Sweetart Bakery Cafe

3 stars because I wasn’t impressed with a cake I bought. Usually I go to buttercooky for all cakes and pastries but decided to check out this bakery instead because of all the great reviews. We stopped in to pick up dessert for Easter and got a vanilla cake. The cake was pricy, priced about the same as buttercooky but not as delicious. It was very plain and not worth the price.

Great service, super nice people working there. The breakfast sandwiches we had were great and they have some of the best cake pops I’ve ever had… Love the pistachio cake pop! Gonna go back and try something new very soon!

This is a great little café. My wife and I stopped by on our way to the cinema for a coffee and pastries. The service was fantastic, and both the coffee and pastries were quite tasty. We’d recommend this place to anyone.

I have an itinerant lifestyle. I’ve lived in many different countries and places and never have I found a place that I can call my home base. I work at a busy inner city hospital and even after an arduous night shift in which the only thought that will assuage my nerves is to sleep I will always stop by here. They have everything you need. It isn’t just a café it is more of an alcove of intellectual conversations, friendly faces, artisan tea, and some of the best tasting food and desserts I have ever had. I hope this place is long present after I leave NY state for many people to enjoy because I have thoroughly enjoyed it and will continue to!

I needed a cake at the last minute for my son’s birthday celebration on a Saturday and was in a bind since he wanted a themed cake. I sent an email to Sweetart on Monday and received a response immediately that they can do the cake. I had some design changes and did not finalize until Wed and they were very flexible with me. I picked up the cake on Saturday morning and it looked great!
Next time i’ll be sure to try their other pastries.

Only the highest of praise for this bakery! I had ordered a custom cake for a bridal shower I was hosting. 15 minutes before I was about to pick it up, Peter called to tell me he was having an issue with the cake. He said he was trying to reach the decorators to have them come back to fix it. I told him the shower was starting in an hour and a half. I said if you can fix it by 1pm or 2pm then it would be ok. He asked where the party was and said he would deliver it. He arrived in time with the cake. He told me he wasn’t happy with the original cake which was in buttercream. He had the decorators change it to fondant. The cake was beautiful!!! The bride to be realized that the design was her invitation and loved it. Peter definitely takes pride in his work and will never send out anything that is subpar! I will be using Sweetart for any future cakes that I need custom made!

Very cute place. The owners were very accommodating and even gave us some free pastries to try! Will definitely be returning!

Thank you again Pete for making a beautiful birthday cake for our daughters first birthday, I wish I could post a picture of it here, but I can not seem to figure it out, any way keep up the good work.

I have been going sweet tart for last months. My favorite is Baklava. I tried baklava in lot different places and cities. Sweet tart baklava is very fresh, yummy and I love extra sweet sauce with baklava.
One thing I don’t like about this shop is, shop is closed after business hours (after 6 PM) some days when I crave above baklava.

i really like it here. i came a little before closing time, and i felt bad because the owner was about to leave, but she was very gracious and patient with me. When I ordered the spinach pie, she didn’t just hand it to me, she also gave me special heating instructions before eating it so I’d get the best results. Just something I appreciated as a customer!
The bakery itself was very cozy and inviting. And I just discovered that they make sandwiches and wraps! At an affordable price! I look forward to coming back :)

Very nice bakery. Owner is a real nice guy too.

I ordered my husband’s 30^th superhero birthday cake from this place which I found on Unilocal and couldn’t have been more pleased. No only did the cake look exactly like the photo I emailed them, the red velvet cake was delicious. They responded to all my emails right away, they were very pleasant and have become my go to place for cakes!!!

I was so glad when this place opened, should have posted a review sooner. Cozy and charming, the staff and owner are always friendly, making this a great neighborhood spot. Everything I’ve had is delicious– the Greek cookies, the spinach pie, and my fave, the croissants. I can’t walk past without stopping in and grabbing a little something. And right by the train makes it an easy stop before work.

Sweetart Bakery made my husband such an amazing cake for his 30^th birthday!!! They were easy to coordinate with and very responsive to all my emails and calls. They made the cake to my exact specifications and it couldn’t have turned out any better. I didn’t want to eat this work of art but I’m glad I did because it tasted even better than it looked. I wouldn’t definitely use Sweetart Bakery again! Thank you so much!

Red velvet cake is to die for! Love this place, my new go to spot

Great Food. Reasonable Prices. Owners are sweet. Highly recommended.

Really cute place with homemade pastries. They have a full menu but I go there for the sweets. I’ve had their cupcakes and they’re delicious! The owners are really nice and cater to you!

I can’t believe this quaint little bakery has been open for 15 months and I’m just now having lunch here. The café is small and very cozy. There are few small tables for two. The display cases are teeming with delicious looking pastries and cakes and they have a nice looking espresso machine.
Our lunch experience had a few bumps, but the food was so good that I would still recommend SweeTart to friends. Hubby ordered the «The Pesto» wrap ($ 7.95) but they served it on crusty baguette bread instead of the wrap. He had a toothache so he was not happy about this. I had ordered the BLT wrap, which did not have a description on the menu. I assumed it would be bacon, lettuce, and tomato – but was pleasantly surprised to find that there was also chopped grilled chicken and fresh mozzarella in there. It was delicious and such a good value at $ 4.95. I felt bad for my husband, so I gave him half of my wrap and ate half of his sandwich. His was delicious too – grilled chicken pieces with roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, and pesto aioli.
Everything tasted fresh, so we decided to try the coffee. Hubs had a 16oz triple shot latte ($ 4) and I ordered a 16oz café au lait. The gentleman behind the counter did not know what a café au lait was, so the lady at the register offered to help him. She did not seem to know what café au lait was either because she made it with one shot of espresso, hot water, and a bit of steamed milk – in a 12oz cup. For the record, café au lait is regular brewed coffee topped with steamed milk. My drink was watery and weak and my husband’s tasted like the espresso shots were pulling for too long. We didn’t complain or correct any of the mistakes, but it did make us feel like they weren’t listening to us when we ordered – and also need some barista training.
Like I said, the food was good, and the staff was nice enough, so we will try again and see what happens. I am very interested in trying the pastries next. The baklava looked mouthwateringly good.

It’s an ok place, many of the baked goods aren’t made there which was surprising and weird
I had iced coffee and it was burnt brewed and bitter… I couldn’t drink it so went to throw it away and the lady made me another one which was nice if her but it was still the same burnt coffee
The croissant we had was (thank goodness) baked in the premises and was decent nothing really amazing
Cute place but will not be coming back

Service is very friendly. I ordered two iced coffees and two small Napoleons.
The iced coffees were $ 2.25 and did not have an edge to them. However there was too much half-​and-​half added to it.
The Napoleons were different. Not bad but not your typical one. The filo was not crispy and flakey so that was disappointing. The custard is not the same filling used at most bakeries. Overall its good but not great. Their Greek pastries are probably better.