
ft
Venera J Martinisi, DVM
Blomngrve Tpke
480
ft
Toppings Frozen Yogurt
287 Windsor Hwy Ste 300

13 reviews of Anthony’s Deli

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Colorado Springs, CO
Had lunch here and man this is exactly why I couldn’t wait to live on the east coast. Bomb Sammies and the salad was perfect. Bread was on point and the staff was very friendly. Every drink choice you can think of in a bottle. Really great chip brands and parking lot is big. Will be back every chance I get.
Place rating: 5
New York, NY
My favorite deli– here are a few of my favorite things:
Mozzarella balls
lemon Chicken
Homemade ham
Macaroni Salad
Maryanne & Anthony!
The food is consistent and the service is always on point!
Place rating: 1
New Windsor, NY
Hero sandwich made with three week old bread! Hard as a rock! Coleslaw, they say wasn’t out of prepackaged bucket, tasted like sugar water packed shredded cabbage. ZERO onion, salt, pepper, etc… disgusting. Sandwich made shoved full of lettuce, tomato first, meat was an afterthought on top. Horrible. DONT BOTHER!!! Not a deli AT ALL. Might as well go to subway — and that’s pathetic.
Place rating: 5
Harrisburg, PA
Happened to be in the general area at lunch time and pulled up «Yelp» to see what local recommendations there where. Was about to grab a pizza slice at another place a few miles away and saw these reviews for Anthony’s Deli…
Drove the few miles and I’m glad I did…
Ordered the Big Boy per a few recommendations from fellow Unilocalers. WOW… Absolutely delicious…
One of the best sandwiches I have had in a very long time and I’m a road warrior so I eat lunch on the road 5 days a week…
Fresh bread with fresh and delicious ingredients can mean only one thing… a delicious sandwich…
I will definetly stop here again if I’m anywhere in the area… AAAA+++++
Place rating: 5
New Windsor, NY
They have catered several events for me and the food is ALWAYS raved about! They delivered everything on time and set up the chafing dishes for me. Great food, service above and beyond
Place rating: 5
Newburgh, NY
I try to come once a week. This place is amazing!
Although I have only tried several sandwhiches, one I have to recommend is the Big boy!
Plan some time ahead if you’re going to stop by during lunch hours because it does get busy. Well worth the wait!
Staff are very friendly and welcoming.
Place rating: 5
New Windsor, NY
Ordered a ham&cheese omelet, toast with butter. Omelet was big and delicious. And the price with a small coffee was less than 7 $. The owner and staff were friendly and welcoming.
Place rating: 5
Lakeside, CA
Absolutely fabulous food. I come from San Diego to visit family and make sure I eat here every time I come. The hot food is awesome and the sandwiches are perfect. I can’t say enough praise!
Place rating: 5
Beacon, NY
If you need a sub and don’t mind waiting a few minutes, this is the pace to go. Try any of the marinated chicken subs.
Place rating: 5
New Windsor, NY
Catered some trays of hot food from Anthony’s for Christmas. Was a bit skeptical, as I always do my own cooking. I must admit that everything was delicious. The Chicken Franchaise and the Pasta Maria were especially yummy! Wouldn’t hesitate to order from them again.
Place rating: 5
New Windsor, NY
BEST! Sandwiches, warm food, pastas, salads– all delish. We had them cater our backyard wedding party last year and everyone loved the food as much as we do. Love Anthony’s!
Place rating: 4
Haskell, NJ
Great Deli! Try the «Big Boy» sub which is marinated chicken + bacon. The bread is soft and fresh. They also have a selection of Italian goodies. The lasagna is pretty good.
Place rating: 5
Manhattan, NY
If you are looking for a «real» deli, then look no further. This place is just what I’ve been looking for in suburbia! They have a nice display of condiments including hot sandwich ingredients such as meatballs, chicken, etc. Everything looks amazingly fresh and it even tasted fresh in my sub.
They have limited seating so you can enjoy your meal there or just take it to go. This place is a straight up deli so don’t expect it to look and feel like a fast food joint.