The Mill- Scozzaro’s Restaurant & Pub

Not someplace I would return. The service was extremely slow and inattentive. French onion soup was very sweet. The bbq sauce for the pulled pork sub and wrap was also very sweet. The southwestern pork soup of the day lacked flavor. However the crab soup was tasty as were the mussels in saffron broth.

Love this place. They have classic pub fare as well as a couple more refined special entrees if you desire. Great craft beer selection as well.

Great sports bar with a pool table, darts and plenty of tv’s. Really good craft beer selection and knowledgable bar tenders. Food is great must get the maryland crab soup every time I’m in there. Also hints of being a Pittsburgh bar with a name and colors like that as well as a few steelers penguins pirate pics and signs on the wall.

Went to the mill to watch steeler game. Thoroughly enjoyed our experience. Tried the wings and crab dip. Both were worthy of having again service was excellent. Will definitely come back

Great-​priced drafts, to-​die-​for crab dip, and tasty hot wings! Will be back for sure!

Since the car show was in Carlisle we decided to head out of town for dinner. My son has passed this place a few times so we decided to give it a try.
I was surprised. It’s a bar/​restaurant with plenty of tables to be seated at. The décor was that of any bar/​restaurant. We were seated at a table and went through the menu. A lot of choices to pick from. I decided on the dinner special, lasagna.
My choice turned out to be the right on. It was quite good. I normally don’t order pasta out since most pastas are overcooked or undercooked. This was spot on.
I would return here again.

Have always had excellent food. The chef’s prepare something special on Fri/​Sat nights, always outstanding. Plenty of beers on tap. Casual bar atmosphere, friendly people.

Highly recommended local joint. The service is awesome and friendly, the food is very good, and the drinks are well made. I would give 5 stars, but I really felt walloped in the bank account when I looked at the prices in the menu. They are overall, too high, for my regular tastes. And that stops me as a local patronizing this local establishment as often as I would like. The friendliness, professionalism and relaxed vibe brings me back for more drinks, but I would have to really think twice about eating/​ordering off their menu — I just don’t have that kind of disposable income.

Great food; lackluster service.
Having been here many many times in the past 3 years, I can say that the food is consistently tasty and the service is consistently lackluster. However, I have had good service here on several occasions, namely during lunch hour and early dinner.
Later at night is when things start to deteriorate. Have had wrong orders, wrong tabs, wrong amount of beers charged, forgotten sides, inattentive waitstaff, and they don’t bring change when you pay in cash. WTF
Food-​wise, try their wings, burgers, chicken sandwiches, and sweet potato fries. Never had a bad dish and the food is cooked nicely, seasoned well, and is better than expected. Plenty of beers on tap including craft and micros, music trivia on Thursday nights, and a good bar scene on Friday nights. Pool table, darts, and an outside deck with live music in the summer and early fall.
Ambience inside is so-​so but the food makes up for it.

Friday night date night, so I planned dinner and then to a bar with live music. The 1^st place a brew pub in Gettysburg had a 45 min wait so we kept on down the road and stopped at Scozzaro’s. I was glad we did! Had friendly attentive wait staff seat us and our waiter Logan was there in a snap and took our drink orders. Great beer selection caught my eye, proudly displayed in the dining area and I had to pause and reflect which beer was I going to have. That is usually not the case in the vast majority of restaurants in our neck of the woods. My wife the Had an unsweetened ice tea which I had a rye ipa both were very good. We both ordered off the specialties menu, she had a Kobe beef burger /​fries, and I had a grilled sausage «bruschetta» /​mashed potatoes. The atmosphere was good the food was even better! The time for our order to the the food hitting the table was too long. My wife mentioned to me she was well into her 2^nd tea and a table seated after us was severed before us. Not a big deal for me but if I was the server I would have asked if I could do something brought out bread or something. The portions were generous and spot on temperature wise, which given the slight delay coming out was good!

We decided to be spontaneous and follow 3 very good looking vehicles in York PA. We thought they would be going to some sort of car show. However after 30 min of following them one split off and we came to the conclusion they weren’t together. I decided to make a 45 min time limit when the 45 min were up we happened to drive by this place. There must have been some wine tasting going on but it had tents music and looked fun so we stopped. AMAZING FOOD; great drinks live entertainment. Good crowd. Fun place to hang out. So happy we found this place by chance.

The lovely and I have been here twice in the last 2 weeks. Both times the food and service were great. The first visit I had the wild boar tacos (they have a wild game selection or two on the special menu that rotate). The lovely had the stuffed shells and they were very good as well. We shared some of the best onion rings as an appetizer. They have a nice selection of drafts and rotate a number frequently, They also have a nice selection of cocktails. Our second visit I had a tasty Ruben and the lovely had a burger. Our app were big plump steamed shrimp. If you are going to Gettysburg this summer, this place is just 10 miles east on Rt. 30 and worth the drive. They also have a huge deck with live entertainment too.

What a pleasant surprise this was! Being a hard-​core Baltimore Ravens fan I was a little hesitant upon entering and seeing all of the Steelers memorabilia on the walls. However the guy who greeted and seated us admitted that he was a true ravens fan and not to worry that everyone was friendly there. He was right. The food that our table ordered was out of this world! Being a sports bar type establishment we were expecting the typical pub food items. We were pleasantly surprised to find fresh baked bread brought to the table and the entrées we ordered were as if they were coming out a professionally prepared culinary kitchen. Excellent is truly the only word to describe the amount, quality and taste of the food. If you happen by this local gem on route 30 heading from or to York from Gettysburg it is a must stop!

Great food, we had the grilled Old Bay wings, chicken Alfredo pasta dish and the trio grilled salad. Delicious food, we found the wings to be very meaty and tender, generous portions, friendly bartender, no reverse happy hour or drink specials or food specials, unattentive waitstaff. They advertise that they stop serving food at 11pm and we got there at 10pm and they said we had to go to the bar. The music was a little loud but the bar crowd was entertaining to watch.

Food is always good. If you are a Steelers fan it is a great place to go on game day but get there early to get a seat. Love eating on the deck in summer. When we get guests coming into the area we like to take them to Scozzaro’s. When our guests come for another visit they ask to go there.

Went for the 1^st and only time after work must have driven past the place atleast 50 times before. I have had their food at a few catered events and it was always good. I went the bar it was fairly crowded. The drink specials were weak. They did have good beer selections but you will pay for them. The sign in front advertising large, award wining wings. There were 3 ways to order, breaded, naked or grilled. I ordered them hot, wet and grilled. First they were served on a plate with very nice presentation. There was a steelers bowl for the bones (an immediate turn off, I know they were picked to the bones by the ravens that week?) The wings were average size, not very wet, rubbery, the skin showed grill marks but was soggy and loose obviously not grilled to perfection. They were surprisingly tastey, not too spicy expected more heat. I was not given fast service, kind of felt ignored by the one bartender. I’m 6’4″ 240 hard to miss, the other bartender younger was able to be waved over, to take my order. I was surprised to a trivia game on the tv. So I asked for and played it till my wings were done (this was nice because it was a distraction from the music people selected on the jukebox almost as bad as karaōke). Willing to try again.