Baldy’s is very hit or miss. It has many pros with a couple of cons. You have to love the fact that is the only delivery service in Murray that you can get pizzas, calzones, sandwiches, pastas, burgers, chicken tenders, and more. They deliver later than most pizza joints and are typically very fast. They have a very random menu and I feel they’d do better if they found their niche they wanted to be in and stuck to it. The food is greasy and unhealthy but it hits the spot on late night. The food quality all depends on who is in the kitchen, sometimes you’ll get a beautifully assembled meal other times it may just be hastily thrown together. The food is extremely cheap and you can get great deals on 3 or more pizzas. The calzones are massive and can easily be two meals. The greatest kept secrets of Baldy’s is the grilled Cajun Chicken Sandwich with Cheese!
Justin S.
Place rating: 4 South Bend, IN
Calzones are delicious. Large in size. They deliver until 1am. Prices are reasonable. I have not tried the pizza in a long time but I love the calzones. Whenever I’m in town this is my go to choice.
Nicole U.
Place rating: 2 Paducah, KY
Ordered several times and the food has been hit or miss. But, they deliver and the prices are pretty reasonable. Tonight, I ordered manicotti. I took two bites and found it hard to chew. I flipped over one of my noodles and saw it was dried out, burnt, and had strange brown blobs on it. It looked almost like a bone. It’ll be a while before I order from them again.
Genna F.
Place rating: 3 Murray, KY
Food is edible. Definitely not gourmet, but can’t complain when they’re the only restaurant in town that delivers more than pizza!
Khaled A.
Place rating: 4 Kent, OH
They have great kabob. However, I tried their mansaf it was awful. I think they should be specified in what they can cook
